How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The first four-band comparison is a compensated band stabilization
Statement
Assume AC. Let , , , and choose arbitrary , , , . Write , use the row interchanges of Block interchanges transport arbitrary braid boxes, and set , for . Define the following words in : In put Each factor is placed on the first strands unless a shift is displayed. Finally set and Then Consequently is related to by conjugations and exactly negative ordinary stabilizations, from to strands. At the two words coincide and the count is zero. These are statements about the displayed algebraic words; identifying a diagram's chronological record with its actual geometric word is a separate convention.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, the stated widths and arbitrary boxes, with every strand placement as in the Statement.
Artin braid relations and far commutations define these groups; strand placements are homomorphisms (The braid group by Artin presentation).
Uniform whole-block interchanges transport arbitrary internal words, including inverses, in the precise shifted placements (Block interchanges transport arbitrary braid boxes).
Under AC the frozen Artin representation is faithful; , and (The Artin representation is faithful, The Artin representation on a free group, Artin automorphisms of the free group).
With arbitrary surrounding braid, the reverse-order packet on the last old strands and new strands has exactly negative ordinary destabilizations and conjugations to that surrounding braid; its reversed sequence gives stabilizations (Compensated band kinks decompose into ordinary Markov moves).
Conjugations and the ordinary signed stabilization/destabilization are Markov moves (Markov conjugation and stabilization moves).
Proof
Zero widths and complete embeddings. If , , , , , and all primed boxes are their unprimed counterparts; therefore and the asserted equality and count hold. Now assume . All words are defined: fit inside the last old strands after the first , fit after the first , their primed versions are shifted by , uses the first strands, and uses the first strands. The unshifted part of uses only the old strands and uses the last old strands, so . When , and , with no padding or generator indexed zero; all subsequent products on the -block are empty and all corresponding individual-generator rows are absent.
Substitution rules used below. For on generators write . Its images are for input , , and for input , . Induct on the number of rows , adjoining a fixed generator each time: the next descending row sends to and to ; the preceding substitution sends that parenthesized product to . This proves every individual-generator formula, including or . Equivalently, in the ordered input basis and output names , the positive interchange sends to and to ; its inverse sends each to and each to , . The names on each side designate the corresponding consecutive indices of the same free basis, rather than a change of generator sign. For , conjugates each of its free generators by their product. Indeed for , ; setting , induction gives for , since . At this is conjugation by the full product. Every Artin generator fixes the full boundary product, so all local words do too. These rules follow solely from [F3], and apply after any displayed shift.
The upper routing identity on all generators. Put and . We prove . Within this substitution calculation, capitals denote products of free generators, not the braid boxes. For this comparison label the input consecutive blocks by sizes and label the output free generators by as , with products and . The domain rows consist respectively of , , , and in their specified ranges. These are explicit output index assignments: for example output , , , and . Both sides send an input generator in the first -block to ; a generator in the next -block to ; a generator in the following -block to ; and the final blocks to respectively. Here is the full substitution verification. By step 1.2, sends the first generators to , the next to , and the next to , in the intermediate order with middle product ; it leaves the last two blocks in place. The rightmost first conjugates that input -block by its own product, and then sends to and the remaining intermediate generators to the corresponding generators, giving the stated five rows. On the other side the monodromy sends to and to ; consequently sends to while its -row is unchanged. The word sends to , , and the remaining generators to those same output blocks. Finally sends each current to and each current to in the output order , fixing ; in particular . Substituting gives exactly the same five rows above, including the full internal -block conjugation. Faithfulness gives the asserted routing identity.
The compensated lower routing identity on all generators. We prove . Capitals again denote free-generator products in this calculation. Use this time the ordered free basis of sizes , with products , and set , , . Both sides fix every , send to , send to and send to . For the left side, apply the words from right to left using step 1.2. After the intermediate order is : each old generator is the corresponding generator in the shifted last slots, and a new is , the product of those last slots. The inverse interchange moves the group past ; its rule conjugates the latter by the inverse product of the relocated group. The next conjugates the middle -block by its product. After applying , in the intermediate order with products , the old image is , the old image is , the old is , and the new image is , ; the -row is fixed. These follow by cancellation of the conjugating product against the leading in the substitutions of step 2.1. The final sends to , each to , and the remaining generators to themselves. It sends to . Substitution gives precisely the five rows asserted, since . For the right side, split the old slots temporarily as with last two products . By step 1.2, sends to , each generator of the -block to , and each last- generator to ; it fixes the new and preserves . Thus , , and . The packet fixes , sends to , and sends to . In particular . Applying to these substituted images gives , , and , with the -row fixed. All individual generators have now been checked, so faithfulness proves the identity.
Strip arbitrary boxes by whole-block naturality. The word interchanges the whole old -block with the new -block. Hence [F2] gives , because the three old words lie wholly in that -block and their primed embeddings are shifted by . Insert the upper routing identity of step 2.1 into . The factor acts only on the first strands, whereas start after that block and is farther out; their smallest possible generator is at least , while has largest at most . Thus every letter of commutes with every letter, including inverse letters, of . Next interchanges the entire old block after the first with the new block, so [F2] gives . The calculation is therefore . By steps 2.1 and 3.1, the bracket equals . This yields exactly . Every box is arbitrary on its stated whole block; no full twist on only part of a box is commuted through it.
The ordinary move sequence and all boundaries. Conjugate in by . By the reverse of [F4], append to this arbitrary surrounding braid by exactly negative ordinary stabilizations: . Conjugate by and then by to obtain using step 4.1. The strand number rises from to ; remains in the original and every intermediate use of [F4] has its selected last old strands and new strands. At all full twists on the single copied band are , but the necessary old full twist in on strands is retained. At , the rows and cap words disappear, and every substitution and naturality argument above still holds with as a free-product name; this does not set the arbitrary braid box to identity. At use step 1.1, with no move and no nonexistent generator. These distinctions cover all stated widths and trivial or nontrivial boxes. AC is inherited only from the faithful-action and packet suppliers; no closure-equivalence or Markov theorem is used.
Depends on
- Block interchanges transport arbitrary braid boxes
- Compensated band kinks decompose into ordinary Markov moves
- The Artin representation is faithful
- Artin automorphisms of the free group
- The Artin representation on a free group
- The braid group by Artin presentation
- Markov conjugation and stabilization moves
- The Axiom of Choice
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
24 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Traczyk, A new proof of Markov's braid theorem, first right-column comparison in Figure 8 and Figure 10, printed pp. 416 and 418-419 (standard reference, not scraped)
- Gonzalez-Meneses, Basic results on braid groups, sections 1.5-1.6, printed pp. 7-10 (standard reference, not scraped)