How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A non-invertible direct sum in Vec_Z2
Example
Let with addition modulo . Let be the category of finite-dimensional complex -graded vector spaces , with grade-preserving linear maps and tensor product Its tensor unit is in grade ; write in grade . The simple objects are , with . The object satisfies For any , its left and right duals are the graded vector space with . The left evaluation and coevaluation have types and , with and . The right evaluation and coevaluation have types and , with and , where is a basis of and its dual basis, placed in grade of . Evaluations vanish on homogeneous pairs whose degrees do not sum to . The canonical associator is vector-space rebracketing. These formulas give both dual orientations; has itself as both duals with identity maps.
Thus is non-invertible although each of its two simple summands is tensor-invertible. The object is reducible; this example does not assert the existence of a non-invertible simple object or a physical defect realization.
Example references
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The finite group under addition modulo and finite-dimensional complex graded vector spaces.
Finite semisimple fusion data for non-invertible defects: a finite semisimple fusion category is a finite semisimple rigid monoidal category with bilinear tensor product and simple unit; rigidity requires both left and right duals with evaluation and coevaluation maps of the displayed orientations satisfying both snake identities. An object is tensor-invertible only if it has a two-sided tensor inverse.
Verification
Every graded vector space is the direct sum of its two finite-dimensional homogeneous components, each of which is a finite direct sum of one-dimensional graded lines. Thus the category is semisimple with exactly two simple isomorphism classes, represented by and ; its Hom spaces are finite-dimensional and its kernels and cokernels inherit the grading. The displayed tensor product is bilinear and has unit . Its associator is the ordinary vector-space rebracketing map, which preserves degree; the two pentagon composites send every pure tensor to the same rebracketed tensor, and the unit triangle follows from the canonical identifications with and . The unit is simple.
The four dual maps displayed in the Example preserve degree: each evaluation pairs only a component of degree with its dual component of degree , and each coevaluation is a sum of tensors of total degree . With the vector-space associator and unit identifications, the two left snake composites act by and . The two right snake composites act by the same contractions, with evaluation and coevaluation in the reversed map orientations: and . Thus every object has both left and right duals, and the category has the fusion properties in [F1].
Distributing the tensor product over direct sums gives since .
Any object has the form for nonnegative integers . Hence If this is the zero object; if it has a nonzero grade- summand. In neither case is it isomorphic to the unit . Therefore has no right tensor inverse and is non-invertible by [F1], while and each have themselves as two-sided inverses.