Alphabeta Math
ExampleConstruction: AI-generatedVerification: AI-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The D4 groupoid and the spherical cell complex

PDF p. 30: §7.2.1, paragraph after (7.2)

Statement

For the D4 example with central J={2}, fill every polygonal face of the undirected chamber adjacency graph, including the outermost hexagon in its planar drawing. The resulting space D is homeomorphic to S2. Equivalently, retain two distinct directed edges per adjacency, attach one disk along each inverse two-cycle, and attach one polygon disk per cyclic face, using coherent boundary orientations as below. This doubled complex K is also homeomorphic to S2. The universal wall groupoid is isomorphic, on its 32 chamber objects, to Π1(K;V) and to Π1(D;V).

Here V is the set of chamber vertices, and Π1(−;V) means the full subgroupoid of the fundamental groupoid whose objects are precisely V. A geometric face is filled once, regardless of the choice of a starting vertex or orientation of its boundary word. This makes the attachment convention explicit.

Statement references

Facts & Assumptions

[F1]

Universal groupoid interpretation of the D4 graph gives the doubled generating graph and the universal groupoid with one arrow between every ordered pair of chamber objects. Explicit D4 atomic braid relations and lifted paths gives the square/hexagon atomic relations and their local rank-two flats.

[F2]

The five supporting constructions The seven D4 planes give a finite spherical cellulation, Flag triangles construct the dual sphere, The dual face cycles are the D4 atomic polygons, Doubling edges with bigons preserves the spherical space and The vertex fundamental groupoid of a sphere is thin give the spherical cellulation, its dual, the atomic polygon correspondence, the directed bigon model and its thin fundamental groupoid. The topological groupoid convention is Fundamental groupoid of a space.

[F3]

Disk attachment uses the quotient construction in Cell attachment by a characteristic map: attach a disk to a graph by identifying each boundary point with its image under the prescribed boundary loop, and use the quotient topology. Apply this construction to all the finitely many polygon and bigon disks.

[F4]

Sⁿ is simply connected for every n≥2 at n=2 says that S2 is simply connected: it is nonempty and path-connected, and its fundamental group at every point is trivial.

[F5]

A full subcategory retains all morphisms between its chosen objects, as in Subcategory and full subcategory. An equivalence consists of functors in both directions and natural isomorphisms from each composite to the appropriate identity (or in the reverse direction), as in Equivalence, quasi-inverse, and adjoint equivalence of categories.

[F6]

A homeomorphism is a continuous bijection with continuous inverse, and two spaces are homeomorphic when such a map exists, as in Homeomorphism, open map, closed map, embedding, and what it means for a property to be topological.

[F7]

A functor assigns objects and arrows with their specified endpoints and preserves identities and composition, as in Covariant functor, identity functor, composite functor, and contravariant functor. An isomorphism of categories means a functor with a two-sided inverse functor, as defined in A functor is an isomorphism of categories exactly when its object and morphism maps are bijective.

[F8]

A natural transformation is a family of component arrows whose naturality squares commute, as in Natural transformation and its components. Vertical composition is componentwise composition, and the identity transformation has identity components, as in Identity natural transformation and vertical composition. A natural isomorphism is a natural transformation with a two-sided inverse under this composition, as in Natural isomorphism.

Proof

Given: The data in the Statement and the exact supplier facts above.

Goal: Establish the Statement.

1.1F1F2F3

Use the dual sphere of [F2] for D, with disk attachments interpreted as in [F3]. Its one-skeleton is exactly the chamber adjacency graph, and every dual two-cell is an atomic square or hexagon. Conversely every atomic polygon is one of these cyclic faces. Thus filling all faces, including whichever face becomes outermost after removing a point for a planar drawing, gives this entire sphere. Omitting the outermost disk would remove a disk from this model, so it must be included in the stated spherical construction.

2.1F1F2F3step 1.1

For genuinely distinct opposite directed edges, use the directed bigon construction of [F2], with the quotient topology of [F3]. Its polygon attaching loops use a coherent sphere orientation, with the two adjacent polygons using opposite directed copies of each shared edge. The bigon imposes that the two crossing arrows are inverses. A polygon disk identifies its two opposite geodesic arcs after these inverse identifications, exactly the codimension-two relation in [F1]. The construction therefore has the specified directed attaching maps and is homeomorphic to S2.

3.1F2F4F6step 1.1step 2.1

For either X=D or X=K, steps 1.1 and 2.1 give a homeomorphism h:X→S2. By [F6], both h and h−1 are continuous. For any a,b∈X, compose a path from h(a) to h(b) with h−1; such a path exists by [F4]. Every loop in X at a maps under h to a loop at h(a), which is homotopic to the constant loop with basepoint fixed by [F4]; composing that homotopy with h−1 gives the corresponding homotopy in X. If p,q:a→b are path classes, then q−1∘p is therefore the identity at a. The groupoid inverse laws in [F2] imply p=q. Thus the fundamental groupoid has exactly one arrow between every ordered pair of points, for both spaces; in particular this agrees with the supplied vertex conclusion for K.

4.1F1F2F5F7step 3.1

For each X∈{D,K} send each chamber object to its corresponding vertex, and its unique universal wall-groupoid arrow to the unique path class between those endpoints in X. By [F1] and step 3.1 this is bijective on objects and on each hom-set. It preserves identities and composition because the relevant hom-sets are singletons; its inverse on objects and arrows is a functor for the same reason. The two functors are inverse on every object and arrow, so their composites are the identity functors. Hence it is an isomorphism in the sense of [F7] to the full vertex subgroupoid of [F5]. Each generating crossing maps to the actual crossing-edge path class, since that class has the required endpoints.

5.1F1F2F5F7F8step 3.1step 4.1∎

Fix one chamber vertex v0∈V. For each X∈{D,K} let I:Π1(X;V)→Π1(X) be the inclusion and let R:Π1(X)→Π1(X;V) send every object to v0 and every arrow to its identity. These preserve endpoints, identities and composition, so are functors by [F7]. Define the component at v∈V of 1⇒RI to be the unique arrow v→v0, and the component at x∈X of IR⇒1 to be the unique arrow v0→x. These arrows exist by step 3.1 and are invertible by [F2]. Every naturality square commutes because the two composites have the same endpoints and there is only one arrow between them. For each of these component families, the inverse component arrows also form a natural transformation: their naturality squares commute by the same uniqueness of arrows with specified endpoints. Both vertical composites have identity components by the inverse laws, so the families are natural isomorphisms by [F8]. Thus I and R give the claimed equivalence by [F5]. Together with step 4.1 this proves all groupoid claims, with the asserted isomorphisms using precisely the 32 chamber objects.

Source notes

The original article is attribution only. The five local supporting lemmas supply the global topology and the compatibility with directed arrow attachments; the declared library inputs and local argument supply the path-class transfer and categorical equivalences. Each inverse two-cycle means one cyclic bigon; reversing its cyclic parametrisation does not request an additional disk. The repaired gaps concern the generated draft, and no original-article defect is asserted.

Depends on

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Each result is drawn at its shortest distance from this item. Arrows run from prerequisites to the items that use them; this item has a heavier outline. External source nodes link directly to the cited text. The view shows up to two dependency steps; open a prerequisite to continue.

Sources