How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Small oscillations at a strict minimum: the linearized model, its normal modes and the Lyapunov stability of the nonlinear equilibrium
A mechanical system in a chart at a strict local minimum of its potential: the assigned small-oscillation quadratic model with mass metric M(q_0) and stiffness the Hessian D^2 U(q_0) (symmetric and non-negative), the identification of that model with the derivative linearization of the mechanical field, the complete normal-mode classification of the linearized motions with frequencies sqrt(lambda_i) and no exponential directions, and the Lyapunov stability of the nonlinear equilibrium by exact energy conservation. The stability conclusion is a statement about the declared chart model; it asserts no asymptotic attraction, no measured frequency, no particular physical system and no empirical claim, and the accuracy of the linear model as an approximation of the nonlinear motion is a separate finite-time statement on this page.
Statement
Use the fixed coordinate, time and energy units and numerical matrix convention of The coupled quadratic oscillator model: mass metric, stiffness, generalized force, modal vocabulary and the small-oscillation model at a mechanical equilibrium. Every displayed matrix identity and phase norm is in those numerical coordinates; physical positions, velocities, modal amplitudes, frequencies and energies are recovered by the stated fixed scale factors. This does not change the set of physical motions.
Adopt the mechanical system in a chart of The mechanical first-order field, Lagrangian and energy of a configuration-dependent kinetic metric in a chart with kinetic metric field of class , symmetric positive definite at every point of the open set , and potential of class ; write for its mechanical vector field on . Let be a strict local minimum of : and there is with and for . Let and . Then:
- is symmetric and non-negative, and the small-oscillation model at of clause (d) of The coupled quadratic oscillator model: mass metric, stiffness, generalized force, modal vocabulary and the small-oscillation model at a mechanical equilibrium — the coupled quadratic model with mass metric matrix , stiffness and zero generalized force, in the displacement coordinates — is an oscillatory model in the sense of clause (e) of that definition;
- the linearization of at is and for a curve of class on an interval with nonempty interior the following are equivalent: is a motion of the small-oscillation model, on , and solves the linear system on ;
- the motions of the small-oscillation model are exactly the modal superpositions of clause 2 of The free coupled quadratic model: global existence, the complete modal classification, mode energies, intrinsic degenerate mode subspaces, boundedness and the unstable direction with every modal stiffness : there are no exponential pure- families, every oscillatory frequency is , and the pure- motions of a degenerate stiffness are the solutions of with values in the intrinsic subspace ;
- is a Lyapunov stable equilibrium of the nonlinear mechanical system: for every with there is such that every maximal solution of with exists for all and stays within distance of .
No asymptotic attraction, no all-time validity of the linear model as an approximation of the nonlinear motion, and no measured frequency is asserted.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The metric field , the potential , the strict local minimum , the mechanical field , and the data , of the statement.
Hessian at a strict minimum (The Hessian matrix and critical points of a scalar field, The Hessian of a scalar field is symmetric, A C² local minimum has vanishing gradient and positive semidefinite Hessian): is the symmetric Hessian matrix of at the critical point and satisfies for all .
Derivative linearization (Linearisation of the mechanical system at an equilibrium: M(q_0) xi'' + D²U(q_0) xi = 0, and the small-oscillation quadratic model clauses 1-3): is totally differentiable at with the displayed derivative ; the linearised equation at the equilibrium is ; and the linearized system is exactly the constant-coefficient quadratic system with symmetric positive definite mass matrix and symmetric non-negative stiffness of Decoupling of the constant-coefficient quadratic system into normal modes, with the zero-mode and energy identities.
Model dictionary (The coupled quadratic oscillator model: mass metric, stiffness, generalized force, modal vocabulary and the small-oscillation model at a mechanical equilibrium clauses (b), (d), (e)): the small-oscillation model at is the coupled quadratic model with mass metric , stiffness and in the coordinates ; its motions are the curves with , and its phase system is with ; it is oscillatory when is non-negative, and its modal vocabulary is that of the definition's clause (e) with .
Free modal classification (The free coupled quadratic model: global existence, the complete modal classification, mode energies, intrinsic degenerate mode subspaces, boundedness and the unstable direction clauses 1-4): for the free model with symmetric positive definite and symmetric the motions are classified by the modal families of its clause 2; the pure- motions form the intrinsic family described in its clause 4.
