How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The left regular factor of an ICC discrete group is a non-type-I factor
Example
Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let be a countably infinite group in which every nonidentity conjugacy class is infinite (ICC), for instance the free group on two generators or the group of finitely supported permutations of . Let be the left regular representation on and . Then: (1) is a faithful normal tracial state on with , and is infinite dimensional; (2) is a factor, i.e. ; (3) is not a type I factor, hence is a factor representation that is not a multiple of an irreducible representation. Thus the canonical central decomposition of has a single non-irreducible factor fibre, exhibiting that factor representations need not be irreducible and that the type I hypothesis in the irreducible disintegration theorem is essential.
Facts & Assumptions
The left and right regular representations are strongly continuous and unitary; in the discrete case , , and the two actions commute (Left and right regular unitary representations of an LCH group, The regular representations are unitary, strongly continuous, and the left one is faithful).
The group von Neumann algebra is the WOT closure of the unital star algebra spanned by ; commutants are WOT-closed, and multiplication by a fixed bounded operator is WOT-continuous. The bicommutant theorem identifies this algebra with (Von Neumann algebras and commutants, The double commutant theorem for concrete von Neumann algebras).
A faithful normal tracial state is positive, unital and tracial, faithful on , and normal; vector functionals are WOT-continuous (States, tracial states and faithful normal traces on a von Neumann algebra).
A factor representation has scalar centre. A separable type I factor has spatial form for nonzero separable , and is equivalent to a multiple of an irreducible representation, with the converse also valid (Factor (primary) representations, A separable type I factor is a multiple of an irreducible representation).
In , the infinite cyclic factors and are self-commensurating and have trivial intersections with conjugates of the other factor (The two cyclic basis factors of the rank-two free group are self-commensurating with trivial cross-conjugate intersections).
AC permits orthonormal bases and the spatial type I splitting used here (The Axiom of Choice).
Verification
Given: AC and a countably infinite discrete ICC group .
The vector functional is positive and unital, since and , and is WOT-continuous, hence normal. On generators, . Bilinearity proves the trace identity on their linear span. For fixed in that span, approximate in WOT and use separate multiplication continuity to obtain ; then fix this and approximate arbitrary , proving traciality on . Every commutes with by [F1,F2]. If , then and for all , so on a dense basis. Thus is faithful. The operators are linearly independent: applying a finite linear relation to gives the corresponding relation among the distinct basis vectors . Hence is infinite dimensional.
Let and write . For the unitary fixes and sends to . Centrality and [F1,F2] imply that commutes with both factors of , so . Thus is constant on each conjugacy class. An sequence cannot have a nonzero constant value on an infinite set, so ICC gives . Commutation with then gives for every . Therefore , proving the factor assertion.
If were type I, [F4] would give the spatial algebra . Finite-dimensional would make finite dimensional. If is infinite dimensional and separable, choose a countable orthonormal basis and the isometries onto its even and odd basis subspaces. Their range projections are orthogonal. Transferring to , traciality gives and , while positivity and give , a contradiction. Thus is not type I and [F4] excludes an irreducible multiple. In particular is not irreducible. Its one-point integral is a central factor decomposition, since diagonal operators on that point are ; any central diagonal model must have a one-atom measure algebra on its effective support, because its diagonal algebra is scalar. The fibre therefore remains this non-irreducible factor, rather than an irreducible.
For completeness, is countable by its finite reduced words and infinite by the powers of . If , all conjugates are distinct: equality at two different integers would make commute with a nonzero power . Then contains , of finite index in both infinite cyclic groups, contradicting from [F5]. If , then by [F5], and the same argument with gives infinitely many conjugates. Thus is ICC. The finite-support permutation group is a countable union of finite permutation groups and is infinite. For a nonidentity permutation with finite moved support , move to infinitely many pairwise disjoint blocks of the same size by finite permutations. Its conjugates then have distinct moved supports and are distinct, proving ICC. Both examples therefore satisfy all conclusions above.
Depends on
- Left and right regular unitary representations of an LCH group
- The regular representations are unitary, strongly continuous, and the left one is faithful
- Von Neumann algebras and commutants
- The double commutant theorem for concrete von Neumann algebras
- States, tracial states and faithful normal traces on a von Neumann algebra
- Factor (primary) representations
- A separable type I factor is a multiple of an irreducible representation
- The two cyclic basis factors of the rank-two free group are self-commensurating with trivial cross-conjugate intersections
- The Axiom of Choice
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
74 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Bachir Bekka and Pierre de la Harpe, Unitary Representations of Groups, Duals, and Characters (arXiv:1912.07262v1) (standard reference, not scraped)