How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A nontrivial degree-zero line bundle has no nonzero section
Counterexample
Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice), inherited from the Cartier-Weil, genus, finite-map and function-field suppliers. Let be an algebraically closed field and let be a smooth plane cubic, a curve of genus one (Arithmetic genus of a plane curve), with distinct closed points . Then the invertible sheaf (Invertible sheaf of cartier divisor) has degree zero, , and is nontrivial: a nonzero section would present as with effective and , forcing and , while nontriviality holds because would give a rational function of divisor and hence a degree-one map , impossible for a curve of genus one. So degree zero neither forces triviality nor produces sections.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: An algebraically closed field , the smooth plane cubic with , and distinct closed points .
Let be cut out by a nonzero homogeneous form of degree and assume is a curve (integral of dimension one); then and . In particular a smooth plane cubic is an integral proper curve with , and a line has . (Arithmetic genus of a plane curve)
A curve over is geometrically integral, separated, finite type of chain dimension one; a smooth proper curve is in particular integral and reduced, and the arithmetic genus of an integral proper curve is an invariant of its isomorphism class, because the cohomology of the structure sheaf depends only on the scheme up to isomorphism. (Curves over a field, Genus and arithmetic genus of a curve)
On a smooth curve divisors are finite -combinations of closed points, , and over an algebraically closed field every closed point has residue field and degree one. (Divisors on a smooth proper curve, Degree divisor proper curve)
For a smooth proper geometrically integral curve : the group of isomorphism classes of invertible sheaves is identified with the divisor class group by , the degree descends to a homomorphism taking to , and if and only if and are linearly equivalent; the sheaf is the invertible sheaf attached to the Cartier divisor . (Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve, The degree of a divisor descends to the Picard group of a normal proper curve, Invertible sheaf of cartier divisor)
A nonzero rational section of an invertible sheaf on a smooth curve determines a divisor with carrying the canonical section to ; consequently nonzero global sections of correspond to effective divisors with . (Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors, Effective divisors linearly equivalent to D are sections modulo scalars)
If is an effective divisor on a proper geometrically integral curve over , then , and if and only if . (Effective divisors have nonnegative degree)
A nonconstant rational function on a smooth proper geometrically integral curve defines a finite morphism whose degree is and whose fibre over infinity is the pole divisor , of the same degree. (A nonconstant rational function defines a finite map to the projective line, Degree of a nonconstant morphism of curves)
Under Choice the assignment is a bijection from dominant morphisms between smooth proper geometrically integral curves over onto injective -algebra homomorphisms of function fields, and every birational rational map between smooth proper geometrically integral curves is represented by a -isomorphism. (Smooth proper curves, dominant morphisms and function fields, Birational smooth proper curves are isomorphic)
The Axiom of Choice: every family of nonempty sets has a choice function. (The Axiom of Choice)
Polynomial rings in finitely many variables over a field are UFDs; irreducibles are prime. A nonzero positive-degree plane hypersurface has pure dimension one. Closed immersions and projective-space structure maps are proper, and proper morphisms compose. (Every finite-variable polynomial ring over a field is a UFD, with prime irreducibles and principal height-one primes, Nontrivial projective hypersurface sections, Finite-dimensional projective space is proper over every base, Closed immersions are proper, Properness survives composition)
Proof
Integrality and genus. On the equation is . The cubic polynomial in is not a square in : its order at infinity is , while a square has even order. Hence the monic quadratic in is irreducible over and, by clearing denominators in the UFD , over . Its homogenization is irreducible too: a nonconstant homogeneous factor becoming constant at would be a scalar power of , but does not divide . Thus [F10] makes the homogeneous quotient a domain; its nonempty projective charts are domains with common generic point, so is integral. It is of dimension one and proper by [F10]. Since is algebraically closed it is geometrically integral, and it is smooth by hypothesis, so [F1] applies with to give and .
The class has degree zero. The closed points are -rational, so by [F3]; hence , and by [F4] the invertible sheaf has .
The class is nontrivial. Suppose ; by [F4] this means that for a rational function , so the pole divisor of is the single point with multiplicity one and the divisor of is nonzero; in particular is nonconstant, and by [F7] it defines a morphism of degree . Consequently is a degree-one extension of , so is birational as a morphism of integral curves and [F8] represents it by a -isomorphism . The arithmetic genus is an isomorphism invariant [F2], so by [F1] applied to a line, contradicting from step 1.1. Hence is nontrivial.
Every nonzero section forces triviality. Suppose is nonzero. By [F5] there is an effective divisor on with ; by [F4] the degree of is , which is by step 1.2. So is an effective divisor of degree zero, and [F6] forces ; then , contradicting the nontriviality of from step 2.1. Therefore .
Conclusion. For distinct closed points on the smooth plane cubic of genus one, the invertible sheaf has degree by steps 1.2, is nontrivial by step 2.1, and has no nonzero global section by step 3.1: degree zero neither forces a line bundle to be trivial nor guarantees that it has a section. The Axiom of Choice is inherited from the Cartier-Weil, genus, finite-map and function-field suppliers [F9] and no further choice is used.
Depends on
- Birational smooth proper curves are isomorphic
- The degree of a divisor descends to the Picard group of a normal proper curve
- Curves over a field
- Genus and arithmetic genus of a curve
- The Axiom of Choice
- Degree divisor proper curve
- Divisors on a smooth proper curve
- Invertible sheaf of cartier divisor
- Degree of a nonconstant morphism of curves
- Effective divisors have nonnegative degree
- Every finite-variable polynomial ring over a field is a UFD, with prime irreducibles and principal height-one primes
- Nontrivial projective hypersurface sections
- Finite-dimensional projective space is proper over every base
- Closed immersions are proper
- Properness survives composition
- Effective divisors linearly equivalent to D are sections modulo scalars
- A nonconstant rational function defines a finite map to the projective line
- Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve
- Smooth proper curves, dominant morphisms and function fields
- Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors
- Arithmetic genus of a plane curve
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
192 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- William Fulton, Algebraic Curves (Internet Archive copy), Chs. 6-8 (standard reference, not scraped)
- The Stacks Project, Algebraic Curves (tag 0BRV) (standard reference, not scraped)
- Ravi Vakil, The Rising Sea (version of October 21, 2025), Chs. 19 and 21 (standard reference, not scraped)