How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The square knot is a nontrivial ribbon knot
Example
Assume ACω. Let be the standard right-handed trefoil, represented by the closure of the standard two-strand braid with three positive half-twists, and let be its reverse mirror. Choose the connected-sum balls on arcs colored in the Fox 3-colorings described below. The square knot is nontrivial, is ribbon, and bounds a smooth properly embedded disk in .
Example references
Facts & Assumptions
Given: ACω, the standard right-handed trefoil , its reverse mirror , and the connected-sum datum specified in the Example.
Under ACω, every smooth oriented knot has bounding a ribbon immersion in , and separately bounding a smooth proper disk whose squared radial function is Morse with only index- and index- critical points. (A reverse-mirror sum admits an explicit ribbon immersion, A knot summed with its reverse mirror bounds a ribbon disk)
Resolving a ribbon immersion gives a smooth proper disk with the same boundary. (Local resolution of ribbon singularities)
Under ACω, a ribbon immersion yields a no-maximum disk movie with the stipulated radial product boundary collar. (Ribbon immersions and disk movies without maxima are equivalent)
The reverse mirror is reflection of the knot followed by reversal of its knot orientation, and the connected sum uses the fixed orientation-matching gluing convention. (Reverse mirror of an oriented knot, Oriented connected sum and prime knot)
A Fox 3-coloring assigns an element of to each diagram arc and satisfies at every crossing. (Quandles and knot-diagram colorings, The dihedral operation is a quandle)
For , the number of Fox -colorings is unchanged by planar isotopy and every oriented Reidemeister move. (Dihedral Fox coloring counts are preserved by Reidemeister moves)
Under ACω, two regular diagrams represent the same oriented knot exactly when connected by a finite sequence of planar isotopies and oriented Reidemeister moves. (Reidemeister's theorem for oriented diagrams)
ACω is the sequence-choice axiom used by [F1] and [F5]. (The Axiom of Countable Choice ())
Verification
Given: ACω, the standard right-handed trefoil, , and the stated connected-sum datum.
Apply [F1] with . Its explicit ribbon immersion has oriented boundary , so the square knot is ribbon by the A-page definition. Apply [F6] to that immersion to obtain a smooth properly embedded disk in with the same boundary, proving smooth sliceness as well. Applying [F7] to the same immersion also gives a no-maximum disk movie with its required radial product boundary collar.
In the two-strand braid chart with parameter increasing from bottom to top, let be the color transfer for the positive generator whose overstrand runs from lower left to upper right. By [F3], ; the inverse crossing has transfer . Direct calculation gives and in . Hence is also the identity. Starting each trefoil tangle with the ordered pair therefore satisfies the braid closure conditions for both the trefoil and its mirror. The first arc in each closure has color ; choose those arcs for the connected-sum datum. The colorings glue because the shared arc colors agree, and the color- arcs remain, giving a nonconstant Fox 3-coloring of the square knot.
A crossing-free diagram of the unknot has one arc and exactly three Fox 3-colorings, one for each residue. The square-knot diagram has those three constant colorings and the nonconstant coloring from step 1.2, so its coloring count is at least four. If it were isotopic to the unknot, [F5] would give a finite Reidemeister sequence between their diagrams, and [F4] would preserve the coloring count, a contradiction. Thus the square knot is nontrivial.
Diagram
The schematic depicts one positive generator and its inverse in the two-strand braid. The braid parameter increases upward; the continuous strand is over, and the understrand has a gap. The top and bottom labels are ordered by left and right position. The calculation in step 1.2, rather than the drawing, verifies the three-crossing closure colorings.
Remarks
The Fox-coloring calculation proves nontriviality. The direct ribbon immersion in [F1] proves ribbonness, and its resolution in [F6] proves smooth sliceness. The general conversion between arbitrary no-maximum disk movies and ribbon immersions is supplied separately on the A page; this example also has the explicit immersion from [F1].
Depends on
- Ribbon disks and ribbon knots
- Local resolution of ribbon singularities
- Every ribbon knot is smoothly slice
- The Axiom of Countable Choice ($\mathrm{AC}_\omega$)
- Reverse mirror of an oriented knot
- Oriented connected sum and prime knot
- A knot summed with its reverse mirror bounds a ribbon disk
- A reverse-mirror sum admits an explicit ribbon immersion
- Ribbon immersions and disk movies without maxima are equivalent
- Quandles and knot-diagram colorings
- The dihedral operation is a quandle
- Dihedral Fox coloring counts are preserved by Reidemeister moves
- Reidemeister's theorem for oriented diagrams
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
39 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Arunima Ray, Slice Knots and Knot Concordance, Winter Braids Lecture Notes 8 (standard reference, not scraped)
- Daniel Brejevs, PhD thesis on alternating 3-braid closures (standard reference, not scraped)
- Brendan Owens, Knots and 4-Manifolds, Winter Braids IX lecture notes (standard reference, not scraped)