Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6-sol)audited 2026-09-27
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

A finite normal extension is separable over its purely inseparable fixed field

Statement

Let M/F be a finite normal field extension and let E=MAut⁡(M/F) be the fixed field of its F-automorphisms. Then E/F is finite purely inseparable and M/E is finite Galois, hence in particular separable. If F has characteristic zero, then E=F. The argument uses only finite groups, finite root sets and finite generating lists, so it is choice-free.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: a finite normal extension M/F, with G:=Aut⁡(M/F) and fixed field E:=MG.

[L2]

For algebraic a over a field F there is a unique monic irreducible minimal polynomial ma∈F[x], and f(a)=0 exactly when ma∣f (The evaluation kernel and the unique monic irreducible minimal polynomial of an algebraic element).

[L3]

A nonzero polynomial of degree n over an integral domain has at most n roots in that domain (A nonzero polynomial of degree n over an integral domain has at most n distinct roots).

[L4]

Aut⁡(M/F) is a group of F-automorphisms of M and MG is the subfield of G-fixed elements, with F⊆MG⊆M (Relative field automorphisms and Aut⁡(K/F), The fixed field KG of a group of field automorphisms).

[L5]

If G is a finite group of automorphisms of a field K, then [K:KG]≥∣G∣ (Artin's fixed-field lower bound [K:KG]≥∣G∣) and [K:KG]≤∣G∣ (Artin's fixed-field upper bound [K:KG]≤∣G∣).

[L7]

α∈M is separable over E when it is algebraic over E with separable minimal polynomial, and M/E is separable when every element is separable; a polynomial is separable when it has no repeated root in a splitting field (Separable algebraic elements and separable extensions, Repeated roots in extension fields and separable polynomials). A finite extension is Galois when it is normal and separable (Finite Galois extensions and Gal⁡(K/F)).

[L9]

If M/F is normal with M=F(α1,…,αm) and pj is the minimal polynomial of αj over F, then M is a splitting field over F of p1⋯pm (A normal extension generated by finitely many elements is the splitting field of the product of their minimal polynomials).

[L10]

If σ:F→F′ is a field isomorphism, 0≠f∈F[x] and E/F, E′/F′ are splitting fields of f and σ∗f, then σ extends to an isomorphism E→E′ (A base-field isomorphism extends to an isomorphism between splitting fields of corresponding polynomials).

[L11]

In characteristic p>0 every nonconstant irreducible f∈F[x] is uniquely f(x)=g(xpe) with g irreducible, separable and e maximal (In characteristic p, every irreducible polynomial is uniquely g(xpe) with g irreducible and separable); in characteristic zero every irreducible polynomial is separable, because an irreducible polynomial is separable exactly when its derivative is nonzero and the derivative of a nonconstant polynomial of characteristic zero does not vanish (An irreducible polynomial over a field is separable exactly when its derivative is nonzero, Repeated roots in extension fields and separable polynomials).

[L12]

In a field of characteristic p>0 the map z↦zpn is injective (Frobenius x↦xp is an injective endomorphism in characteristic p, and an automorphism for finite fields), and a finite extension in characteristic p>0 is purely inseparable when every element satisfies αpn∈F for some n (Purely inseparable algebraic extensions).

[L13]

If a is algebraic over F with minimal polynomial ma of degree n, then F(a) consists of the elements c0+c1a+⋯+cn−1an−1 and is isomorphic to F[x]/(ma) (A simple algebraic extension is its minimal-polynomial quotient and has power basis 1,a,…,an−1 and degree n).

Proof

Proof technique: direct. 1.1 The group G=Aut⁡(M/F) is finite. By [L1] choose α1,…,αn∈M with M=F(α1,…,αn); by [L8] and [L2] each αi has a minimal polynomial mi over F. Every σ∈G fixes F and is a field homomorphism, so it is determined by the images σ(α1),…,σ(αn), since these generate M over F; and σ(αi) is a root of mi, because applying σ to mi(αi)=0 gives mi(σ(αi))=0 as σ fixes the coefficients of mi. By [L3] the polynomial mi has at most deg⁡mi roots in M, so the map σ↦(σ(α1),…,σ(αn)) injects G into the finite product of these root sets; hence G is finite. [L1, L2, L3, L8, construct]

2.1

The fixed field E=MG satisfies F⊆E⊆M by [L4], and [M:E]=∣G∣: both bounds [M:E]≥∣G∣ and [M:E]≤∣G∣ hold by [L5], applied to the finite group G of automorphisms of M. In particular M/E is a finite extension of degree ∣G∣.

L4L5step 1.1algebra
3.1

The extension M/E is finite Galois. It is finite by step 2.1. For α∈M let αG:={σ(α):σ∈G} be its finite G-orbit and put f:=∏β∈αG(T−β)∈M[T], a monic polynomial of degree ∣αG∣ with f(α)=0 whose roots in M are the distinct elements of the orbit. Every σ∈G permutes αG, hence fixes the coefficients of f, which are the elementary symmetric functions of the orbit; those coefficients therefore lie in E=MG, that is f∈E[T]. It follows that the minimal polynomial m of α over E, whose existence and divisibility property are given by [L2], divides f in E[T]; being a divisor of a polynomial that is a product of distinct linear factors, m itself is a product of distinct linear factors over M. Thus the minimal polynomial over E of every α∈M splits over M with distinct roots, so M/E is normal by [L6] and separable by [L7]. Therefore M/E is finite Galois by [L7].

L2L6L7step 2.1algebra
4.1

The extension E/F is purely inseparable, and E=F in characteristic zero. Since M/F is finite it is algebraic by [L8], and by [L1] and [L9] M is a splitting field over F of the product p1⋯pn of the minimal polynomials of a finite generating list of M/F. Let a∈E with minimal polynomial q over F, and let b∈M be any root of q. The assignment a↦b defines an isomorphism F(a)→F(b) of F-extensions: the F-algebra map F[T]→M with T↦b kills q and so factors through F[T]/(q)≅F(a) by [L13], and it is injective because F(a) is a field. Moreover M is a splitting field of p1⋯pn over both F(a) and F(b), since all roots of the pj lie in M and generate it over F, hence also over each of these intermediate fields. By [L10] applied over the base field F(a) the isomorphism a↦b extends to an isomorphism M→M, which is an F-automorphism because it fixes F; so b=σ(a)=a for this σ∈G, since a lies in the fixed field E. Hence q has exactly one distinct root in M, and by normality of M/F it has all its roots in M by [L6]. If F has characteristic p>0, write q(T)=g(Tpe) as in [L11] with g irreducible and separable; the distinct roots of q in M correspond bijectively to the roots of g in M, because z↦zpe is injective by [L12], so g has exactly one root and deg⁡g=1; writing g(T)=T−β with β∈F gives q(T)=Tpe−β and hence ape=β∈F. Thus every element of E has a p-power in F, so E/F is purely inseparable by [L12]. If instead F has characteristic zero, then the irreducible q is separable by [L11], so q has deg⁡q distinct roots in M by [L7]; having exactly one root forces deg⁡q=1 and a∈F. Hence E=F in characteristic zero. This proves all three clauses of the statement.

L1L6L7L8L9L10L11L12L13step 2.1cases∎

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

69 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources