Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: AI-generatedProof: AI-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Spectral rationalization and its homotopy groups

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice and the fixed compatible universe conventions of the stable-spectra interface. For an integer m>0, let m:E→E denote the natural sum of m identity maps, formed by the finite biproduct diagonal and fold. Define the rational sphere and rationalization by the coherent sequential colimit

SQ:=colim⁡(S→2S→3S→4⋯ ),EQ:=E∧SQ.

The first stage supplies the natural map E→EQ. This functor preserves small colimits and is exact: it preserves finite limits and finite colimits, including cofiber sequences and their connecting maps. For every integer i there is a natural isomorphism

πi(EQ)≅πi(E)⊗ZQ,

carrying the unit map to a↦a⊗1 and spectral maps to their tensor products with Q. Tensoring abelian groups with Q preserves exact sequences and their kernels, images and quotients. A spectrum R is called rational when every positive-integer multiplication R→R is an equivalence. The spectrum EQ is rational, and restriction along the unit induces an equivalence of mapping spaces Map⁡(EQ,R)≃Map⁡(E,R) for every rational R. Thus this construction has the usual rational-localization meaning, including for nonconnective spectra.

External input

Reference 0 imports preservation of small filtered colimits by every integer spectral homotopy-group functor. It applies to the displayed countable sequence without any connectivity bound. References 1 and 2 supply the precise contractible-index limit facts in [F5], used only for the mapping-space localization property. The rationalization construction and its consequences are locally proved below.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: Spectra in the supplied stable enhancement, its sphere unit, fixed universes and the Axiom of Choice.

Goal: Construct rationalization, identify its homotopy groups and prove exactness and the localization property.

[F1]

Stable spectra and exact triangles supplies coherent small colimits and mapping spaces, the sphere, abelian homotopy groups, their detection of equivalences, and separately colimit-preserving and exact smash. Cofiber of a direct-summand inclusion supplies the finite coproduct/product identification. Consequently the finite diagonal and fold define natural integer multiples of the identity; they act by repeated addition on homotopy groups.

[F2]

Reference 0 in External input supplies the natural comparison between the homotopy groups of a filtered spectral colimit and the filtered colimit of its homotopy groups. Here filtered means nonempty, with a common target for each pair of objects and with every pair of parallel arrows equalized by a further arrow. The sequential index has objects n≥1 and one arrow n→k when n≤k: it is small and nonempty, a pair has upper bound its maximum, and parallel arrows already coincide.

[F3]

Rationalization is exact and commutes with singular homology identifies A⊗ZQ with positive-integer fractions a/s. Equality is a/s=b/t when a positive integer kills ta−sb, and every element is such a fraction. It also supplies exactness of this group rationalization. The tensor product M⊗_R N from the additive group underlying the free ℤ-module on M× N, elementary tensors, and finite tensor sums supplies the tensor notation.

[F4]

A sequential abelian colimit is the cokernel of one minus shift supplies the following presentation, with no injectivity assumption on the transition maps. For a sequence A1→u1A2→u2⋯, let D=⨁r≥1Ar be the abelian group of tuples (ar) having only finitely many nonzero coordinates, with coordinatewise addition. Write ιr:Ar→D for the coordinate inclusion and define sιr=ιr+1ur. Then the quotient C=D/im⁡(1−s), whose elements are cosets modulo the subgroup of elements y−sy, is the group colimit, with stage maps a↦[ιr(a)]. Write urN for the composite transition map from stage r to stage N≥r, with urr=1. The finite-stage and eventual-equality properties used below are derived from this presentation in step 2.1.

[F5]

Reference 1 supplies the limit-cone criterion for an equivalence-valued diagram indexed by a weakly contractible simplicial set. Reference 2 supplies weak contractibility of the nerve of a small ordinary category with a terminal object. Apply these to the inverse-sequence category with objects n≥1 and an arrow n→k when n≥k; its terminal object is 1. Thus every projection of a limiting cone over such an all-equivalence diagram is an equivalence. These are coherent limit statements, not assertions about limits in the homotopy category.

[A1]

Retain The Axiom of Choice in the ZFC and size assumptions of [F1], [F2] and [F3]. No independent family of choices of representatives, denominators or inverse maps is used.

Proof

1.1A1F1F2givenconstruct

The small colimit in the statement exists by [F1] under [A1]. Smash commutes with that colimit, and smashing the finite diagonal and fold with E preserves their biproduct description. Hence EQ is naturally the colimit of E→2E→3E→4⋯. Smash with a fixed spectrum preserves small colimits and is exact by [F1], proving the asserted functoriality and exactness. For A=πiE, [F2] now identifies πi(EQ) with the group colimit of A→2A→3A→4⋯, with the same transition maps by [F1].

