Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedprecheck passjudge pass (gpt-6-luna)verified 2026-11-04 (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Every nonzero weak positive-integral-level simple affine module contains a simple ordinary submodule

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let g be finite-dimensional complex simple with its invariant form normalized by (α,α)=2 for long roots, let ℓ∈Z>0, and let Lℓ(g) be the simple affine VOA with its noncritical Sugawara conformal vector. Every nonzero weak Lℓ(g)-module contains a nonzero simple ordinary Lℓ(g)-submodule.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A nonzero weak module M with the indicated simple affine VOA action.

[A1]

Assume the Axiom of Choice, as required by Complete reducibility of integrable kac moody o modules for set-indexed families of singular weight-space bases.

[F1]

Uniform nilpotence for root currents of positive-integral-level simple affine VOAs supplies a finite basis B of g such that, on every weak module, an is locally nilpotent for every a∈B and n∈Z. It also proves akNℓu=0 whenever aju=0 for every j>k.

[F2]

Untwisted affine central extension gives [bn,ak]=[b,a]n+k+nℓB(b,a)δn,−kI for current modes. The central term is zero when n,k>0.

[F3]

Weyl's complete reducibility theorem applies to finite-dimensional g-modules, and Finite-dimensional representations of sl2 identifies highest-weight strings and their highest vectors.

[F4]

Complete reducibility of integrable kac moody o modules assumes AC and a finite symmetrizable GCM, and decomposes an integrable module in category O into simple highest-weight modules. Kac moody category o and Universal property and pbw character of kac moody verma modules give finite weight spaces and finite-cone support for a cyclic affine highest-weight module.

[F5]

Simple positive-integral-level affine vertex operator algebra realizes Lℓ(g) as a current-generated quotient of the universal affine vertex algebra, and Universal affine vertex algebras exist at every complex level gives its current fields. Module for an ordinary vertex algebra supplies lower truncation and module Jacobi. Lower truncation makes the current action restricted. Sugawara modes and their normal ordering gives 2(ℓ+h∨)L0=∑axa(0)xa(0)+2∑n>0,axa(−n)xa(n) on restricted modules; Sugawara modes act on affine currents with weight one and Sugawara modes satisfy Virasoro at every noncritical complex level give [L0,an]=−nan and the noncritical conformal action. The denominator is nonzero because ℓ>0 and h∨>0.

[F6]

Ordinary module requires semisimple L0, finite-dimensional eigenspaces and real-part lower boundedness.

[F7]

Finite semisimple PBW and highest-weight construction supplies the finite-dimensional PBW ordering, and Schur’s lemma for irreducible Lie-algebra representations makes any endomorphism of a finite-dimensional irreducible complex g-module scalar.

Proof

1.1F1givenalgebra

For u∈M∖{0}, put E(u)=span⁡{anu:a∈B, n>0}. Lower truncation and finiteness of B make E(u) finite-dimensional. Choose nonzero u minimizing d(u)=dim⁡E(u). If d(u)=0, then u is already killed by all positive currents. Otherwise let k>0 be the largest index for which aku≠0 for some a∈B, choose such a, and let r≥1 be maximal with akru≠0. Set v=akru.

2.1F1F2step 1.1algebra

In the remaining case d(u)>0, for every b∈B and n>0, expand bnakru by repeatedly commuting bn past ak. The term with no commutator is akrbnu. Every other term contains a current mode of index n+jk>k for some j≥1. Move that mode right past the remaining ak factors; each new commutator has still larger positive index, so induction on the number of remaining factors reduces every term to one with a mode of index >k acting directly on u, which vanishes by maximality of k. Thus bnv=akrbnu and E(v)⊆akrE(u). But aku≠0 lies in E(u) and is killed by akr, so dim⁡E(v)<dim⁡E(u), contradicting minimality. Therefore the minimum is zero and Ω={w∈M:anw=0 for every a∈g,n>0} is nonzero.

