Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedSession-authored (Fable 5 assisted)precheck passjudge pass (deepseek-v4-pro + gpt-5.6-terra)audited 2026-08-26
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

For odd p, a central product of two modular groups of order p3 is a central product of a modular group with a Heisenberg group

Statement

Let p be an odd prime and let E be a central product of two copies of the modular group Mp along an isomorphism of their centres. Then E is an internal central product of a subgroup isomorphic to the Heisenberg group Hp and a subgroup isomorphic to Mp; consequently

MpMp    HpMp.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: An odd prime p, two copies of Mp with generators ai of order p2 and si of order p satisfying siaisi1=ai1+p, and the central product E of the two along an isomorphism of their centres, with canonical images xi,yi of ai,si and common central image z.

[F1]

The modular group of order p3 is Mp=AαB with A=a of order p2, B=s of order p, and sas1=a1+p (The modular group of order p3 as a semidirect product Cp2Cp).

[F2]

For groups G,H with central subgroups Z1Z(G), Z2Z(H) and an isomorphism α:Z1Z2, the central product GαH is the quotient of G×H by N={(z,α(z)1):zZ1} (The central product GαH of two groups along an isomorphism of central subgroups).

[F3]

For g,hG the commutator is [g,h]:=ghg1h1 (Commutators [g,h]=ghg1h1 and the commutator subgroup [G,G]).

[F4]

Z(G):={zG:zg=gz for every gG} (The center Z(G) of a group).

[F5]

For a finite group G, exp(G)=min{nN:n>0 and gn=e for every gG} (The exponent of a finite group).

[L1]

Mp is nonabelian of order p3, extraspecial of exponent p2, with Z(Mp)=[Mp,Mp]=ap (The modular group of order p3 is extraspecial, of exponent p2 when p is odd).

[L2]

A central product of two extraspecial p-groups identified along their centres is extraspecial of order E1E2/p (A central product of extraspecial p-groups identified along their centres is extraspecial).

[L3]

The canonical maps into a central product are injective homomorphisms whose images commute elementwise, generate the product, and meet in the image of the identified subgroup (The two canonical maps into a central product are injective homomorphisms whose images commute, generate it, and meet in the identified centre).

[L4]

For an odd prime p and a finite group G with [G,G]Z(G) of exponent dividing p, (xy)p=xpyp for all x,y (For an odd prime p, the p-th power map is a homomorphism on a finite group whose derived subgroup is central of exponent dividing p).

[L5]

An extraspecial p-group is nilpotent of class exactly two, its derived subgroup satisfies P=Z(P) and has order p, and every nonidentity commutator has order p (An extraspecial p-group is nilpotent of class exactly two and its derived subgroup has order p).

[L6]

If [G,G]Z(G) then [xy,w]=[x,w][y,w], [x,yw]=[x,y][x,w], and [xn,y]=[x,y]n=[x,yn] for every integer n (Commutator identities in a group whose derived subgroup is central).

[L7]

If [x,y]e in an extraspecial p-group P, then x,y contains Z(P), has order p3, is nonabelian, and is extraspecial with centre Z(P) (Two elements of an extraspecial p-group with nontrivial commutator generate an extraspecial subgroup of order p3).

[L8]

If x,yP satisfy [x,y]e and F=x,y, then P=FCP(F) and FCP(F)=Z(P), and CP(F) is extraspecial of order P/p2 with centre Z(P) when P>p3 (Every extraspecial p-group is an internal central product of nonabelian subgroups of order p3, The centralizer CG(H) of a subgroup).

[L9]

For every prime p there are exactly two nonabelian groups of order p3 up to isomorphism; for odd p they are Hp, of exponent p, and Mp, of exponent p2 (For each prime there are exactly two nonabelian groups of order p3 up to isomorphism).

[L10]

Subgroups form an internal central product of G if and only if the multiplication map from their direct product is a surjective homomorphism; for two factors GG1idG2 along the identity of G1G2 (Internal central products are the images of external ones).

Proof

technique · direct
1.1

E is extraspecial of order p5, its centre is the common image z of the two centres, and the two canonical images commute elementwise, are injective and generate E.

F2F4L1L2L3
1.2

The generator a2 may be replaced by a power a2c with c not divisible by p without changing the relations of the second copy, and such a replacement multiplies x2p by c in the exponent; choosing c suitably we may assume x1p=x2p=z.

F1F2L1L11
2.1

Each xi has order p2 and each yi has order p, and [x2,y2] is the image of [a2,s2]=a2p, so [x2,y2]=z1.

F1F3L1L3step 1.2
2.2

Put w=x2x11. The p-th power map on E is a homomorphism, because p is odd and [E,E]=Z(E) has order p, so wp=x2p(x1p)1=zz1=e.

L4L5L11step 1.1step 1.2
3.1

Moreover we: otherwise x1=x2 would lie in both canonical images, hence in z, contradicting that x1 has order p2. So w has order p.

L3step 1.1step 2.1step 2.2
3.2

Since x1 and y2 lie in different canonical images they commute, so [w,y2]=[x2x11,y2]=[x2,y2][x11,y2]=[x2,y2]=z1e.

F3L3L6step 1.1step 2.1
4.1

Hence F=w,y2 is extraspecial of order p3 with Z(F)=Z(E).

F6L7step 3.2
5.1

The elements of E whose p-th power is the identity form the kernel of the p-th power homomorphism, hence a subgroup; it contains w, y2 and z, so it contains F, and F has exponent p.

F5F6L4step 2.2step 3.1step 4.1
5.2

By the splitting clause, E=FCE(F) with FCE(F)=Z(E), and C=CE(F) is extraspecial of order p5/p2=p3 with Z(C)=Z(E); so F and C form an internal central product of E.

L8step 1.1step 3.2step 4.1
6.1

A nonabelian group of order p3 and exponent p is isomorphic to Hp, since the other one has exponent p2; so FHp.

L9step 4.1step 5.1
6.2

If C had exponent p then every element of E=FC would be a product of two commuting elements of p-th power the identity, so E would have exponent p, contradicting that x1 has order p2. Hence C has exponent p2 and CMp.

F5L4L9step 2.1step 5.1step 5.2
7.1

Therefore E is an internal central product of FHp and CMp meeting in Z(E), and the recognition theorem identifies it with HpMp along the identity of that centre.

L10step 6.1step 5.2step 6.2

Remarks

The construction of the exponent-p subgroup is where oddness of p is spent: the element w=x2x11 has order p only because the p-th power map is a homomorphism, and at p=2 that map is not one. The corresponding statement at p=2 is the trade of two quaternion factors for two dihedral ones, which is a different computation with a different outcome.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

98 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources