How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Random-coordinate pullback extends every fair-coin product measure
Statement
Assume ZFC. Supply a transitive set model of ZFC containing a strongly compact cardinal . In let be the sigma-algebra on generated by finite-coordinate cylinders, let be its fair-coin product probability, and let be its probability algebra. Suppose satisfies . Supply an -generic filter on , and assume separately that satisfies ZFC and preserves ground cardinals. Then for every cardinal of there is in a countably additive probability on the full power set of extending its standard fair-coin product measure. Its null ideal is closed under families indexed by every ordinal in . Consequently, if additionally satisfies , then satisfies PMEA with null closure below its continuum.
The ground and extension product measures have their respective cylinder sigma-algebras as domains; no assertion that all topological Borel sets have countable coordinate support is used. Preservation of ZFC, ground cardinals and the continuum equality are premises here, not conclusions or a formal relative-consistency transfer.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: with all the separate premises of the statement. Ground constructions in the proof are performed inside .
For every ground cardinal , a fine complete ultrafilter supplies coordinates for ; finitely many are distinct and avoid any fixed support of size below on a member of the ultrafilter. (Fine-measure coordinates avoiding small supports)
A supplied generic extension has a measure graph on all its subsets of the ground set , extending the ultrafilter measure, countably additive for extension sequences and null-closed for extension families indexed by any ground ordinal below . (Solovay measure on all ground-set subsets in a supplied generic extension)
A Boolean vector has an almost-everywhere unique density characterized by , where is the ultrafilter-large constant value of . (Solovay densities and localized small null joins)
The measure value of a represented subset is the generic evaluation of its density; constant densities evaluate to their constants. (Generic evaluation of bounded measurable functions by rational cuts, Solovay measure on all ground-set subsets in a supplied generic extension)
A generic Boolean filter is a proper ultrafilter and selects joins of ground families. (Generic Boolean filters select ground-model joins)
The probability algebra of a probability space is complete and countably additive, with classes represented by measurable sets modulo null sets. (Probability algebras, arbitrary joins and the countable chain condition)
Under AC, consistent finite-dimensional laws on arbitrary standard-Borel coordinate spaces have a unique probability on the cylinder sigma-algebra. (Assuming the Axiom of Choice, Kolmogorov extension for arbitrary families of standard Borel coordinate spaces)
Finite measures agreeing on a generating pi-system and on the whole space agree on the generated sigma-algebra. (Finite measures agreeing on a generating pi-system and on the whole space are equal)
AC is available in both supplied models; it supplies countable support choices and the stated measure and ultrafilter prerequisites. (The Axiom of Choice)
Proof
The discrete two-point space is standard Borel: its discrete metric is complete and its finite underlying set is a countable dense set. On a finite coordinate set , assign mass to each point of . Summing over the coordinates removed by a restriction verifies consistency, including the empty coordinate set with its one point. F7 therefore supplies the ground product probability, and F6 supplies its probability algebra. The same construction is available for every coordinate ordinal inside , since ZFC in is an explicit premise.
Every ground cylinder-measurable set has a countable support in the stronger form for a countable and a cylinder-measurable . Indeed the class of sets with this property contains all finite cylinders and is closed under complement. Given a sequence of such sets, use F9 to choose their supports and bases; the union of their countable supports is countable under AC. Each restriction map from to a coordinate subproduct is measurable, since inverse images of finite cylinders are finite cylinders, and inverse images preserve complement and countable union. Pulling the bases back to and taking their countable union proves the union closure. Generated-sigma minimality proves the assertion. This concerns , and hence suffices for a representative of every Boolean condition.
For each , let be the class of the event whose -bit is one. F5 decides exactly one of ; define exactly when . This is a function in : the ground Boolean name evaluates to its one-set, and ZFC in forms the characteristic-function graph. Check-name evaluation and the vector-name construction are included in F2. No choice of a representative generic point of the ground probability space is required.
Fix a finite partial function with . For every cylinder-measurable one has . To prove it, the left side as a function of is a finite measure: inverse images preserve disjoint countable unions and intersecting with the fixed measurable cylinder does also. The right side is a finite measure. Their total masses are both . On a finite cylinder in , the identity is the finite uniform marginal calculation of step 1.1, using disjointness of and . Finite cylinders together with the empty set form a generating pi-system, so F8 proves the identity. The identical uniqueness argument without gives . Thus for every condition representative supported on .
Fix a cardinal in . Cardinal preservation makes a ground cardinal. Put in , and take the ground from F1. F2 applies because satisfies the continuum bound in the statement; write for its measure on . In define for . Replacement forms . Define for every . Power Set, Separation and Replacement in the assumed ZFC model form this whole function. Inverse images preserve empty sets, whole spaces, unions and intersections, so F2 gives total mass one, countable additivity, and null closure for every extension family indexed by a ground ordinal below . Cardinal preservation and unchanged ordinals make these exactly the required bounds in .
Let be a finite coordinate prescription on , and put . Every such finite ordinal/bit datum belongs to , by transitivity and closure under finite set constructions. For let be the Boolean meet of when and their complements when , over . This is one ground vector in . F5 identifies its represented subset exactly with . Fix any and a measurable representative supported on a countable ground from step 2.1. Since , F1 gives a -member on which the finitely many coordinates are distinct and outside . At every such , the vector element is the class of a consistent cylinder on exactly coordinates disjoint from . Step 3.1 gives .
The defining large-fibre rule in F3 now gives for every , including zero. The constant density has exactly these integrals, so almost-everywhere uniqueness in F3 identifies it with . F4 evaluates it to in , whence . For the vector is constantly one and this also gives total mass one; incompatible simultaneous bit prescriptions instead give the empty cylinder and zero.
In , the restriction of to the cylinder sigma-algebra and the standard product probability from step 1.1 are finite measures agreeing on all finite cylinders and on the whole space. F8 makes them equal on that sigma-algebra. Step 3.2 already supplies on its full extension power set, with the required null closure. If the additional continuum equality holds, any family of fewer than continuum many null sets in can be indexed, using AC there, by an ordinal below ; its union is null by that closure. This proves the final PMEA assertion under all the stated premises, without inferring any of those forcing-preservation premises from genericity alone.
Depends on
- Fine-measure coordinates avoiding small supports
- Solovay measure on all ground-set subsets in a supplied generic extension
- Solovay densities and localized small null joins
- Generic evaluation of bounded measurable functions by rational cuts
- Generic Boolean filters select ground-model joins
- Probability algebras, arbitrary joins and the countable chain condition
- Assuming the Axiom of Choice, Kolmogorov extension for arbitrary families of standard Borel coordinate spaces
- Finite measures agreeing on a generating pi-system and on the whole space are equal
- The Axiom of Choice
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
49 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.