Alphabeta Math
ExampleConstruction: AI-generatedVerification: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedprecheck passjudge pass (gpt-6-sol)audited 2026-09-30
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The dual numbers have Cartan map multiplication by two

Example

Let k be any field and let A=k[ε]/(ε2), viewed as an ungraded k-algebra. Then

K0(A)≅Z[A],G0(A)≅Z[k],cA([A])=2[k].

In particular, the Cartan map cA:K0(A)→G0(A) is not an isomorphism.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A field k, the dual-number algebra A=k[ε]/(ε2), and unital left modules. All Grothendieck groups in this example are the ungraded groups on finite-dimensional modules and finite-dimensional projectives. No axiom of choice is assumed or used.

[F1]

G0(A) is the short-exact-sequence group of finite-dimensional left A-modules, K0(A) is the split group of finite-dimensional projective left A-modules, and cA sends a projective class to its module class (Graded Grothendieck groups, shift action, and Cartan map).

[F2]

In an essentially small abelian category in which every object has finite length, simple-object classes form a free abelian basis of G0 (Simple classes freely generate the Grothendieck group of a length category).

[F3]

For a finite-dimensional algebra over a field, projective-cover classes, one for each simple isomorphism class, form a free abelian basis of the split projective K0 (Indecomposable projective classes form a basis of split K0).

[F4]

The polynomial ring k[x] consists of finitely supported coefficient sequences, with convolution multiplication (The polynomial ring over a commutative ring as finitely supported coefficient sequences with convolution).

[F5]

In a quotient ring by a two-sided ideal I, multiplication is (r+I)(s+I)=rs+I (The quotient ring R/I with (r+I)(s+I)=rs+I).

[F6]

In a commutative ring, a left ideal, a right ideal, and a two-sided ideal are the same notion (Left, right and two-sided ideals).

[F7]

With its coefficientwise addition and convolution multiplication, k[x] is a commutative ring containing k by the constant-polynomial map (Polynomial convolution makes R[x] a commutative ring containing R as its constant subring).

[F8]

The quotient multiplication is well defined when the additive subgroup is a two-sided ideal (Multiplication of additive cosets is well defined if and only if the additive subgroup is a two-sided ideal).

[F9]

The additive cosets modulo a two-sided ideal form a ring with identity (For a two-sided ideal I, the additive cosets form a ring R/I with identity 1+I).

[F10]

The category of left modules over any ring is abelian (Modules over a ring form an abelian category).

[F11]

A left module is simple when it is nonzero and has no proper nonzero submodule (Simple module: a nonzero module with no proper nonzero submodule).

[F12]

A module is projective when maps from it lift across every surjective module homomorphism (Projective modules and the lifting property).

[F13]

A projective cover is a surjection with projective source and superfluous kernel; superfluity means N+ker⁡π=P forces N=P (An essential epimorphism is a surjection with superfluous kernel, and a projective cover is a projective source with such a map).

[F14]

A k-algebra has a unital structure map from k whose image is central; this defines its k-vector-space structure (Algebras over a commutative ring, central structure maps, and algebra homomorphisms).

[F15]

G0(C) imposes [Y]=[X]+[Z] for each short exact sequence 0→X→Y→Z→0 (Grothendieck group of an essentially small abelian category).

Verification

technique · direct
1.1F4F5F6F7F8F9F14givenalgebra

Write a polynomial as p(x)=∑n≥0anxn, with only finitely many nonzero coefficients, and let I=x2k[x]. Multiplication by x2 shifts coefficients two places, so elements of I have zero constant and linear coefficients; conversely, any polynomial with those two coefficients zero is in I. Sums and differences remain multiples of x2, and multiplying by any polynomial on either side again gives a multiple of x2; thus I is a two-sided ideal. Modulo I every polynomial has the representative a0+a1x, since p(x)−(a0+a1x)=x2∑n≥2anxn−2, and that representative is unique. By [F5]–[F9], A=k[x]/I is the quotient k-algebra with this multiplication. Thus 1,ε form a k-basis, dim⁡kA=2, and ε2=0.

2.1F1F10step 1.1givenconstructalgebra

The category A-Mod is abelian by [F10]. Its full subcategory Mfd(A) of finite-dimensional modules is closed under kernels and cokernels, since kernels are subspaces and cokernels are quotients of finite-dimensional vector spaces. Finite biproducts are finite-dimensional, and the coimage-to-image isomorphism remains in this full subcategory; hence Mfd(A) is abelian. It is essentially small: on kn, an unital A-action is determined by a matrix T∈Mn(k) with T2=0. For each n these matrices form a set, and every n-dimensional module is isomorphic to one of these models after choosing a basis. Their union over n≥0 is a set, so the isomorphism classes form a set. This object-by-object argument makes no simultaneous choice of bases.

2.2F5F6F7F11step 1.1givenchoosealgebra

By step 1.1, every element of A is a+bε. If a≠0, then a+bε is a unit, with inverse a−1−a−2bε; if a=0, the element is nilpotent or zero and is not a unit. Hence the nonunits are exactly the proper ideal (ε), and every maximal left ideal is (ε), since a proper left ideal contains no unit. The quotient A/(ε)≅k is a field, so (ε) is maximal. Any simple left module S is cyclic: for 0≠s∈S, the map A→S, a↦as, is onto, and its kernel is a maximal left ideal. It follows that S≅A/(ε)≅k. Thus k is the unique simple isomorphism class.

3.1F10F11step 2.1giveninductionchoosealgebra

Every object M of Mfd(A) has finite length. The zero module has the empty composition series. For nonzero M, choose a proper submodule N of maximal k-dimension; it exists because 0 is proper and possible dimensions lie in a finite set. The quotient M/N is nonzero, and a proper nonzero submodule of it would lift to a proper submodule of M strictly containing N. Thus M/N is simple. Induction on dim⁡kM gives a finite composition series for N; appending M/N gives one for M.

3.2F5F12F13step 1.1step 2.2givenchoosealgebra

Define the augmentation π:A↠k by π(a+bε)=a; its kernel is (ε). The source A is projective: given a surjection q:E↠M and f:A→M, choose e∈E with q(e)=f(1) and define f~(a)=ae; then qf~(a)=af(1)=f(a). If a submodule N≤A satisfies N+(ε)=A, write 1=n+cε with n∈N. Then n=1−cε is a unit, with inverse 1+cε, so N=A. Thus the kernel is superfluous and [F13] makes π a projective cover of the unique simple k.

4.1F1F2step 2.1step 3.1step 2.2construct

Steps 2.1, 3.1 and 2.2 verify that Mfd(A) is an essentially small abelian category of finite-length objects with exactly one simple isomorphism class, represented by k. By [F2], its Grothendieck group is the free abelian group on [k]: G0(A)≅Z[k].

4.2F3step 1.1step 2.2step 3.2construct

The algebra A is finite-dimensional by step 1.1, and its only simple isomorphism class is k by step 2.2. The cover in step 3.2 is A↠k. Applying [F3] to this one representative shows that K0(A)≅Z[A].

5.1

The ideal (ε)=kε is a submodule of A. The map k→kε, c↦cε, is an A-module isomorphism, because ε acts by zero on both modules. The quotient A/(ε) is also isomorphic to k. Therefore 0→kε→A→A/(ε)→0 is short exact, and [F15] gives [A]=[kε]+[A/(ε)]=2[k] in G0(A). The Cartan map of [F1] sends the projective class [A] to this same module class. By steps 4.1–4.2, this is multiplication by 2 from Z[A] to Z[k]; its image is 2Z[k], which is proper. Hence the Cartan map is not an isomorphism. [F1, F5, F6, F7, F15, step 1.1, step 2.2, step 4.1, step 4.2, algebra] □

Depends on

Used by

Nothing in the library uses this result yet.

Dependency tree · two levels

59 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources