Alphabeta Math
ExampleConstruction: AI-adaptedVerification: AI-generatedSession-authored (Fable 5 assisted)precheck passjudge pass (z-ai/glm-5.2)audited 2026-07-27
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Q(2)\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}) carries exactly two distinct field orders, exchanged by the conjugation 22\sqrt{2} \mapsto -\sqrt{2}

Example

Let u:=2Ru := \sqrt 2 \in \mathbb{R} (Square roots exist: a unique a0\sqrt{a} \ge 0 with (a)2=a(\sqrt{a})^2 = a; the positives are {x2:x0}\{x^2 : x \neq 0\}) and

F  :=  Q(2)  =  {a+bu:a,bQ}    R.F \;:=\; \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt 2) \;=\; \{\, a + bu : a, b \in \mathbb{Q} \,\} \;\subseteq\; \mathbb{R}.

Then FF is a field, every element of it is a+bua + bu for exactly one pair (a,b)(a,b) of rationals, and the conjugation σ(a+bu):=abu\sigma(a + bu) := a - bu is a field automorphism of FF.

FF carries exactly two positive cones (Ordered field):

P1  =  {xF:x>0 in R},P2  =  {xF:σ(x)P1},P_1 \;=\; \{\, x \in F : x > 0 \text{ in } \mathbb{R} \,\}, \qquad P_2 \;=\; \{\, x \in F : \sigma(x) \in P_1 \,\},

and σ\sigma exchanges them. They differ: uP1u \in P_1 and uP2u \notin P_2. In the second order 2\sqrt 2 is negative, and indeed lies below every positive rational, while 2-\sqrt 2 is positive; the rationals themselves are ordered the same way in both.

The point of the example is that an order is extra structure on a field, not a property of it: the same field is an ordered field in two inequivalent ways, and no algebraic property of FF can distinguish uu from u-u.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: R\mathbb{R} with its order, u=2u = \sqrt 2, the set FF above, and the map σ(a+bu)=abu\sigma(a+bu) = a - bu.

[L1]

R\mathbb{R} is a complete ordered field and every a0a \ge 0 in it has a unique s0s \ge 0 with s2=as^2 = a; in particular u>0u > 0 and u2=2u^2 = 2 (Square roots exist: a unique a0\sqrt{a} \ge 0 with (a)2=a(\sqrt{a})^2 = a; the positives are {x2:x0}\{x^2 : x \neq 0\}, Complete ordered field (least-upper-bound property), The reals form a totally ordered field).

[L2]

No rational squares to 22 (FALSE: some rational number squares to 2, The rationals as equivalence classes of pairs of integers); in particular uQu \notin \mathbb{Q}.

[L3]

Field axioms and arithmetic (Field); a positive cone is a subset PP satisfying trichotomy, exactly one of xPx \in P, x=0x = 0, xP-x \in P, and closure under addition and multiplication, and x<yx < y means yxPy - x \in P (Ordered field).

[L4]

In any ordered field: 0<10 < 1 (The multiplicative identity is positive); n1>0n \cdot 1 > 0 for n1n \ge 1 (Canonical naturals are positive and strictly increasing); a nonzero square is positive (Squares of nonzero elements are positive); a positive element has a positive inverse (Inverses of positives are positive, and reciprocation reverses order); a product of two positives or of two negatives is positive and a product of a positive and a negative is negative (Sign rules for products and monotonicity of multiplication); sums of positives are positive and adding a constant preserves the order (Order is preserved by adding a constant and by adding inequalities). In each clause above, Sign rules for products and monotonicity of multiplication and Order is preserved by adding a constant and by adding inequalities state the STRICT forms and only those; the nonstrict forms used below are those together with the equality cases, which trichotomy settles, the order being total (Ordered field).

[L5]

Q\mathbb{Q} embeds in any ordered field as {(p1)(q1)1}\{(p \cdot 1)(q\cdot 1)^{-1}\}, compatibly with the field operations (The unique embedding of ℚ into an ordered field).

Verification

technique · direct
1.1

uRu \in \mathbb{R} satisfies u>0u > 0 and u2=2u^2 = 2, and uQu \notin \mathbb{Q}.

L1L2
1.2

In every ordered field the positivity of a rational is forced: n1>0n \cdot 1 > 0 for n1n \ge 1, so for positive integers p,qp, q the element (p1)(q1)1(p\cdot 1)(q\cdot 1)^{-1} is positive, and hence a rational is in the positive cone exactly when it is positive in the usual sense.

L4L5
2.1

FF is a subfield of R\mathbb{R}: it contains 00 and 11, is closed under subtraction, and (a+bu)(c+du)=(ac+2bd)+(ad+bc)u(a+bu)(c+du) = (ac + 2bd) + (ad + bc)u gives closure under multiplication; for a+bu0a + bu \ne 0 one has a22b20a^2 - 2b^2 \ne 0, since b0b \ne 0 would otherwise give (a/b)2=2(a/b)^2 = 2 against [L2] while b=0b = 0 forces a0a \ne 0, and then (a+bu)1=(abu)(a22b2)1F(a+bu)^{-1} = (a - bu)(a^2-2b^2)^{-1} \in F.

step 1.1L2L3
2.2

The representation is unique: a+bu=a+bua + bu = a' + b'u with bbb \ne b' would give u=(aa)(bb)1Qu = (a-a')(b'-b)^{-1} \in \mathbb{Q}, against step 1.1; so b=bb = b' and then a=aa = a'.

step 1.1L2L3
3.1

σ\sigma is therefore a well-defined map FFF \to F, and it is a field automorphism: it is additive by inspection, σ(1)=1\sigma(1) = 1, and σ(a+bu)σ(c+du)=(ac+2bd)(ad+bc)u=σ((a+bu)(c+du))\sigma(a+bu)\sigma(c+du) = (ac+2bd) - (ad+bc)u = \sigma\big((a+bu)(c+du)\big); moreover σσ\sigma \circ \sigma is the identity, so σ\sigma is a bijection.

step 2.1step 2.2L3
3.2

Let QQ be any positive cone on FF. Since u0u \ne 0, exactly one of uQu \in Q, uQ-u \in Q holds.

step 2.1L3
4.1

QQ is determined by that choice. Suppose uQu \in Q (the other case is the same with uu replaced by u-u, which also squares to 22). Let x=a+bu0x = a + bu \ne 0. If b=0b = 0 then xx is a nonzero rational and step 1.2 decides it. If b0b \ne 0 then x=b(u+c)x = b(u + c) with c:=a/bQc := a/b \in \mathbb{Q}, and by [L4] the membership of xx is decided by those of bb and of u+cu + c; for c0c \ge 0 one has u+cQu + c \in Q, while for c<0c < 0, writing e:=c>0e := -c > 0, the identity (ue)(u+e)=2e2(u-e)(u+e) = 2 - e^2 with u+eQu + e \in Q and 2e202 - e^2 \ne 0 shows that ueQu - e \in Q exactly when 2e2>02 - e^2 > 0, a condition on a rational decided by step 1.2. So QQ is uniquely determined, and there are at most two positive cones on FF.

step 1.2step 2.1step 3.2L2L3L4
4.2

Both occur. P1P_1 is a positive cone on FF, being the restriction to the subfield FF of the positive cone of R\mathbb{R}; and P2=σ1(P1)P_2 = \sigma^{-1}(P_1) is one because σ\sigma is a field automorphism, so trichotomy and closure transfer along it. They are distinct: uP1u \in P_1 by step 1.1, whereas σ(u)=uP1\sigma(u) = -u \notin P_1, so uP2u \notin P_2.

step 1.1step 2.1step 3.1L3
5.1

Hence FF carries exactly two positive cones, P1P_1 and P2P_2, and since σ\sigma is an involution, P2=σ(P1)P_2 = \sigma(P_1) and P1=σ(P2)P_1 = \sigma(P_2): the conjugation exchanges the two orders.

step 3.1step 4.1step 4.2

Remarks

  • Two orders, one field, and no way to tell them apart algebraically. The automorphism σ\sigma carries (F,P1)(F,P_1) isomorphically onto (F,P2)(F,P_2) as an ordered field, so the two ordered fields are isomorphic even though the two orders on the underlying FF are different subsets. That is the precise sense in which an order is not determined by the field: what is determined here is the order up to isomorphism, not the order itself.

  • Contrast with Q\mathbb{Q} and with R\mathbb{R}, each of which carries exactly one order. For Q\mathbb{Q} this is step 1.2: every rational is a quotient of canonical naturals, so its sign is forced. For R\mathbb{R} it is Square roots exist: a unique a0\sqrt{a} \ge 0 with (a)2=a(\sqrt{a})^2 = a; the positives are {x2:x0}\{x^2 : x \neq 0\}: the positives are exactly the nonzero squares, and the squares are fixed by the field structure alone. Q(2)\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt 2) sits between the two and has room for exactly two, because 22 acquires a square root while FF still has elements that are not squares.

  • What decides an order on FF is a single bit, the sign of uu, after which every other comparison reduces to a comparison of rationals. That is also why there are exactly two and not more: the sign of uu is the only free choice, and both of its values are realised.

Depends on

Used by

Nothing in the library uses this result yet.

Dependency tree · next 3 levels

Direct dependencies and their dependencies through the next three levels: 52 results over 21 levels. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, and this result sits at the bottom with a heavier outline. Click the chart to enlarge it.

Sources