Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedprecheck passjudge pass (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Affine codimension-one neighbourhoods and divisors

Statement

Assume AC and DC as inherited from the supplied algebra and scheme results.

(a) On a finite-type separated normal scheme over an affine Noetherian base, finitely many points of codimension at most one lie in a single affine open subscheme.

(b) For a normal Noetherian separated scheme X and a dense affine open subscheme U⊆X, the complement X∖U has pure codimension one in X; if X is regular in addition, its reduced support is an effective Cartier divisor. If X is flat over a discrete valuation ring and U meets every irreducible component of the special fibre, then X∖U is the closure of its generic fibre complement, so it contains no special-fibre component.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: AC and DC, an affine Noetherian base ring R and a finite-type separated normal R-scheme X with points x1,…,xn of codimension at most one.

[F1]

Valuative uniqueness holds for separated schemes: a valuation ring admits at most one centre on a separated scheme dominating a given centre (Valuative uniqueness detects separatedness, Valuative criterion for properness); at distinct codimension-one points this identifies the normal local rings OX,xi with distinct DVRs in the function field.

[F2]

Hartogs for normal Noetherian domains: a rational function on a normal Noetherian domain which is regular at every height-one point is regular (A normal Noetherian domain is the intersection of its height-one localizations, assuming AC); the scheme Zariski Main Theorem and the regular-local UFD property give the corresponding divisorial statements (Scheme Zariski Main factorization for separated quasi-finite morphisms, Regular local rings are unique factorization domains, Regularity ascends and descends along a flat local homomorphism, Locally standard smooth iff flat with geometrically regular fibres).

[F3]

Rational sections of line bundles correspond to Cartier divisors, and finite prime avoidance is available (Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors, An ideal contained in a finite union of prime ideals lies in one of them).

Proof

technique · direct. Approximation for finitely many inequivalent valuations produces a common affine neighbourhood of the given points, and Hartogs controls complements of dense affine opens
1.1F1givenalgebra

Reduce to a connected normal component of X. Its generic point lies in every nonempty affine open, so discard it from the list; if the list becomes empty, any affine open suffices. Remove repeated points. For the remaining codimension-one points put Vi=OX,xi, viewed as rank-one valuation rings in the common function field L. The Vi are pairwise distinct: if two points xi≠xj gave centres of the same valuation of L, both would dominate the same valuation ring and separatedness would force xi=xj by [F1]. Two distinct rank-one valuation rings in L are incomparable: if V⊆W and the uniformizer π of V is invertible in W, then L=V[1/π]⊆W, so W is a field, and otherwise every x∉V has inverse in πV and cannot lie in W; hence inclusion forces equality.

2.1F1step 1.1construct

Fix i and, for each j≠i, choose yij∈Vi∖Vj. Multiplying a sufficiently high power of yij by a uniformizer of Vi gives zij with vi(zij)>0 and vj(zij)<0. If there is only one valuation, take hi to be its uniformizer; otherwise begin with one zij and construct hi successively: to add a new index j, replace the preceding sum h by h+zijM. Choose M so large that its new term has strictly smaller valuation than h at j and at every earlier index where zij has negative valuation. At an earlier index where that valuation is nonnegative, the old negative valuation persists. Thus cancellation is excluded at every required index, and vi(hi)>0, vj(hi)<0 for all j≠i. Put ei=1/(1+hiN). Increasing N makes vi(ei−1) and all vj(ei) for j≠i arbitrarily large. For prescribed targets ci∈L, the sum ∑ieici consequently approximates cj at every vj to any fixed finite precision.

3.1F3step 2.1algebra

Let C=⋂iVi. The residue map C→κ(Vi) is surjective: approximate a representative in Vi modulo its maximal ideal and approximate zero at all other valuations, using step 2.1. Thus its kernel mi={c∈C:vi(c)>0} is maximal. These are all the maximal ideals: an element of C is invertible exactly when all its valuations vanish, so the nonunits are the union of the mi, and finite prime avoidance [F3] makes every maximal ideal one of the mi. The approximation of step 2.1 separates the mi, realizes arbitrary prescribed residues, and shows Cmi=Vi: for x∈Vi one approximates 1 at i and 0 to high order at the other indices by some t∈C, and then tx∈C with t∉mi, so x=(tx)/t∈Cmi, the reverse inclusion being immediate.