3.1F1F3F7step 2.1algebra

The subspace Ω is stable under the zero-mode action of g: for b∈g, anb0w=b0anw+[an,b0]w=0, since [an,b0]=[a,b]n and n>0. For nonzero w∈Ω, Order the finite basis B as a1,…,as. PBW [F7] spans U(g)w by ordered zero-mode words. The powers of as(0) on w span a finite-dimensional space by local nilpotence [F1]. Recursively take powers of ai(0) on a finite spanning set for the suffix space: each string is finite, and their finite sum is finite-dimensional. After the s basis elements this contains every ordered PBW word, so U(g)w is finite-dimensional. It is a nonzero finite-dimensional g-module inside Ω. By [F3], it contains a nonzero finite-dimensional irreducible summand; choose a highest vector v there and put H=U(g)v. Then H is that irreducible summand, and v is killed by all positive loop modes and all positive finite-root spaces.

4.1A1F1F4F5F7step 3.1algebra

Positive loop modes kill v, so the quadratic Sugawara formula in [F5] shows that L0v is a linear combination of zero-mode products applied to v, hence belongs to H. The commutator [L0,x0]=0 then makes H invariant under L0; since H is finite-dimensional irreducible, Schur's lemma [F7] gives L0∣H=hI for some h∈C. On R=U(g^)v, define the affine derivation d=−L0; [F5] gives [d,xn]=nxn, and v is a weight vector for the full affine Cartan. By The affine simple root alpha zero is delta minus the highest root, let θ be the highest finite root. For the untwisted affine matrix A^, write aij=αj(hi), with node-zero data α0=δ−θ, h0=c−θ∨, and finite simple pairs αi,hi=αi∨ [F5], with δ∣h⊕Cc=0, δ(d)=1, and αi(c)=0. Under the finite invariant-form identification of the Cartan dual with its root span, αi∨=2αi/(αi,αi) and θ∨=2θ/(θ,θ). Normalize the finite root inner product so (θ,θ)=2, put β0=−θ, βi=αi, τ0=1, and τi=(αi,αi)/2>0. For finite indices, τiaij=(αi,αj)=τjaji. For j>0, a0j=αj(h0)=−(αj,θ) and aj0=α0(hj)=−2(θ,αj)/(αj,αj), so τ0a0j=τjaj0; and a00=α0(h0)=2. Hence A^ is a finite symmetrizable GCM, and the matrix hypothesis of [F4] holds. The module R is integrable because every affine simple raising or lowering generator is one of the root-current modes covered by [F1]. It is generated by the affine highest vector v of weight λ, so Verma PBW gives finite-dimensional weight spaces and support in λ−Q+; hence R lies in affine category O. By [F4] and [A1], R is a direct sum of simple highest-weight modules. Its weight-λ space is the line Cv. Each projection of v to a simple summand is singular; in a simple highest-weight module every singular vector is in its highest line, since a singular vector generates the whole simple module and PBW bounds the generated weights below its weight. Therefore exactly one summand has a nonzero projection of v; because v generates R, that summand is all of R. To see R is a VOA submodule, note it is stable under every current mode by its definition. For a current state a and a state b whose modes preserve R, module Jacobi gives

((a(r)b)M)(m)u=∑j≥0(−1)j(rj)a(r−j)Mb(m+j)Mu−(−1)r∑j≥0(−1)j(rj)b(m+r−j)Ma(j)Mu.

On fixed u∈R, lower truncation of the rightmost factor makes both sums finite, and each term preserves R. Induction over current-generated states shows every state mode preserves R. Affine simplicity then implies VOA simplicity.

5.1F1F4F5F6F7step 4.1algebra∎

Affine PBW orders R as negative-loop words followed by zero modes on v; positive loops kill v. Equivalently it is spanned by negative-loop words applied to the finite-dimensional space H. A word of total loop degree q raises the L0 eigenvalue from h by q by [F5]. There are finitely many ordered negative-loop monomials of fixed total degree (finitely many mode indices summing to q and finitely many basis vectors of g), each applied to finite-dimensional H. Thus the L0 eigenspaces are finite-dimensional and the spectrum is contained in h+Z≥0. PBW spanning by L0 eigenvectors makes L0 semisimple, and this spectrum is real-part lower bounded; [F6] makes the simple weak submodule an ordinary module.

Depends on

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Sources