Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6-sol)audited 2026-09-27
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

A nonabelian supersolvable group has a noncentral abelian normal subgroup, also in its nonabelian quotients

Statement

Let G be a finite group and suppose G has a series 1=G0◃G1◃⋯◃Gr=G in which every term Gi is normal in the whole group G and every factor Gi/Gi−1 has prime order; that is, G is supersolvable in the sense of (Supersolvable groups and monomial characters) with all series terms normal in G.

If G is nonabelian, then G contains an abelian normal subgroup A⊴G with A⊈Z(G). Moreover, if K⊴G is such that the quotient G/K is nonabelian, then G/K contains an abelian normal subgroup that is not contained in Z(G/K).

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A finite group G with a series 1=G0◃G1◃⋯◃Gr=G of subgroups normal in G and prime-order factors, and a normal subgroup K⊴G such that G/K is nonabelian; the first assertion assumes in addition that G is nonabelian.

[F1]

Along such a series each factor Gi/Gi−1 has prime order, in particular Gi/Gi−1 is cyclic and nontrivial for i≥1. (Supersolvable groups and monomial characters).

[F2]

For a subgroup N≤G, the product NK={nk:n∈N,k∈K} of normal subgroups N,K⊴G is a normal subgroup of G containing both. (Normal subgroup: invariance under conjugation).

[F3]

In the quotient G/K the elements are the cosets gK, the quotient map π:G→G/K, g↦gK, is a surjective homomorphism, and π(N)=NK/K for a subgroup N≤G. (The quotient group G/N and coset product (gN)(hN)=ghN).

[F4]

Z(G)={z∈G:zg=gz for all g∈G}, and G is abelian precisely when G=Z(G). (The center Z(G) of a group).

[F5]

First isomorphism theorem: for a group homomorphism φ with kernel L, the induced map G/L→im⁡φ is an isomorphism. (First isomorphism theorem for groups: G/ker⁡f≅im⁡f).

[A1]

For any subgroup Gi−1⊴Gi of prime index p and any x∈Gi∖Gi−1, the subgroup generated by Gi−1 and x equals Gi, so every element of Gi has the form gxk with g∈Gi−1 and k∈Z.

Proof

technique · direct
1.1

Let K⊴G and put Gˉ:=G/K, Gˉj:=GjK/K for j=0,…,r. Each Gˉj is a subgroup of Gˉ containing Gˉj−1 and is normal in Gˉ, because Gj⊴G and K⊴G ([F2], [F3]); moreover Gˉ0=K/K=1 and Gˉr=G/K=Gˉ. For each j the map φ:Gˉj→GjK/Gj−1K, gK↦gGj−1K, is well defined and a surjective homomorphism with kernel Gˉj−1=Gj−1K/K, so by [F5] the quotient Gˉj/Gˉj−1 is isomorphic to GjK/Gj−1K; that group is in turn a quotient of the prime-order group Gj/Gj−1, since Gj→GjK/Gj−1K is surjective with Gj−1 in its kernel. Hence every factor Gˉj/Gˉj−1 has order 1 or prime.

F2F3F5givenalgebra
1.2

Now assume that G is nonabelian, so G=Gr⊈Z(G) by [F4], while G0=1⊆Z(G). Let i∈{1,…,r} be the least index with Gi⊈Z(G); such an index exists because Gr⊈Z(G), and i≥1 because G0=1 is central. By minimality Gi−1⊆Z(G).

F4givenalgebra
2.1

By step 1.2 the subgroup Gi−1 is contained in Z(G), hence in Z(Gi); by [F1] the factor Gi/Gi−1 has prime order, so Gi=Gi−1⟨x⟩ for any x∈Gi∖Gi−1 by [A1], and every element of Gi is of the form gxk with g∈Gi−1. Two such elements gxk and g′xk′ commute, because g,g′∈Gi−1⊆Z(Gi) and powers of x commute with each other. Hence Gi is abelian.

A1F1step 1.2algebra
3.1

Thus A:=Gi is abelian by step 2.1, it is normal in G by hypothesis, and A=Gi⊈Z(G) by the choice of i in step 1.2. This is the asserted abelian normal subgroup of G and proves the first assertion.

step 1.2step 2.1given
4.1

Finally assume that Gˉ=G/K is nonabelian, so Gˉ=Gˉr⊈Z(Gˉ) by [F4] while Gˉ0=1⊆Z(Gˉ). Let j be the least index with Gˉj⊈Z(Gˉ); then j≥1, Gˉj−1⊆Z(Gˉ), and Gˉj≠Gˉj−1, so by step 1.1 the factor Gˉj/Gˉj−1 has prime order. The computation of step 2.1, applied with the pair (Gi,Gi−1) replaced by the pair (Gˉj,Gˉj−1) inside Gˉ, shows in the same way that Gˉj is abelian, while Gˉj⊈Z(Gˉ) by the choice of j. Hence the nonabelian quotient Gˉ also contains an abelian normal subgroup that is not contained in its center, which is the second assertion.

F4step 1.1step 2.1∎

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

17 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources