Alphabeta Math
CounterexampleConstruction: Literature-sourcedVerification: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6-luna)verified 2026-10-22 (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The trefoil exterior is Seifert-fibered

Statement refuted

Every compact exterior of a smooth knot in S3 is non-Seifert-fibered.

Counterexample description

Let S3={(z,w)∈C2:∣z∣2+∣w∣2=1} with the weighted circle action gθ(z,w)=(e3iθz,e2iθw), and let K(t)=2−1/2(e3it,e2it) for t∈R/(2πZ). The Clifford torus ∣z∣=∣w∣=2−1/2 separates S3 into two solid tori; K winds twice around the core of ∣z∣≤∣w∣ and three times around the core of ∣w∣≤∣z∣, so it is the standard (3,2) torus knot, the trefoil. Let q:S3→S3/S1 be the orbit map and choose a small closed disk D about q(K) disjoint from the axis orbits. Then N(K)=q−1(D) is an invariant solid torus neighborhood and EK=S3∖int⁡N(K) is Seifert-fibered over a disk with cone points of orders 2 and 3; a regular fiber is central in π1(EK).

Diagram

The disk marks the regular orbit removed to form the exterior. The two filled points mark the axis orbits, with their stabilizer orders. The proof uses the explicit circle action and does not depend on the drawing.

\begin{center} \begin{tikzpicture}[scale=1.15] \draw[thick] (0,0) circle (1.6); \fill[gray!15] (0.45,0.15) circle (0.33); \draw[thick] (0.45,0.15) circle (0.33); \fill (0,1.6) circle (2pt); \fill (0,-1.6) circle (2pt); \node at (0.45,0.15) {q(K)}; \node[right] at (0,1.6) {order 3}; \node[right] at (0,-1.6) {order 2}; \node at (0,-2.0) {quotient sphere; remove the shaded disk}; \end{tikzpicture} \end{center}

Facts & Assumptions

Given: S3={(z,w)∈C2:∣z∣2+∣w∣2=1}, the weighted circle action gθ(z,w)=(e3iθz,e2iθw), its orbit K(t)=2−1/2(e3it,e2it), the orbit map q:S3→S3/S1, a small closed disk D around q(K) disjoint from the two axis orbits, and the invariant tube N(K)=q−1(D) with exterior EK=S3∖int⁡N(K).

[F1]

Knot exterior defines the compact exterior by removing the interior of the chosen closed tube.

[F2]

Incompressibility, Seifert fibrations, and JSJ systems defines a Seifert fibration by local fibered-solid-torus models; multiplicity 1 fibers are regular, while multiplicity q>1 fibers are exceptional of order q.

[F3]

Thurston hyperbolization for atoroidal knot exteriors explicitly requires that the exterior not be Seifert-fibered.

Counterexample

1.1givenalgebraconstruct

The action preserves ∣z∣2+∣w∣2, so it acts smoothly on S3. The orbit of (2−1/2,2−1/2) is exactly K. A group element stabilizes this point only if 3θ and 2θ are both multiples of 2π; coprimality of 2 and 3 makes the stabilizer trivial. The regions ∣z∣≤∣w∣ and ∣w∣≤∣z∣ are solid tori, parametrized respectively by (z,w)=(z,1−∣z∣2η) and (z,w)=(1−∣w∣2η,w) with the disk coordinate bounded by 2−1/2 and η∈S1. The w coordinate is the core direction of the first solid torus and winds twice along K; the z coordinate is the core direction of the second and winds three times. This proves the claimed (3,2) torus-knot type. On the axis z=0 the stabilizer has order 2, and on the axis w=0 it has order 3.

2.1givenF1F2step 1.1construct

On zw≠0, write α=arg⁡z and β=arg⁡w modulo 2π. The integer coordinate change θ=α−β, ϕ=2α−3β has determinant −1 and is invertible on the phase torus. The circle action changes θ by its parameter and fixes ϕ, while r=∣z∣∈(0,1) is fixed; thus the quotient of this open set is the cylinder with coordinates (r,ϕ), and the inverse image of any disk D around q(K) in it is explicitly Sθ1×D. At r=0 and r=1 the phase circle collapses to one point at each end, so the full orbit space is a sphere; the two axis orbits have stabilizer orders 2 and 3. The complement of D is a disk with those two cone points. Its orbits give the fibers of EK, and [F2] identifies the axis fibers as exceptional of orders 2 and 3.

3.1givenstep 2.1construct

Choose a basepoint x on a regular fiber, let h be that fiber loop, and let γ be any loop in EK based at x. The map F:[0,1]2→EK defined by F(s,t)=g2πs(γ(t)) is well-defined because the tube is invariant. Its boundary represents hγh−1γ−1: the two vertical sides are γ and γ−1 since g0=g2π=id⁡, and the horizontal sides are the fiber loop and its reverse. The square contracts its boundary, so h commutes with [γ]. Since γ was arbitrary, the regular fiber class is central in π1(EK).

4.1F2F3step 2.1algebra∎

By [F3], a Seifert-fibered exterior does not satisfy the required non-Seifert-fibered hypothesis. Step 2.1 establishes that EK is Seifert-fibered, so this example refutes the statement that every knot exterior is non-Seifert-fibered and also fails that hypothesis of the hyperbolization contract.

Depends on

Used by

Nothing in the library uses this result yet.

Dependency tree · two levels

13 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources