How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A quasi-compact image stable under specialization is closed
Statement
Assume AC. For a quasi-compact morphism , the image is closed if and only if it is stable under specialization in .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC and a quasi-compact morphism of schemes .
A morphism is quasi-compact when the inverse image of every quasi-compact open of is quasi-compact. (Quasi-compact and quasi-separated morphisms)
Every affine scheme is quasi-compact. (Every affine scheme is quasi-compact)
Every point of a scheme has an affine open neighbourhood. (Schemes)
A scheme morphism is a morphism of locally ringed spaces, hence has a continuous underlying map; an open subset of a scheme carries its open subscheme structure. (Morphisms of schemes, Morphisms of ringed spaces, Affine open subschemes)
A scheme is quasi-compact when its underlying topological space is quasi-compact, so every open cover of it has a finite subcover. (Quasi-compact and quasi-separated schemes)
The points of are prime ideals, and its basic opens are . (The underlying space of an affine spectrum)
A point is a specialization of when . (Specialisations, generalisations, and generic points)
A morphism corresponds to a ring map . (Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings)
A homomorphism induces the contraction map , . (The map of affine spectra induced by a ring homomorphism)
For a prime , is multiplicative, and its image under is multiplicative in . (Localisation at a prime ideal: , Multiplicative subsets and the localisation as equivalence classes of fractions)
The localization is a commutative ring, and every for is a unit. (The localisation relation is an equivalence relation and fraction arithmetic is well defined)
A localization is the zero ring exactly when . (Equality, vanishing, and the kernel of the localisation map)
The Axiom of Choice states that every family of nonempty sets has a choice function. (The Axiom of Choice)
Under AC, every proper ideal of a nonzero commutative ring is contained in a maximal ideal. (In a nonzero commutative ring, every proper ideal is contained in a maximal ideal)
Every maximal ideal of a commutative ring is prime. (Every maximal ideal of a commutative ring is prime)
Proof
If is closed and , then . Thus every specialization of a point of is again in , so the image is stable under specialization.
Assume that is stable under specialization, and let . Choose an affine open containing by [F3]. Since is open, every open neighbourhood of in is also open in ; therefore lies in the closure in of .
The affine open is quasi-compact by [F2], so [F1] makes quasi-compact. It is an open subscheme of by [F4]. Its affine open neighbourhoods cover it by [F3], and [F5] gives a finite affine open cover ; empty members may be discarded.
The image is the finite union of the images . Some has in its closure in : otherwise, for each of the finitely many there would be an open neighbourhood of disjoint from , and the finite intersection of those neighbourhoods would miss their union, contradicting step 1.2. Fix such an and write . By [F9] the restricted morphism is induced by a ring map , and its image in has in its closure.
Let be the prime corresponding to , and put . Suppose . By [F13], , so for some . Every prime then contains , and [F10] shows its image lies outside . But is a basic open neighbourhood of by [F6, F7], contradicting that lies in the closure of the image of . Thus is nonzero.
The zero ideal of the nonzero commutative ring is proper. By [F14, F15], AC supplies a maximal ideal of , which is prime by [F16]. Its contraction along is prime by [F10]. It avoids , since each with is a unit by [F12] and a proper prime ideal contains no unit. Hence is a prime contained in : every has and so is not in .
The point lies in the image of . Since , every basic open containing also contains , by [F6, F7]. Thus in , so is a specialization of the image point in as well: every open neighbourhood of in restricts to one in the open set . Stability under specialization then gives .
Every point of belongs to by steps 1.2--6.1, so is closed. Together with step 1.1 this proves both directions. The empty source has empty image and satisfies both conditions; if an affine chart is the zero ring it is empty and can be discarded. A zero localization in step 4.1 is excluded by the closure argument. If is a field, then is its only prime, so the inclusion in step 5.1 is equality and the same proof handles a one-point affine target. The only AC use is prime existence in step 5.1; only a finite affine cover and a single chart from its finite list are used.
Depends on
The Axiom of Choice
Morphisms of schemes
Morphisms of ringed spaces
Quasi-compact and quasi-separated morphisms
Quasi-compact and quasi-separated schemes
Schemes
Affine open subschemes
Every affine scheme is quasi-compact
The underlying space of an affine spectrum
Principal distinguished subsets of the prime spectrum
Specialisations, generalisations, and generic points
Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings
The map of affine spectra induced by a ring homomorphism
Localisation at a prime ideal:
Multiplicative subsets and the localisation as equivalence classes of fractions
The localisation relation is an equivalence relation and fraction arithmetic is well defined
Equality, vanishing, and the kernel of the localisation map
In a nonzero commutative ring, every proper ideal is contained in a maximal ideal
Every maximal ideal of a commutative ring is prime