2.1F1F2F3F4F5step 1.1constructalgebra∎

By [F4], use the presentation C=D/im⁡(1−s) for the group colimit in step 1.1. Its relations [ιr(a)]=[ιr+1(ura)] move every finite sum to a single common later stage, so every class has a finite-stage representative. If a∈Ai and b∈Aj have equal classes, write ιi(a)−ιj(b)=(1−s)y with y∈D. Choose N greater than i, j and all nonzero coordinate indices of y. The homomorphism ⨁r=1NAr→AN sending coordinate r by urN kills (1−s)y: for each coordinate of y, its two terms cancel because urN=ur+1,Nur. Thus uiNa=ujNb. Conversely, equality at a common stage gives equal classes by those relations. This proves eventual equality without injective transition maps. Number the copies of A starting at n=1. Send a in copy n to a/n! in the fraction group of [F3]. These homomorphisms are compatible, since (n+1)a/(n+1)!=a/n!. They are jointly onto: for a/s take n≥s, so s divides n!, and use (n!/s)a in copy n. If a/n!=0, then ka=0 for some positive k by [F3]; choose N≥nk so k divides N!/n!. The image of a in copy N is zero, so its colimit class is zero. This proves the claimed isomorphism. It is natural because both formulas commute with homomorphisms, and at copy 1 the unit is a↦a/1. Exactness in [F3] also preserves kernels, images and quotients, by applying it to the associated short exact sequences. Positive multiplication on fractions has inverse a/s↦a/(ms), so [F1]'s equivalence detection makes EQ rational. Finally, for rational R, mapping the colimit of step 1.1 into R is the inverse limit of the spaces Map⁡(E,R) with transition maps given by precomposition with positive multiplication. Naturality of multiplication identifies this with postcomposition by the corresponding equivalences of R. All transition maps are therefore equivalences. The inverse-sequence index in [F5] is small in the stipulated universes and has terminal object 1, so its nerve is weakly contractible. The mapping-colimit universal property gives its coherent limiting cone. Applying the limit-cone direction of [F5] shows that its projection to the first term is an equivalence. The evaluation map is precisely restriction along E→EQ. This proves the localization assertion and finishes the proof.

Depends on

Used by · 1

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Each result is drawn at its shortest distance from this item. Arrows run from prerequisites to the items that use them; this item has a heavier outline. External source nodes link directly to the cited text. The view shows up to two dependency steps; open a prerequisite to continue.

External dependencies

Jacob Lurie, Higher Algebra (September 18, 2017) · Proof of Proposition 1.4.3.6, printed p. 152 (PDF page index 151), paragraph proving that homotopy groups preserve products and filtered colimits

Integer-indexed homotopy-group functors on spectra preserve small filtered colimits.

Hypotheses: Spectra of spaces in Sp, any integer degree and a small filtered diagram, with the fixed compatible universes and ZFC foundations of the supplied stable-spectra interface. No connectivity assumption.

Reading limits: Historical reading record retained from the incoming generated item: Current repair read the named proof paragraph through the primary PDF web text extraction, including its reduction by shifts to degree zero. Import this foundational colimit fact only. The telescope, its fraction calculation and its application below are local arguments; the foundational proof was not reconstructed. Current maintenance read the assigned consumer and its exact declared supplier interfaces; no fresh primary-source or page-image reading, reconstruction or independent acceptance is claimed for this reference.

Kerodon, Corollary 7.2.3.5 (02XX) · Corollary 7.2.3.5, equivalence of conditions (1) and (2), and complete proof

For a diagram indexed by a weakly contractible simplicial set whose edges are equivalences, a limiting cone has equivalences as all its projection maps; conversely an all-equivalence cone is limiting.

Hypotheses: A weakly contractible small indexing simplicial set, an infinity-category target and a coherent cone. Use the implication from the limit-cone condition when every diagram edge is an equivalence.

Reading limits: Read the complete corollary and displayed proof through primary web extraction in this maintenance pass. Its anodyne-replacement and cofinality foundations remain imported; no reconstruction or independent acceptance is claimed.

Kerodon, Contractibility (02L4) · Example 3.2.4.2; Definition 3.2.4.16 and Remark 3.2.4.17

A small ordinary category with an initial or terminal object has contractible nerve, and a contractible simplicial set is weakly contractible.

Hypotheses: An ordinary category with an initial or terminal object. Apply to the inverse-sequence index with terminal object 1.

Reading limits: Read these three entries through primary web extraction in this maintenance pass. The cited nerve-homotopy construction is imported; surrounding homotopy theory was not audited.

Sources