Energy stability (A strict local minimum of the potential gives a Lyapunov stable equilibrium of the mechanical system, by energy conservation): for the positive definite metric field , the potential and the strict local minimum , the rest point of the mechanical field is Lyapunov stable in the sense of Equilibria, Lyapunov stability and asymptotic stability of an autonomous first-order system.
Proof
Proof technique: direct; assemble the assigned model from the definition, identify the derivative linearization with the model's phase system, read the modal classification at a strict minimum, and invoke the energy-stability theorem for the nonlinear statement.
Clause 1: by [F1] the stiffness is symmetric and non-negative; by [F3] the small-oscillation model at is the coupled quadratic model with data , and a coupled quadratic model whose stiffness is non-negative is oscillatory in the sense of the definition's clause (e).
Clause 2: by [F2] the derivative of at is ; by [F3] the phase system of the small-oscillation model is for the same block matrix , and the model equation is equivalent to by the product rule and invertibility of . This proves clause 2.
Clause 4: the hypotheses of [F5] are the positive definite metric field, the potential and the strict local minimum of the statement; its conclusion is exactly the Lyapunov stability assertion of clause 4 for the field and the rest point , whose equilibrium property is recorded in The mechanical first-order field, Lagrangian and energy of a configuration-dependent kinetic metric in a chart.
Clause 3: apply the classification of [F4] to the data of the small-oscillation model; since is non-negative by [F1], every modal stiffness satisfies , so no exponential family occurs and the oscillatory and zero families of the free-mode theorem exhaust the motions, with frequencies and the intrinsic pure- families described there.
Clauses 1-4 are proved. Clause 4 is a nonlinear conclusion obtained from exact energy conservation, not from the linearization; clauses 2 and 3 describe the linearized model only, and no accuracy of that model as an approximation of the nonlinear motion, and no attraction, is claimed here.
Remarks
-
Stability is not asymptotic. The proof of clause 4 uses exact conservation of the mechanical energy, so the equilibrium is stable but not attracting: there is no mechanism in an autonomous conservative model that forces nearby motions to converge to the rest point, and none is asserted.
-
The linear model and the nonlinear motion. Clause 2 identifies the derivative linearization with the small-oscillation model; this makes the normal-mode calculation a statement about the first-order Taylor model at the equilibrium. The difference between that model and the nonlinear motion is quantified, at finite times and on explicitly small data, by Finite-time error control for the small-oscillation approximation: the quadratic remainder of the mechanical field and the variation-of-constants bound; no all-time claim follows from either theorem.
Depends on
The coupled quadratic oscillator model: mass metric, stiffness, generalized force, modal vocabulary and the small-oscillation model at a mechanical equilibrium
The free coupled quadratic model: global existence, the complete modal classification, mode energies, intrinsic degenerate mode subspaces, boundedness and the unstable direction
Decoupling of the constant-coefficient quadratic system into normal modes, with the zero-mode and energy identities
Linearisation of the mechanical system at an equilibrium: M(q_0) xi'' + D²U(q_0) xi = 0, and the small-oscillation quadratic model
A strict local minimum of the potential gives a Lyapunov stable equilibrium of the mechanical system, by energy conservation
A C² local minimum has vanishing gradient and positive semidefinite Hessian
The mechanical first-order field, Lagrangian and energy of a configuration-dependent kinetic metric in a chart
Equilibria, Lyapunov stability and asymptotic stability of an autonomous first-order system
The Hessian of a scalar field is symmetric
The Hessian matrix and critical points of a scalar field
Rectangular matrix multiplication and the identity matrix , including zero-sized shapes
Euclidean maps and diffeomorphisms
Intervals of : the nine order-convex forms, nondegeneracy, and length
Dependency tree · 2 levels
Sources
- D. Tong, Classical Dynamics (Cambridge lecture notes, January 2015 printing), Section 2.6, Eqs. (2.113)-(2.129), printed pages 38-41 (PDF pages 44-47): expansion about an equilibrium, the quadratic matrices and the stability reading of the normal modes
- I. Stewart, Advanced Classical Mechanics (MIT 8.09/8.309 Fall 2014 course text), Chapter 3, Sections 3.1-3.2, printed pages 52-59 (PDF pages 55-62): the quadratic natural Lagrangian about a minimum and the generalized symmetric eigenproblem
- G. Teschl, Ordinary Differential Equations and Dynamical Systems (AMS Graduate Studies in Mathematics 140, online edition), Section 6.7, Theorem 6.16: a fixed point of Newton's equation is stable if the potential has a local minimum there