Alphabeta Math
PropositionStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedaudited 2026-09-22
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The roots form a reduced crystallographic Euclidean root system

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let g be a finite-dimensional complex semisimple Lie algebra with Cartan subalgebra h, root set Φ=Φ(g,h) and Killing form B (Root and root space, Killing form). Let E:=spanRΦh,hR:=spanR{hα:αΦ} be the real span of the roots and the real span of the coroots (Coroot of a Lie-algebra root). Then:

(i) every λE is real valued on hR, and restriction is a linear isomorphism EHomR(hR,R);

(ii) hR is a real form of h, that is h=hRihR, and the Killing form restricted to hR is positive definite;

(iii) the formula (λ,μ):=B(Hλ,Hμ)(λ,μE), where HλhR is the vector with B(Hλ,H)=λ(H) for all HhR (Killing-dual vector of a root), defines a positive definite inner product on E, and for all roots α,β 2(β,α)(α,α)=β(hα)Z;

(iv) with this inner product, (E,Φ) is a reduced crystallographic Euclidean root system in the sense of Reduced crystallographic Euclidean root system, and for every root α the abstract reflection xx2(x,α)(α,α)α of that definition agrees with the reflection sα(λ)=λλ(hα)α of Root reflection defined by a coroot;

(v) if Δ={α1,,αr} is the base of a positive system of (E,Φ) (Positive systems and simple roots), then Δ is a basis of E and {hα1,,hαr} is a basis of hR, hence also a basis of h over C.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The Axiom of Choice, such g,h,Φ and the Killing form B of Killing form.

[A1]

The Axiom of Choice is assumed; it enters only through the root-space suppliers [L1], [L2] and [L6], whose contracts carry the assumption (The Axiom of Choice).

[L1]

Φ is finite and g=hαΦgα; the root spaces are the eigenspaces of the adH with Hh, and h=g0, the zero eigenspace (Root-space decomposition, Root and root space).

[L2]

Every root space is one-dimensional, and {Hh:α(H)=0 for all αΦ}=0, so the roots span h; in particular Φ contains a basis of h (Root spaces of a complex semisimple Lie algebra are one-dimensional, The center is the common kernel of the roots inside the Cartan subalgebra).

[L3]

Bh is nondegenerate, the map hh, HB(H,), is an isomorphism, and for a root α the Killing-dual vector Hα satisfies α(Hα)=B(Hα,Hα)0; the coroot hα=2Hα/α(Hα) satisfies α(hα)=2 (Orthogonality of root spaces and nondegeneracy on the Cartan subalgebra, Killing-dual vector of a root, The Killing length of a root is nonzero, Coroot of a Lie-algebra root).

[L4]

For the coroots, α(hβ)=α,β is an integer for all roots α,β (Cartan integers are integers).

[L5]

B(x,y)=tr(adxady) on g, every adH with Hh is diagonalisable, and the trace of an endomorphism whose characteristic polynomial factors as i(xλi) equals iλi (Killing form, Toral and maximal toral subalgebras, If χT(x)=i<n(xλi) in F[x], then tr(T)=i<nλi: trace is the sum of the eigenvalues counted with algebraic multiplicity).

[L6]

For roots α,β the reflected functional sα(β)=ββ(hα)α is again a root, αΦ, and the only scalar multiples of α that are roots are α and α (Root reflections preserve the root set, Root reflection defined by a coroot, Roots of a complex semisimple Lie algebra form a reduced crystallographic root system, The only scalar multiples of a root that are roots are plus or minus the root).

[L7]

For a reduced crystallographic root system the base of a positive system is a basis of the ambient space (Reduced crystallographic Euclidean root system, Positive systems and simple roots, Simple roots form a signed integral basis).

Proof

technique · direct
1.1

By [L1] and [L2], Φ is finite, dimgα=1 for every αΦ, and g=hαΦgα with h=g0 the zero eigenspace; hence for Hh the operator adH is diagonalisable on g with eigenvalues α(H), each occurring on the one-dimensional space gα, together with the eigenvalue 0 on h.

A1L1L2L5
1.2

The roots span h over C: a proper subspace of h has nonzero annihilator in h, so if Φ did not span h there would be 0Hh with α(H)=0 for every α, contradicting [L2].

