Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedaudited 2026-10-02
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Effective divisors linearly equivalent to D are sections modulo scalars

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice. It supplies Dependent Choice by AC implies DC implies countable choice for the curve Cartier-to-Weil interface. Let k be a field and let C be a smooth proper geometrically integral curve over k, and let D be a divisor on C. For every nonzero f∈L(D) the divisor div⁡(f)+D is an effective divisor on C linearly equivalent to D, and the assignment f⟼div⁡(f)+D descends to a bijection (L(D)∖{0})/k×  ⟶  { D′ effective divisor on C:D′ linearly equivalent to D }. In particular L(D)=0 if and only if no effective divisor is linearly equivalent to D.

The curve-level Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve identifies the closed-point Weil divisors with Cartier divisors and preserves principal divisors, so it transports linear equivalence between the two descriptions. The current Cartier conventions are Linear equivalence cartier divisors, Effective cartier divisor, and Invertible sheaf of cartier divisor. The current The space L(D) defines L(D) by the displayed order condition and identifies it with H0(C,OC(D)); the current Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors gives the Cartier divisor and associated invertible sheaf of a nonzero rational section, while A regular global section of an invertible sheaf glues to an effective Cartier divisor constructs an effective Cartier divisor from a regular section. These are the current section/divisor interfaces behind the bijection below.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A smooth proper geometrically integral curve C over a field k with function field k(C), a divisor D on C, and the space L(D) of The space L(D); the Axiom of Choice is assumed.

[F1]

A divisor on C is a finite formal Z-linear combination D=∑xnx[x] of closed points, it is effective when all nx≥0, and the divisor of a nonzero rational function f is div⁡(f)=∑xord⁡x(f)[x], the order being the discrete valuation of the local ring OC,x, a discrete valuation ring; the order is additive, vanishes exactly on units, and ord⁡x(c)=0 for c∈k×. (Divisors on a smooth proper curve, Divisor support positive negative parts, Order codimension one rational function, Local rings at closed points of smooth curves are discrete valuation rings, Curves over a field)

[F2]

L(D)={ f∈k(C)×:div⁡(f)+D≥0 }∪{0} is a k-subspace of k(C), and f∈L(D)∖{0} means exactly that div⁡(f)+D is an effective divisor. (The space L(D))

[F3]

The current Cartier dictionary has these interfaces. The definition Linear equivalence cartier divisors says D∼D′ exactly when D−D′=div⁡C(u) for a global meromorphic unit u; Effective cartier divisor defines effectivity by local equations that are regular sections, meaning multiplication is injective on every stalk; and Invertible sheaf of cartier divisor defines OC(D) by the local sheaves fi−1OUi. The theorem Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors associates to a nonzero rational section its Cartier divisor and an isomorphism from the sheaf of that divisor carrying the canonical section to the given section; A regular global section of an invertible sheaf glues to an effective Cartier divisor constructs an effective Cartier divisor from a regular global section. On C, Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve identifies these Cartier conventions with the closed-point Weil-divisor conventions and preserves principal divisors. (Linear equivalence cartier divisors, Effective cartier divisor, Invertible sheaf of cartier divisor, Rational sections of line bundles are Cartier divisors, A regular global section of an invertible sheaf glues to an effective Cartier divisor, Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve)

[F4]

In ZF, AC implies DC by AC implies DC implies countable choice. Under the stated AC assumption, the current Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve body applies with its DC premise: on C, every divisor is Cartier, the Cartier and Weil divisor groups are identified, and the identification is compatible with principal divisors. Thus a Weil divisor difference D′−D equals div⁡(f) for a nonzero rational function f exactly when the corresponding Cartier divisors are linearly equivalent in the sense of [F3]. (Cartier and Weil divisors agree on a smooth curve, AC implies DC implies countable choice, Divisors on a smooth proper curve)

[F5]

Under AC, a proper curve over k that is geometrically connected and geometrically reduced has H0(C,OC)=k, with the map k→H0(C,OC) an isomorphism (Functions on a proper curve). A smooth proper geometrically integral curve is such a curve; hence a rational function h∈k(C)× with div⁡(h)=0 has no poles and lies in H0(C,OC)=k, and h≠0 gives h∈k×. (Functions on a proper curve, The Axiom of Choice, Divisors on a smooth proper curve)

Proof

technique · direct; the divisor of a rational function is principal and the effectivity condition is exactly membership in $L(D)$, while scalar multiples have the same divisor; injectivity uses that a rational function with zero divisor is constant on a proper curve
1.1F1F2F3F4

The map and its scalar invariance. Let f∈L(D)∖{0}. By [F2] the divisor div⁡(f)+D is effective, and it is linearly equivalent to D because (div⁡(f)+D)−D=div⁡(f) is the principal divisor of the rational function f, which is exactly linear equivalence on the curve C by [F4]. If c∈k×, then ord⁡x(cf)=ord⁡x(c)+ord⁡x(f)=ord⁡x(f) for every closed point x by [F1], so div⁡(cf)=div⁡(f) and the assignment f↦div⁡(f)+D is constant on k×-orbits; it therefore descends to a well-defined map Φ on (L(D)∖{0})/k× into the effective divisors linearly equivalent to D.

1.2F1F5

Injectivity. Suppose Φ(f)=Φ(g) for f,g∈L(D)∖{0}, that is, div⁡(f)=div⁡(g). The quotient h=f/g∈k(C)× satisfies div⁡(h)=div⁡(f)−div⁡(g)=0 by additivity of the order [F1], so h has no zeros and no poles on the variety; in particular h∈H0(C,OC) and h≠0, so [F5] gives h∈k×. Hence g=h−1f with h−1∈k×, so f and g have the same class in (L(D)∖{0})/k× and Φ is injective.

2.1F2F3F4F5step 1.1step 1.2∎

Surjectivity and the conclusion. Let D′ be an effective divisor linearly equivalent to D. By [F4] linear equivalence means that D′−D=div⁡(f) for some nonzero rational function f∈k(C)×; then div⁡(f)+D=D′ is effective, so f∈L(D)∖{0} by [F2], and Φ(f)=D′. Hence Φ is surjective, and with step 1.1 and step 1.2 it is a bijection from (L(D)∖{0})/k× onto the effective divisors linearly equivalent to D. Finally, L(D)=0 holds exactly when L(D)∖{0} is empty, which by the bijection is exactly the assertion that there is no effective divisor linearly equivalent to D. The current Cartier and section/divisor interfaces of [F3] support the terminology and equivalent section reading; AC is used through [F5] and supplies the DC premise of [F4].

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

70 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources