Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: AI-generatedProof: AI-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The empty-object ribbon component and its braid relations

Statement

Let (A,S) be a finite-rank spherical Artin system, so its associated Coxeter group W is finite, and let A+ be its positive monoid. For I⊆S, let AI+ be the standard parabolic submonoid generated by I and let ΔI be its standard Garside element, the positive lift of the longest element of WI; in particular Δ∅=1 and Δ{a}=a.

Use the ribbon category with objects I⊆S and arrows (I,g,J) satisfying g−1Ig=J, with g∈A+ for positive arrows and g∈A for groupoid arrows. Equality requires equal endpoints and equal labels; composition is (I,g,J)(J,h,K)=(I,gh,K). For a∈S∖I, the reduced generator has label ν(I,a)=ΔI−1ΔI∪{a} and target ν(I,a)−1Iν(I,a). The reduced positive category and reduced groupoid are the subcategory and subgroupoid generated by these arrows.

At I=∅, every reduced generator is the loop labelled a. This object is an isolated component: its reduced positive component is the one-object monoid A+, and its reduced groupoid component is the one-object group A. For distinct a,b∈S, the lcm for left divisibility has exactly its two alternating braid paths of length mab, and these braid equalities present this component as a groupoid.

Facts & Assumptions

[F1]

The positive monoid embeds in its Artin group and both have their standard braid presentations. (Independent spherical Artin Garside input)

[F2]

Groupoid arrows retain their endpoints and composition is read from left to right. (Set-sized groupoids, functors and composition conversion)

[F3]

The lcm of distinct positive generators has exactly the two alternating length-m representatives. (The two-generator braid element is the lcm)

[F4]

The labelled ribbon construction is the independent input from Godelle, Definitions 3.7–3.8 and the monoidal description preceding Definition 3.12, recorded in External input.

[F5]

The spherical nu-formula and reduced-generator convention are the independent input from Godelle, Example 3.14 and §4.2, recorded in External input.

External input

Godelle, Definitions 3.7–3.8, defines the positive ribbon category and ribbon groupoid using conjugation of standard positive parabolics. In the monoidal description before Definition 3.12, a positive arrow I→J is a label g∈A+ with g−1Ig=J. Groupoid labels lie in A with the same endpoint condition; the natural-transformation construction gives label equality at fixed endpoints and multiplication for composition.

For the spherical structure of F1, Example 3.14 supplies ν(I,a)=ΔI−1ΔI∪{a} for a∉I. The reduced-generator notation is from §4.2; the paragraph before Lemma 4.17 defines the reduced subcategory and subgroupoid generated by these arrows. These construction inputs are imported under the reference hypotheses; their general proofs are not reconstructed.

Proof

Given: The hypotheses and notation in the Statement.

Goal: Establish the asserted conclusion.

1.1F1F2F4F5given

Take Δ∅=1 and Δ{a}=a. F5 gives ν(∅,a)=a. By F4, conjugation of the empty generating subset again gives the empty subset, so its target is empty. Conversely a generator with empty target has empty source, since conjugation is a bijection between its source and target subsets. Hence no reduced edge connects this object to a nonempty one, in either orientation.

2.1F1F2F3F4step 1.1∎

Thus positive paths at this object are precisely positive words in the standard letters. By F4 they are equal exactly when their monoid labels are equal. Consequently this positive component is A+. Allowing inverses gives precisely the subgroup of A generated by S, namely A, with equality of group labels; F1 prevents extra positive equalities. Its group presentation is exactly the braid presentation read as a one-object groupoid presentation. By F3 each generator-pair lcm has exactly its two alternating word representatives. Every such word is a path at the empty object, and every reduced path there is such a word, so these are exactly its two lcm paths.

Depends on

Used by · 1

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Each result is drawn at its shortest distance from this item. Arrows run from prerequisites to the items that use them; this item has a heavier outline. External source nodes link directly to the cited text. The view shows up to two dependency steps; open a prerequisite to continue.

External dependencies

Eddy Godelle, Parabolic subgroups of Garside groups II: ribbons, arXiv:0811.0751v1 · Example 3.14 (printed/PDF p. 15); §4.2 opening notation (p. 20); paragraph immediately before Lemma 4.17 (p. 23)

For a spherical Artin monoid with standard generators $S$, each $I\subseteq S$ has its standard parabolic Garside element $\Delta_I$. For $a\in S\setminus I$, $\nu_I(a)=\Delta_I^{-1}\Delta_{I\cup\{a\}}$ is a positive ribbon from $I$. The notation $\nu(I,a)$ selects the generators outside the source parabolic monoid. The reduced positive category and reduced groupoid are generated by these arrows.

Hypotheses: Finite-rank spherical Artin system, its standard positive Garside monoid and standard parabolic submonoids; only generators with a outside I are used.

Reading limits: Read the extracted PDF text of Example 3.14, the opening notation of §4.2 and the paragraph before Lemma 4.17. The nu-structure and reduced-generator convention are imported, not proved here. The cited historical proofs were not read or reconstructed. The PDF screenshot tool failed; no visual inspection is claimed.

Eddy Godelle, Parabolic subgroups of Garside groups II: ribbons, arXiv:0811.0751v1 · §2.2, natural transformations for groups (printed/PDF p. 4); Definition 2.7 (p. 7); Definitions 3.7–3.8 (pp. 12–13); monoidal description immediately preceding Definition 3.12 (p. 14)

For a monoidal Garside structure $(A^+,\Delta)$ with group $A$, objects of the positive ribbon category are standard parabolic submonoids $A_I^+$. A positive arrow from $I$ to $J$ is a label $g\in A^+$ satisfying $g^{-1}A_I^+g=A_J^+$, equivalently $g^{-1}Ig=J$. The ribbon groupoid uses labels $g\in A$ inducing the same conjugation of positive parabolics. With endpoints fixed, equality is label equality, and composition is multiplication in traversal order.

Hypotheses: Monoidal Garside structure and its associated group, standard parabolic submonoids identified by their atom sets. Applied only to the finite-rank spherical Artin structure supplied by F1.

Reading limits: Read the extracted PDF text of the group natural-transformation description, Definition 2.7, Definitions 3.7–3.8 and the monoidal paragraph before Definition 3.12. These definitions and their labelled specialization are the imported construction; no general ribbon presentation theorem is used here. No visual PDF inspection succeeded.

Sources