4.1step 3.1constructalgebra

Choose affine charts Wi=Spec⁡Bi around xi and finite R-algebra generators bil of Bi. By step 3.1 write bil=ail/sil with ail,sil∈C and sil∉mi. Let C0⊆C be the R-algebra generated by all these numerators and denominators, and put si=∏lsil, so Bi⊆(C0)si inside L. Each of the finitely many generators of C0 lies in (Bi)pi=Vi, where pi represents xi. Writing those generators as fractions in (Bi)pi and multiplying their denominators gives ti∈Bi∖pi with C0⊆(Bi)ti. Since ti∈(C0)si, write ti=di/siNi with di∈C0; both si and di are units in Vi. The two inclusions just constructed induce mutually inverse homomorphisms, inside L, between (C0)sidi and (Bi)ti[1/si]: Bi lies in (C0)si and ti becomes invertible after inverting di, while C0 lies in (Bi)ti and di=tisiNi becomes invertible after inverting si. All defining relations and both inverse identities hold because these are subrings of the same field. To identify an actual principal open of Wi, write si=ri/tiMi in (Bi)ti; then ri∉pi and (Bi)ti[1/si]=(Bi)tiri. Thus Ui=DWi(tiri) contains xi and is isomorphic to DSpec⁡C0(sidi).

5.1F1F3step 4.1construct

The inverse morphisms D(sidi)→Ui⊆X agree on every overlap: they agree at the common generic point, their source is integral, and separatedness of X makes their equalizer closed. Their maps to Spec⁡C0 likewise agree on overlaps of the Ui, since all are defined by the inclusion C0⊆L. Consequently these isomorphisms glue to an isomorphism from the open W=⋃iUi⊆X onto the open ⋃iD(sidi)⊆Spec⁡C0. Let J define its closed complement. For every prime qi corresponding to xi, J⊈qi; finite prime avoidance gives f∈J∖⋃iqi. Then D(f)⊆W is affine and contains all xi. A normal Noetherian scheme has finitely many disjoint open and closed integral components; applying this construction on each component with a prescribed point and taking the finite disjoint union gives (a), including any generic points discarded in step 1.1.

6.1F2step 5.1algebra

For (b), work on one integral component of X, with function field L, and write U=Spec⁡A there. If an irreducible component of the closed boundary has generic point z of codimension at least two, choose an affine normal chart V=Spec⁡B containing z and avoiding every other boundary component. Every height-one point of V then belongs to U. For each a∈A⊆L, its restriction to U∩V is regular at all these points, so [F2] places a in B. This gives a single ring homomorphism A→B: sums, products, the unit and every relation are preserved inside L. Thus it defines an actual morphism h:V→U, with no finite-generation assumption on A needed. On the dense open U∩V it is the identity inclusion into U; separatedness of X makes the composite V→hU↪X equal to the inclusion V↪X everywhere. Its image would put z in U, a contradiction. Hence every boundary component has codimension one. If X is regular, at each point its finitely many boundary prime ideals are principal in the regular local UFD. Their intersection is generated by the product of their distinct prime generators, a nonzerodivisor; these reduced ideals glue to the reduced boundary subscheme, making it an effective Cartier divisor. The same argument on the finitely many normal components proves (b) for general X.

7.1F2step 6.1algebra∎

Finally let X be flat over a discrete valuation ring and let U meet every irreducible component of the special fibre. A prime divisor P contained in the boundary X∖U and dominating the base would meet the generic fibre; a prime divisor contained in the special fibre would be a component of it, which is excluded by the fibre-density hypothesis. Hence every boundary prime meets the generic fibre, so the closure of the generic complement XK∖UK contains the whole boundary and is contained in it by closedness; the boundary is therefore the closure of its generic complement and contains no special-fibre component.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

102 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources