How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Two declared linear models worked through: the harmonic flow has zero finite-time growth in every direction, while the repulsive linear model has exact rates and the positive Lyapunov exponent at its equilibrium
A declared-data check of two physical one-label Cartesian force models with m0=1 kg, ell0=1 m and t0=1 s: F_1,phys=-(m0/t0^2)X and F_2,phys=(m0/t0^2)X, in newtons. The formulas use normalized q=X/ell0, v=t0 V/ell0 and t=T/t0, mass 1 and potentials U_1(q)=||q||^2/2 and U_2(q)=-||q||^2/2 with energy reference E0=m0 ell0^2/t0^2. In this numerical state metric the harmonic derivative is orthogonal, so all finite-time rates and Lyapunov exponents are zero; the repulsive derivative has exact rates plus and minus 1 along its eigendirections, with positive exponent 1 at equilibrium. The corresponding physical rates divide by t0. All data are declared, with no measurement and no claim of chaos.
Example
Declared model data and normalization. Take one label with and declare physical reference data , , . For , define physical force maps by , with in seconds, in metres, in metres per second, and outputs in newtons. These are smooth globally state-Lipschitz force maps of Adopted force model: force maps, the equation of motion, additive composition of force contributions and frame covariance with physical mass . Put , , and . Then becomes , with , since . The normalized force maps are , with normalized mass . The physical potentials are ; normalizing their energies by gives, in the constant-metric chart with , they have the potentials and of The mechanical first-order field, Lagrangian and energy of a configuration-dependent kinetic metric in a chart. The associated fields and complete motion maps are listed below; denote the coordinate basis, explicitly for and otherwise, for and . All state and tangent norms below apply to the dimensionless numerical coordinates .
- The harmonic model has field and motion map
- The repulsive linear model has field and motion map
For a state and a nonzero tangent vector with , the finite-time tangent growth rate is ; when the forward lifetime is unbounded and its finite limit as exists, that limit is the Lyapunov exponent (Finite-time tangent growth rates and Lyapunov exponents of the model's flow: the rate per unit time of a transported deviation, with its existence convention and its limits clauses (i)-(ii)). Both displayed flows are complete, so this lifetime condition holds for each state.
Assertions to check. (i) Both displayed maps are the local flows of their fields; (ii) for the harmonic model is the orthogonal block rotation so every finite-time tangent growth rate vanishes and every existing Lyapunov exponent is ; (iii) for the repulsive model the rates along the directions and are and , so the Lyapunov exponent of the equilibrium along the unstable eigenvector is .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: the two force maps and their equivalent chart data with , the displayed candidate flows and the finite-time growth-rate definition of Finite-time tangent growth rates and Lyapunov exponents of a C¹ flow as recorded in Finite-time tangent growth rates and Lyapunov exponents of the model's flow: the rate per unit time of a transported deviation, with its existence convention and its limits.
Uniqueness of force-model motions (Local existence and uniqueness for the Newtonian initial-value problem, with the quantitative Picard-Lindelöf cylinder): for the adopted physical force maps, every initial datum has a unique maximal model motion; consequently a globally defined curve that solves the equation with the given initial data is the model's maximal motion. The invertible state and time normalization transfers this uniqueness and maximality to the numerical systems.
calculus (The exponential function is smooth and , The chain rule, in one line from Carathéodory: if is differentiable at and is differentiable at , then is differentiable at with , Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: , , , and when , The derivatives of sine and cosine are cosine and minus sine, The natural logarithm as the inverse of the exponential function, The Euclidean inner product on ): the exponential and trigonometric functions have their standard derivatives, sums and constant multiples differentiate termwise, and is the natural logarithm, so that for real .
Pythagorean identity (Parity and the Pythagorean identity for sine and cosine): for every real , .
Verification
The two fields: for the constant metric the mechanical field of The mechanical first-order field, Lagrangian and energy of a configuration-dependent kinetic metric in a chart is , giving and . These are also the normalized force-model fields of the declared physical .
Harmonic flow: differentiating the displayed with respect to by [L2] gives ; at the map is the identity. By [L1] the displayed map is the force model's maximal flow.
Repulsive flow: differentiating the displayed gives and ; at the map is the identity, so by [L1] it is the force model's maximal flow of .
Harmonic growth rates: is linear in , with derivative writing , , its transpose times itself has diagonal blocks by [L3] and off-diagonal blocks , so it is orthogonal, whence for every . The explicit flow exists for every real time, so the forward lifetime is unbounded, as required by the exponent definition. Therefore for every , and the limit defining the Lyapunov exponent exists and equals ; the variational equation of Linearisation along a motion of the mechanical model: the flow derivative solves the variational equation, with Lipschitz dependence, the constant-metric second-order form, and the conditional finite-time error bound of the linear approximation is satisfied by this derivative matrix, whose columns solve by step 2.1.
Repulsive growth rates: for an initial tangent vector put and . The derivative flow satisfies and . For each , input gives output and rate , while input gives output and rate . The explicit flow exists for every real time, so the lifetime hypothesis holds and these Lyapunov exponents exist. At the equilibrium this gives a positive exponent along each unstable coordinate eigenvector.
Scope check: the chain rule transfers each numerical motion to satisfying its physical Newton equation. A rate per numerical time becomes per physical time ; thus the physical rates are and , and the positive physical exponent is . All steps substitute declared normalized data into the chart formulas and the finite-time-rate definition; no step produces a chaotic invariant set, a mixing property or a measurement, and the positive exponent of step 3.2 concerns the linear model at its equilibrium, as the page's counterexample discusses.
Remarks
-
What is genuinely checked. The example verifies that the variational equation holds with the displayed derivative matrices and that the growth rate is invariant under multiplication of the deviation by nonzero scalars (the logarithm of a positive factor cancels against the norm ratio), so the rate is a function of the direction, not of the length of . Both flows are complete on the declared chart; no domain-escape phenomenon occurs.
-
The unstable direction. For the repulsive model the directions and are exactly the eigendirections of , with eigenvalues and , respectively, so the rates are the eigenvalues of the linearisation, in agreement with Hyperbolic linearisation of an equilibrium of the model: exponential dichotomy of the linearised flow, local exponential asymptotic stability in the stable case, and instability in the saddle case clause 1 with .
Depends on
Adopted force model: force maps, the equation of motion, additive composition of force contributions and frame covariance
The model vocabulary of stability and chaos: the associated flow of a declared force model, equilibria, periodic and homoclinic orbits, and invariant sets
Finite-time tangent growth rates and Lyapunov exponents of the model's flow: the rate per unit time of a transported deviation, with its existence convention and its limits
Linearisation along a motion of the mechanical model: the flow derivative solves the variational equation, with Lipschitz dependence, the constant-metric second-order form, and the conditional finite-time error bound of the linear approximation
Local existence and uniqueness for the Newtonian initial-value problem, with the quantitative Picard-Lindelöf cylinder
Finite-time tangent growth rates and Lyapunov exponents of a C¹ flow
The mechanical first-order field, Lagrangian and energy of a configuration-dependent kinetic metric in a chart
The exponential function is smooth and
The chain rule, in one line from Carathéodory: if is differentiable at and is differentiable at , then is differentiable at with
Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: , , , and when
The derivatives of sine and cosine are cosine and minus sine
Parity and the Pythagorean identity for sine and cosine
The Euclidean inner product on
The natural logarithm as the inverse of the exponential function
Dimensions and SI unit conventions of the non-relativistic classical mechanics framework
Dependency tree · 2 levels
Sources
- Iain Stewart, Advanced Classical Mechanics (MIT 8.09/8.309, Fall 2014), §7.3.1 pp. 164-170: linear fixed-point equations and their exponential solutions; the exact six-dimensional model computations are proved locally
- Iain Stewart, Advanced Classical Mechanics (MIT 8.09/8.309, Fall 2014), §7.6.1 pp. 189-191: contextual discussion of Lyapunov exponents; the distinction between a positive equilibrium exponent and chaos in the stated sense is established locally
- Konstantin Likharev, Essential Graduate Physics: Classical Mechanics (title page last edited September 1, 2026), §5.1, equations (5.2)-(5.3): the linear harmonic equation and its sine/cosine solution; the repulsive model and tangent-rate calculations are supplied locally