A1L2
2.1

Fix αΦ and put c=α(Hα)=B(Hα,Hα)0. Since Hα=(c/2)hα, [L4] gives β(Hα)=(c/2)β(hα) for every root β. Applying the trace formula of [L5] to Hα and using step 1.1 yields c=B(Hα,Hα)=βΦβ(Hα)2=c24βΦβ(hα)2. The final sum is a positive integer because it contains the term α(hα)2=4; division by c0 therefore gives c=4βΦβ(hα)2>0. Thus hα=(2/c)Hα is a nonzero real multiple of Hα.

L3L4L5step 1.1
3.1

By [L3] the map φ:hh, φ(λ)=Hλ with B(Hλ,H)=λ(H) for all Hh, is a C-linear isomorphism; since the Hα are the images of the roots, step 1.2 shows that {Hα:αΦ} spans h over C, and step 2.1 shows that the coroots hα have the same complex span. Hence hR spans h over C.

A1L3step 1.2step 2.1
4.1

Every αΦ is real valued on hR, because a real linear combination H=βcβhβ of coroots satisfies α(H)=βcβα(hβ)R by [L4]; consequently, for HhR, [L5] and step 1.1 give B(H,H)=tr(adH2)=αΦα(H)20, and if B(H,H)=0 then α(H)=0 for all α, so H=0 by [L2]; thus BhR is positive definite.

A1L2L4L5step 1.1step 3.1
5.1

The form BhR is positive definite by step 4.1; in particular hRihR=0, because a vector in the intersection has α(H)RiR={0} for every root by step 4.1 and then H=0 by [L2]; moreover hR+ihR is a C-subspace of h containing the spanning set hR of step 3.1, hence equals h, so h=hRihR and dimRhR=dimCh.

A1step 3.1step 4.1
6.1

Let λE=spanRΦ, say λ=αcαα with real cα; then λ(H)R for every HhR by step 4.1, so restriction is a real linear map EHomR(hR,R), and it is injective because a functional vanishing on hR vanishes on the C-span of hR, which is h by step 5.1; since dimREdimCh=dimCh=dimRhR=dimRHomR(hR,R) by [L2] and step 5.1, the injection is an isomorphism, and Φ spans the real space E. This proves (i).

A1L2step 5.1
7.1

For λ,μE define (λ,μ):=B(Hλ,Hμ), where HλhR is characterised by B(Hλ,H)=λ(H) for all HhR; this is bilinear, symmetric and positive definite by step 4.1, so it is an inner product on E. This proves the first assertion of (iii).

A1step 4.1step 6.1
8.1

For roots α,β we have HαhR and 2(β,α)(α,α)=2B(Hβ,Hα)B(Hα,Hα)=2β(Hα)α(Hα)=β(2Hαα(Hα))=β(hα)Z by [L3], [L4] and step 7.1; this is the crystallographic identity in (iii), and it identifies the abstract reflection xx2(x,α)(α,α)α with sα(x)=xx(hα)α of [L6].

A1L3L4step 7.1
9.1

The set ΦE is finite, consists of nonzero vectors and spans E by step 6.1; the reflection identity of step 8.1 shows that sα(Φ)Φ for every α, because sα(β) is a root for all roots β by [L6] and sα is involutive, so sα(Φ)=Φ; the crystallographic integrality condition is step 8.1; and reducedness holds because the only scalar multiples of a root that are roots are α and α, both of which lie in Φ, by [L6]; hence (E,Φ) is a reduced crystallographic Euclidean root system whose reflections are exactly the reflections sα of [L6]. This proves (iv).

A1L6step 6.1step 8.1
10.1

Let Δ={α1,,αr} be the base of a positive system of (E,Φ); by [L7] it is a basis of E, so under the isomorphism EhR, λHλ, of step 6.1 the vectors Hα1,,Hαr form a basis of hR, and since hαi is a nonzero real multiple of Hαi by [L3], the coroots hα1,,hαr also form a basis of hR; because h=hRihR by step 5.1, that basis is a C-basis of h as well, which proves (v) and completes the proof.

L3L7step 5.1step 6.1

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

49 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources