Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedprecheck passjudge pass (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The tangent space of the affine Minkowski model at any event is canonically V

Statement

Let (A,V,η,C+) be an oriented time-oriented affine Minkowski space with the smooth structure of The affine atlas makes the Minkowski model a smooth 4-manifold diffeomorphic to R^4, and let p∈A. A smooth germ at p is the equivalence class of a smooth real function on an open neighbourhood of p, where representatives agreeing on a smaller neighbourhood are equivalent (The germ of a smooth function at a point). For such a germ [f] define

Φp(v)([f]):=ddt∣t=0f(p+tv),v∈V.

Then Φp:V→TpA is a linear isomorphism of V onto the tangent space TpA; in particular TpA is canonically identified with V, independently of any chart. If x is an inertial chart and v=v0e0+v1e1+v2e2+v3e3, then the coordinate derivations satisfy Φp(v)=∑ava∂a∣p.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: An event p of A, an inertial chart x with frame (o;e0,e1,e2,e3) and E(u)=∑auaea, and the map Φp of the Statement.

[L1]

The tangent space TpA is the set of derivations at p, i.e. of R-linear maps v:Cp∞(A)→R satisfying v([f][g])=f(p)v([g])+g(p)v([f]) (Derivations at a point and the tangent space).

[L2]

A smooth germ at p has a coordinate representative smooth near x(p), and composition with smooth maps is smooth: for a smooth curve c:(−ε,ε)→A through p and a smooth germ [f], the map t↦f(c(t)) is smooth near 0 (Cr and smooth maps between smooth manifolds, Ck maps and multi-index derivative notation in Euclidean space, Identity maps and composites of smooth maps are smooth).

[L3]

If a map g between open subsets of Euclidean space has all partial derivatives continuous at a, then g is totally differentiable at a and Dg(a) is the linear map with matrix the Jacobian of g at a (If all partial derivatives exist on a neighbourhood and are continuous at a point, then the map is totally differentiable there with Jacobian derivative).

[L4]

If g is totally differentiable at a and h at g(a), then D(h∘g)(a)=Dh(g(a))∘Dg(a) (The chain rule for total derivatives: D(g∘f)(a)=Dg(f(a))∘Df(a)).

[L7]

Sum and scalar-multiple derivatives are linear (Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: (f+g)′(c)=f′(c)+g′(c), (αf)′(c)=αf′(c), (fg)′(c)=f′(c)g(c)+f(c)g′(c), and (f/g)′(c)=(f′(c)g(c)−f(c)g′(c))/g(c)2 when g(c)≠0, claims 1 and 2). Let A⊆R, c a limit point of A, and f,g differentiable at c; then fg is differentiable at c with (fg)′(c)=f′(c)g(c)+f(c)g′(c) (the same source, claim 3).

[L5]

The coordinate derivations ∂0∣p,∂1∣p,∂2∣p,∂3∣p of a smooth chart form a basis of TpA (Coordinate derivations form a basis of the tangent space).

[L6]

In an inertial chart x, the affine structure gives x(p+tv)=x(p)+tu with u=E−1(v) for every v∈V, and E:R4→V is a linear isomorphism (Inertial frames and inertial charts of the affine Minkowski model, Invertible linear maps, linear isomorphisms, and inverse linear maps).

Proof

1.1L2L6

Fix v∈V and a smooth germ [f] at p. By [L6] the curve c(t):=p+tv has coordinate representation x(c(t))=x(p)+tu with u=E−1(v), a smooth curve in R4; hence c is a smooth curve through p in the chart x, and t↦f(c(t)) is smooth near 0 by [L2], so its derivative at 0 exists. If g agrees with f near p, then f∘c and g∘c agree near 0, so the derivative depends only on the germ [f]; hence Φp(v)([f]) is a well-defined real number.

2.1step 1.1L2L3L4algebra

With u=E−1(v)=(u0,u1,u2,u3), set F:=f∘x−1, the smooth coordinate representative of [f] near x(p) [L2]. Then f(c(t))=F(x(p)+tu) for t near 0, so by the chain rule [L4] applied to t↦x(p)+tu and to F, whose total derivative at x(p) has matrix the Jacobian by [L3], Φp(v)([f])=ddt∣0F(x(p)+tu)=DF(x(p))⋅u=∑a=03ua∂aF(x(p)).

3.1step 2.1L6algebra

Φp is linear in v: by step 2.1 the value Φp(v)([f])=∑aua∂aF(x(p)) is a linear function of u=E−1(v), and E−1 is linear by [L6].

3.2step 2.1L1L2L7algebra

Φp(v) is a derivation at p: it is R-linear in the germ because the sum and scalar-multiple derivative rules of [L7] apply to t↦f(p+tv) near 0. For smooth germs [f],[g], the coordinate representatives satisfy ((fg)∘x−1)=(f∘x−1)(g∘x−1), so the one-variable product rule [L7] applied to the differentiable functions t↦F(y+tea) and t↦G(y+tea), where y=x(p)∈R4 and ea∈R4 is the a-th standard coordinate vector gives the product rule for the partial derivatives: ∂a((fg)∘x−1)(x(p))=f(p)∂a(g∘x−1)(x(p))+g(p)∂a(f∘x−1)(x(p)), since f(x−1(x(p)))=f(p) and likewise for g; substituting into step 2.1 gives Φp(v)([f][g])=f(p)Φp(v)([g])+g(p)Φp(v)([f]), so Φp(v)∈TpA by [L1].

3.3step 2.1L6algebra

Φp is injective: suppose Φp(v)=0 with coordinate vector u=E−1(v). Applying Φp(v) to the germ of the coordinate function xa gives, by step 2.1, Φp(v)([xa])=∑bub∂b(xa∘x−1)(x(p))=∑bubδba=ua; hence u=0, and since E−1 is injective by [L6], v=0.

4.1step 2.1step 3.1step 3.3L5L6

Φp carries the basis (e0,e1,e2,e3) of V to the coordinate derivations: for v=ea one has u=E−1(ea)=(δba)b by [L6], so step 2.1 gives Φp(ea)([f])=∂aF(x(p))=∂a∣p([f]) for every smooth germ, that is, Φp(ea)=∂a∣p. By [L5] the derivations ∂a∣p form a basis of TpA, so the linear map Φp carries a basis of V to a basis of TpA; hence Φp is surjective (its image contains a basis) and injective by step 3.3, so it is a linear isomorphism V→TpA.

5.1step 4.1L6algebra∎

Finally, let v=∑avaea; then u=E−1(v)=(v0,v1,v2,v3), so step 2.1 gives Φp(v)([f])=∑ava∂aF(x(p)), that is, Φp(v)=∑ava∂a∣p. The construction uses only the affine structure p+tv and the smooth structure of the model, both fixed independently of any choice of chart, so the isomorphism Φp is canonical.

Depends on

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Sources