Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6-luna)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Trace-state cyclicity and spectral probability calculus

Statement

For a nonnegative countably additive Borel measure μ on R with μ(R)=1, define m(μ):=∫Rλ dμ(λ) when ∫∣λ∣ dμ(λ)<∞. If ∫λ2 dμ(λ)<∞, then ∣λ∣≤(1+λ2)/2 makes the first absolute moment finite, and define V(μ):=∫R(λ−m(μ))2 dμ(λ)=∫Rλ2 dμ(λ)−m(μ)2. Let H≠{0} be a separable complex Hilbert space and ρ a trace-class normal density state. Its positive eigenvalues pj and orthonormal eigenvectors uj satisfy ρ=∑jpj∣uj⟩⟨uj∣ in trace norm and ∑jpj=1. For bounded A, Tr⁡(ρA)=∑jpj⟨Auj,uj⟩, with absolute value at most ∥A∥, and Tr⁡(ρA)=Tr⁡(Aρ). For a self-adjoint observable A with spectral PVM EA, the scalar law μρ(B)=Tr⁡(ρEA(B))=∑jpj∥EA(B)uj∥2 is a probability measure. Its first absolute moment defines a scalar mean, and its second moment defines a variance; these are not defined as arbitrary unbounded products ρA. For a fixed positive Boltzmann scale kB>0 (in SI units J/K), the von Neumann entropy is S(ρ)=−kB∑jpjlog⁡pj∈[0,∞], and need not be finite. Countable convex mixtures of normal density states converge in trace norm.

For this spectral law, the notations are mρ(A):=m(μρ) and Var⁡ρ(A):=V(μρ).

Facts & Assumptions

Given: Countable Choice and the Axiom of Choice; a nonzero separable complex Hilbert space; a positive trace-class density ρ; a bounded operator B; a self-adjoint operator A with its spectral PVM; and the positive scale kB>0 for the entropy clause.

[A1]

Countable Choice permits indexing the positive eigenvalues of a positive trace-class operator by a finite or countable set (The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω)).

[A2]

The full Axiom of Choice is assumed by the inherited unbounded spectral calculus used below (The Axiom of Choice).

[F1]

Trace-class normal density states: a normal density state is represented by a positive trace-class ρ with Tr⁡ρ=1, acting by the bounded trace pairing.

[F2]

Spectral theorem for compact self adjoint operators and Trace is absolutely convergent and basis independent: a positive trace-class density has a finite or countable positive-eigenvalue expansion with trace equal to the sum of its eigenvalues.

[F3]

Trace class is a two sided Banach operator ideal: multiplication by a bounded operator preserves trace class and is trace-norm continuous.

[F4]

Spectral theorem for unbounded self-adjoint operators (PVM form): a self-adjoint operator has a regular spectral PVM and D(A)={u:∫λ2 dEu(λ)<∞}.

[F5]

Bounded borel pvm integral: bounded Borel functions integrate against the spectral PVM with the stated pairing and norm identities.

[F6]

Nuclear bounded cyclicity for trace-class operators, parts (a)–(b): under Countable Choice, trace-class T and bounded C have Tr⁡(CT)=Tr⁡(TC), by absolutely convergent nuclear pairings. No unbounded cyclicity is used.

[F7]

Density operators and scalar spectral probability, parts (a)–(c): a trace-one positive density gives the scalar PVM probability law and scalar moments on their actual integrability domains; the unbounded spectral clauses retain full Choice.

Proof

1.1givenA1F1F2F3F6algebra

Since ρ is the trace-one positive density of [F1], [F2] gives ρ=∑jpj∣uj⟩⟨uj∣, pj>0, with ∑jpj=Tr⁡ρ=1, and trace-norm convergence. For bounded B, [F3] makes ρB trace class. Applying the basis-independent trace to finite partial sums and passing to the trace-norm limit gives Tr⁡(ρB)=∑jpj⟨Buj,uj⟩; its absolute sum is at most ∥B∥∑jpj=∥B∥. The bounded cyclicity statement in [F6] gives Tr⁡(Bρ)=Tr⁡(ρB).

1.2givenF4F5algebra

The scalar mean is defined on the first absolute-moment domain stated above. If the second moment is finite, then ∣λ∣≤(1+λ2)/2 and μρ is a probability measure, so the first absolute moment is finite as well. Expanding (λ−mρ(A))2 and using ∫1 dμρ=1 gives the displayed variance identity. For a vector u, the PVM domain formula [F4] is the operator domain, while the first absolute moment defines the larger form domain D(∣A∣1/2)={u:∫∣λ∣ dEu(λ)<∞}. These definitions use scalar integrals and make no unbounded cyclic permutation.

1.3givenalgebra

Since 0<pj≤1, every term −pjlog⁡pj is nonnegative, so the entropy sum is well defined in [0,∞]; multiplying by the given kB>0 preserves that range. It can diverge: let c−1=∑n≥2(n(log⁡n)2)−1 and pn=c/(n(log⁡n)2). The normalizing series converges because the block 2k≤n<2k+1 contributes at most 1/(klog⁡2)2, and ∑kk−2 converges by grouping dyadic blocks. For sufficiently large n, −pnlog⁡pn≥c/(2nlog⁡n). Each dyadic block contributes at least 1/(4(k+1)log⁡2) to ∑n1/(nlog⁡n), so that entropy series diverges.

2.1givenA2step 1.1F5F7algebra

For each Borel set C⊆R, [F5] and step 1.1 give μρ(C)=∑jpj∥EA(C)uj∥2≥0 and μρ(R)=∑jpj=1. For pairwise disjoint Ck, the PVM property gives ∥EA(⋃kCk)uj∥2=∑k∥EA(Ck)uj∥2, since the projected vectors are orthogonal. The nonnegative double series may be summed in either order; therefore μρ(⋃kCk)=∑kμρ(Ck). This proves that μρ is a probability measure and agrees with the canonical scalar-law interface [F7].

3.1givenA1F2F3algebra∎

For densities ρk and weights tk≥0, ∑ktk=1, the partial sums ∑k≤Ntkρk are Cauchy in trace norm because each ∥ρk∥1=Tr⁡ρk=1 and the tail norm is at most ∑k>Ntk. Completeness in [F3] gives a trace-class limit. Its trace is one by [F2] and trace continuity; its quadratic forms are nonnegative as limits of nonnegative quadratic forms. Thus the countable mixture is again a normal density state and the convergence is in trace norm.

Depends on

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Sources