How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Worked simultaneity gap of the traveler's two momentary rest frames at the turn
Example
Fix reals , , and . This is a mathematical proper-time computation: the inertial chart has metric and ; the stay-at-home worldline is for ; the traveler is on and on . All clock readings below mean the based mathematical proper-time values of these curves, initialized to zero at (Proper time along a future timelike worldline, Total proper time of a piecewise C^1 future timelike worldline), so the stay-at-home reading equals ; the turn event is ; the two momentary inertial rest frames of the traveler are the charts and of the boosts with velocities and , both with the same origin as . Explicitly their bases are and for ; the two charts are defined from these bases and origin by Inertial frames and inertial charts of the affine Minkowski model.
(a) Outbound rest frame. The chart has ; at this is , so the slice through meets the stay-at-home worldline at , that is , i.e. coordinate time .
(b) Inbound rest frame. The chart has ; at this is , so the slice through meets the stay-at-home worldline at , that is , i.e. coordinate time .
(c) The gap. The two momentary frames assign to the stay-at-home clock 'at the time of the turn' the two different readings and ; their difference is , the simultaneity gap.
(d) Reconciliation. The traveler's own clock reads at the turn and at the reunion; during each leg his momentary frame assigns to the stay-at-home clock the advance (outbound from to ; inbound from to ); with the gap the total assignment is , the stay-at-home reading at the reunion, while the traveler reads ; the two readings differ by .
(e) The two rest frames are distinct. Their relative boost parameter is the collinear composition , so the traveler's momentary inertial frame changes at the turn.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: An inertial frame with chart , metric and ; , , ; the two explicitly parametrized worldlines and mathematical proper-time readings of the Example, the turn event , the reunion event , and the boost charts , of the lemma Coordinate formulas of a boost: clock rates, rod lengths, simultaneity and velocity transformation for velocities and , both with origin .
Boost chart transitions (Coordinate formulas of a boost: clock rates, rod lengths, simultaneity and velocity transformation): for inertial frames with a common origin whose bases are related by a boost of velocity with along a common spatial direction one has , with ; and along the worldline at rest in the clock rate is .
Simultaneity slices (Simultaneity slices and rest distance relative to a future unit timelike vector, Inertial frames and inertial charts of the affine Minkowski model): for a future unit timelike vector the slice through an event is ; in a chart the slice of constant through an event consists of the events with that coordinate, and coordinate differences of events are the coordinates of their displacements.
Boosts (The passive Lorentz boost with parameter beta, The passive boost is a proper orthochronous Lorentz map with inverse B(-beta), Linear and affine Lorentz maps, and the Lorentz group): for the passive boost is a proper orthochronous Lorentz map, so it maps inertial bases to inertial bases and its charts are inertial charts.
Collinear composition (Collinear boost composition and the relativistic velocity-addition law): .
Proper times (Proper time along a future timelike worldline, Total proper time of a piecewise C^1 future timelike worldline): a straight leg with constant tangent over a parameter interval of length has proper time , and the two-leg total is ; the stay-at-home worldline has tangent , so its based proper time is . This identifies the mathematical reading, without any physical-clock assumption.
Arithmetic, roots and order (Square roots exist: a unique with ; the positives are , Squaring is monotone on the nonnegatives, Ordered field): all the rational evaluations below are exact; and .
Verification
By [L1] with and the outbound chart is and the inbound chart is ; both are inertial charts by [L3], and the stay-at-home worldline has with clock reading the coordinate time by [L5].
For (a): the turn event has and , so ; the slice meets at , that is and clock reading .
For (b): ; the slice meets at , that is and clock reading .
For (e): the outbound frame is obtained from by a boost of dimensionless parameter and the inbound frame by one of parameter ; the boost from the inbound to the outbound momentary frame is therefore the collinear composition of parameters and in the composed description, whose parameter is by [L4]; since , the two momentary inertial frames are distinct.
For (c): the two readings differ by , and , so the gap equals .
For (d): by [L5] the traveler's clock reads at the turn and at the reunion; the outbound frame assigns to the stay-at-home clock the advance from to , namely , the inbound frame assigns the advance from to , again , so with the gap the total assigned reading is , equal to the stay-at-home clock reading at the reunion, while the traveler reads ; the readings differ by .
All the numbers of (a)-(e) are exact rational evaluations of the model's chart transitions, slices and proper-time values: the simultaneity gap of the traveler's two momentary frames at the turn is , and the leg-by-leg assignment reproduces the stay-at-home reading. The example makes no empirical claim; it displays a reconciliation of the traveler's momentary-frame accounts within the model.
Depends on
Coordinate formulas of a boost: clock rates, rod lengths, simultaneity and velocity transformation
Collinear boost composition and the relativistic velocity-addition law
Simultaneity slices and rest distance relative to a future unit timelike vector
Inertial frames and inertial charts of the affine Minkowski model
The passive Lorentz boost with parameter beta
Linear and affine Lorentz maps, and the Lorentz group
Proper time along a future timelike worldline
Total proper time of a piecewise C^1 future timelike worldline
Square roots exist: a unique with ; the positives are
Squaring is monotone on the nonnegatives
Ordered field
The passive boost is a proper orthochronous Lorentz map with inverse B(-beta)
Dependency tree · 2 levels
Sources
- B. Crowell, Special Relativity, revision 2020-12-10 (author-published undergraduate textbook): section 1.3.3 'The gamma factor' pp. 25-26 (figure s, the reunion discussion and the symmetry/asymmetry discussion); signature (+---) converted to (-+++) and c = 1 formulas converted to x^0 = c t
- S. M. Carroll, Lecture Notes on General Relativity, arXiv:gr-qc/9712019v1 (1997), Chapter 3 pp. 71-72 (the twin remark and the role of simultaneity conventions)
- H. S. Reall, Mathematical Tripos Part III General Relativity (Cambridge, October 12, 2022), sections 2.1-2.3 pp. 25-30 (inertial frames, Lorentz transformations and the straight-line maximum); Internet Archive copy of the original https://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/hsr1000/part3_gr_lectures.pdf