Alphabeta Math
ExampleConstruction: AI-adaptedVerification: AI-generatedprecheck passjudge pass (z-ai/glm-5.2)audited 2026-07-27
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Q(2) carries exactly two distinct field orders, exchanged by the conjugation 2↦−2

Example

Let u:=2∈R (Square roots exist: a unique a≥0 with (a)2=a; the positives are {x2:x≠0}) and

F  :=  Q(2)  =  { a+bu:a,b∈Q }  ⊆  R.

Then F is a field, every element of it is a+bu for exactly one pair (a,b) of rationals, and the conjugation σ(a+bu):=a−bu is a field automorphism of F.

F carries exactly two positive cones (Ordered field):

P1  =  { x∈F:x>0 in R },P2  =  { x∈F:σ(x)∈P1 },

and σ exchanges them. They differ: u∈P1 and u∉P2. In the second order 2 is negative, and indeed lies below every positive rational, while −2 is positive; the rationals themselves are ordered the same way in both.

The point of the example is that an order is extra structure on a field, not a property of it: the same field is an ordered field in two inequivalent ways, and no algebraic property of F can distinguish u from −u.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: R with its order, u=2, the set F above, and the map σ(a+bu)=a−bu.

[L1]

R is a complete ordered field and every a≥0 in it has a unique s≥0 with s2=a; in particular u>0 and u2=2 (Square roots exist: a unique a≥0 with (a)2=a; the positives are {x2:x≠0}, Complete ordered field (least-upper-bound property), The reals form a totally ordered field).

[L3]

Field axioms and arithmetic (Field); a positive cone is a subset P satisfying trichotomy, exactly one of x∈P, x=0, −x∈P, and closure under addition and multiplication, and x<y means y−x∈P (Ordered field).

[L4]

In any ordered field: 0<1 (The multiplicative identity is positive); n⋅1>0 for n≥1 (Canonical naturals are positive and strictly increasing); a nonzero square is positive (Squares of nonzero elements are positive); a positive element has a positive inverse (Inverses of positives are positive, and reciprocation reverses order); a product of two positives or of two negatives is positive and a product of a positive and a negative is negative (Sign rules for products and monotonicity of multiplication); sums of positives are positive and adding a constant preserves the order (Order is preserved by adding a constant and by adding inequalities). In each clause above, Sign rules for products and monotonicity of multiplication and Order is preserved by adding a constant and by adding inequalities state the STRICT forms and only those; the nonstrict forms used below are those together with the equality cases, which trichotomy settles, the order being total (Ordered field).

[L5]

Q embeds in any ordered field as {(p⋅1)(q⋅1)−1}, compatibly with the field operations (The unique embedding of ℚ into an ordered field).

Verification

technique · direct
1.1

u∈R satisfies u>0 and u2=2, and u∉Q.

L1L2
1.2

In every ordered field the positivity of a rational is forced: n⋅1>0 for n≥1, so for positive integers p,q the element (p⋅1)(q⋅1)−1 is positive, and hence a rational is in the positive cone exactly when it is positive in the usual sense.

L4L5
2.1

F is a subfield of R: it contains 0 and 1, is closed under subtraction, and (a+bu)(c+du)=(ac+2bd)+(ad+bc)u gives closure under multiplication; for a+bu≠0 one has a2−2b2≠0, since b≠0 would otherwise give (a/b)2=2 against [L2] while b=0 forces a≠0, and then (a+bu)−1=(a−bu)(a2−2b2)−1∈F.

step 1.1L2L3
2.2

The representation is unique: a+bu=a′+b′u with b≠b′ would give u=(a−a′)(b′−b)−1∈Q, against step 1.1; so b=b′ and then a=a′.

step 1.1L2L3
3.1

σ is therefore a well-defined map F→F, and it is a field automorphism: it is additive by inspection, σ(1)=1, and σ(a+bu)σ(c+du)=(ac+2bd)−(ad+bc)u=σ((a+bu)(c+du)); moreover σ∘σ is the identity, so σ is a bijection.

step 2.1step 2.2L3
3.2

Let Q be any positive cone on F. Since u≠0, exactly one of u∈Q, −u∈Q holds.

step 2.1L3
4.1

Q is determined by that choice. Suppose u∈Q (the other case is the same with u replaced by −u, which also squares to 2). Let x=a+bu≠0. If b=0 then x is a nonzero rational and step 1.2 decides it. If b≠0 then x=b(u+c) with c:=a/b∈Q, and by [L4] the membership of x is decided by those of b and of u+c; for c≥0 one has u+c∈Q, while for c<0, writing e:=−c>0, the identity (u−e)(u+e)=2−e2 with u+e∈Q and 2−e2≠0 shows that u−e∈Q exactly when 2−e2>0, a condition on a rational decided by step 1.2. So Q is uniquely determined, and there are at most two positive cones on F.

step 1.2step 2.1step 3.2L2L3L4
4.2

Both occur. P1 is a positive cone on F, being the restriction to the subfield F of the positive cone of R; and P2=σ−1(P1) is one because σ is a field automorphism, so trichotomy and closure transfer along it. They are distinct: u∈P1 by step 1.1, whereas σ(u)=−u∉P1, so u∉P2.

step 1.1step 2.1step 3.1L3
5.1

Hence F carries exactly two positive cones, P1 and P2, and since σ is an involution, P2=σ(P1) and P1=σ(P2): the conjugation exchanges the two orders.

step 3.1step 4.1step 4.2∎

Remarks

  • Two orders, one field, and no way to tell them apart algebraically. The automorphism σ carries (F,P1) isomorphically onto (F,P2) as an ordered field, so the two ordered fields are isomorphic even though the two orders on the underlying F are different subsets. That is the precise sense in which an order is not determined by the field: what is determined here is the order up to isomorphism, not the order itself.

  • Contrast with Q and with R, each of which carries exactly one order. For Q this is step 1.2: every rational is a quotient of canonical naturals, so its sign is forced. For R it is Square roots exist: a unique a≥0 with (a)2=a; the positives are {x2:x≠0}: the positives are exactly the nonzero squares, and the squares are fixed by the field structure alone. Q(2) sits between the two and has room for exactly two, because 2 acquires a square root while F still has elements that are not squares.

  • What decides an order on F is a single bit, the sign of u, after which every other comparison reduces to a comparison of rationals. That is also why there are exactly two and not more: the sign of u is the only free choice, and both of its values are realised.

Depends on

Used by

Nothing in the library uses this result yet.

Dependency tree · two levels

28 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources