How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The first connective complex K-theory Postnikov invariant is integral Sq-three
Statement
Assume AC. Write for Adams's connective complex -theory spectrum , with its fixed Bott generator , and , . Its first stable Postnikov invariant is the nonzero degree-three integral operation where is reduction modulo two and is the integral Bockstein of .
Here the stable invariant means the operation whose degree- universal class is the first potentially nonzero space Postnikov class with the stage and fiber identifications fixed by the spectrum and . The compatibility of these classes is the stable compatibility for Adams's spectrum recorded in the source input below, not a spectral assertion supplied by the definition for spaces. Its occurrence in each representing space is evaluation of this same operation; it does not assert that every evaluation is nonzero. The fixed Bott identifications transport this normalization to its coefficient rows.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: Adams's connective spectrum and its specified Bott data as in the Statement.
AC is assumed for the space Postnikov constructions, representability and cellular cohomology (The Axiom of Choice).
For a connected simple space, a marked Postnikov stage with fiber has its class in ; this is a statement about spaces (Postnikov k-invariant, Postnikov section and Postnikov tower). For connected CW complexes, can be constructed by adjoining cells of dimension at least (Postnikov towers exist for connected CW complexes). A marked simple stage is the homotopy fiber of a map representing its class (Simple Postnikov stages are classified by k-invariants).
Positive-degree operations correspond to universal classes on , with their positive-degree suspension identities characterized by the corresponding universal-class identities (Cohomology operations are universal classes on Eilenberg--Mac Lane spaces). Full stability requires every suspension identity, including degree zero (Stable natural cohomology operation).
On a degree- cocycle, uses for and vanishes for (Steenrod squares from cup-i). The integral and mod-two Bocksteins have different targets and come from different coefficient sequences (Bockstein connecting operation).
A spectrum here has weak-equivalence adjoint structure maps and stable groups are their indicated colimits (Sequential prespectra, spectra, and adjoint structure maps, Stable homotopy groups of a sequential prespectrum).
The source computations used here are the opening of Adams, Proposition 16.6, printed p.391: the first stable invariant of belongs to the order-two group of degree-three stable integral operations, generated by ; each spectrum space has the evaluation of the same stable operation; the third space is ; and in whereas . These computations and their spectrum compatibility are source inputs, not results asserted to follow from [F1] or [F2]. Adams distinguishes the mod-two Bockstein on printed p.326 from the integral Bockstein on printed p.398. Thus his integral operation here is in the present fully typed notation. Source: https://www.sas.rochester.edu/mth/sites/doug-ravenel/otherpapers/Adams-SHGH-latex2.pdf .
Cellular cochains compute the cohomology of a CW pair, including constant integral coefficients (Cellular cochains compute cohomology with local coefficients); the pair cohomology sequence is exact (Long exact sequence of a pair in singular cohomology).
Proof
We first locate the space classes correctly. For a connective Omega-spectrum, [F4] identifies with for : each adjoint map is a weak equivalence, so the bonding maps in that stable colimit are isomorphisms. For the space is connected (its components identify with ), and it is simply connected by connectivity. Its first groups are , and . Consequently the lower space stage is a model. Presenting the next stage as the marked fibration of [F1], its class lies in . This uses [F1] only for connected simple spaces, with , never for a spectrum or a degree-zero space stage.
By [F5] the classes of step 1.1 are evaluations of a single stable operation and its group has just two elements: and . The target types are integral to mod-two, then mod-two, then integral, respectively. [F3] supplies these local conventions; [F5], rather than [F2], supplies the stable group calculation and compatibility. In particular we are not inferring an operation group for an Eilenberg–Mac Lane spectrum from the theorem for one space .
Suppose . Its evaluation at the third space is then zero. Here , and step 1.1 gives up to the fixed stage equivalence. The fibration has fiber and zero class. By [F1] it is fiber homotopy equivalent to the homotopy fiber of the constant map , which has a section given by the constant loop. Hence is injective, since section pullback is its left inverse.
Choose the CW Postnikov model in [F1] for . The pair has only relative cells of dimension at least seven. Its cellular cochain group in degree six is zero, so by [F6]. The pair sequence therefore makes injective. Composing with step 3.1 would inject the nonzero class of [F5] into , a contradiction. Equivalences of stage models transport these maps and do not affect injectivity.
Thus , and the two-element alternative of step 2.1 forces . Its evaluation gives the stated universal class in each space by [F5]. The two identifications of an integral coefficient generator differ by sign; that sign cannot change an element of an order-two group, since . Hence the fixed Bott identifications preserve this normalization. In low degrees evaluations may be zero: for instance is zero on degree-zero and degree-one classes by [F3]; this illustrates why nonzero stable operation does not mean nonzero on every space. The nonvanishing used in the proof is specifically the degree-three universal class.
Source notes
The source inputs are those in Adams, Stable Homotopy and Generalised Homology, Proposition 16.6, opening on printed p.391. The full proof continues on pp.392–393 with a mod-two module calculation; that later Bockstein is not substituted for the integral one. Steps 3.1–4.1 give the missing explanation for the nonvanishing deduction using space Postnikov stages and relative cellular cohomology. Stable group classification and spectrum compatibility remain explicitly identified source computations.
Depends on
- Postnikov k-invariant
- Postnikov section and Postnikov tower
- Postnikov towers exist for connected CW complexes
- Simple Postnikov stages are classified by k-invariants
- Cellular cochains compute cohomology with local coefficients
- Long exact sequence of a pair in singular cohomology
- Cohomology operations are universal classes on Eilenberg--Mac Lane spaces
- Stable natural cohomology operation
- Bockstein connecting operation
- Steenrod squares from cup-i
- Sequential prespectra, spectra, and adjoint structure maps
- Stable homotopy groups of a sequential prespectrum
- The Axiom of Choice
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
48 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. F. Adams, Stable Homotopy and Generalised Homology, Proposition 16.6 and its proof, printed pp. 391–393 (standard reference, not scraped)