Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6-sol)audited 2026-09-27
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

A nonabelian supersolvable group has a noncentral abelian normal subgroup, also in its nonabelian quotients

Statement

Let G be a finite group and suppose G has a series 1=G0◃G1◃⋯◃Gr=G in which every term Gi is normal in the whole group G and every factor Gi/Gi−1 has prime order; that is, G is supersolvable in the sense of (Supersolvable groups and monomial characters) with all series terms normal in G.

If G is nonabelian, then G contains an abelian normal subgroup A⊴G with A⊈Z(G). Moreover, if K⊴G is such that the quotient G/K is nonabelian, then G/K contains an abelian normal subgroup that is not contained in Z(G/K).

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A finite group G with a series 1=G0◃G1◃⋯◃Gr=G of subgroups normal in G and prime-order factors, and a normal subgroup K⊴G such that G/K is nonabelian; the first assertion assumes in addition that G is nonabelian.

[F1]

Along such a series each factor Gi/Gi−1 has prime order, in particular Gi/Gi−1 is cyclic and nontrivial for i≥1. (Supersolvable groups and monomial characters).

[F2]

For a subgroup N≤G, the product NK={nk:n∈N,k∈K} of normal subgroups N,K⊴G is a normal subgroup of G containing both. (Normal subgroup: invariance under conjugation).

[F3]

In the quotient G/K the elements are the cosets gK, the quotient map π:G→G/K, g↦gK, is a surjective homomorphism, and π(N)=NK/K for a subgroup N≤G. (The quotient group G/N and coset product (gN)(hN)=ghN).

[F4]

Z(G)={z∈G:zg=gz for all g∈G}, and G is abelian precisely when G=Z(G). (The center Z(G) of a group).

[F5]

First isomorphism theorem: for a group homomorphism φ with kernel L, the induced map G/L→im⁡φ is an isomorphism. (First isomorphism theorem for groups: G/ker⁡f≅im⁡f).

[A1]

For any subgroup Gi−1⊴Gi of prime index p and any x∈Gi∖Gi−1, the subgroup generated by Gi−1 and x equals Gi, so every element of Gi has the form gxk with g∈Gi−1 and k∈Z.

Proof

technique · direct
1.1F2F3F5givenalgebra

Let K⊴G and put Gˉ:=G/K, Gˉj:=GjK/K for j=0,…,r. Each Gˉj is a subgroup of Gˉ containing Gˉj−1 and is normal in Gˉ, because Gj⊴G and K⊴G ([F2], [F3]); moreover Gˉ0=K/K=1 and Gˉr=G/K=Gˉ. For each j the map φ:Gˉj→GjK/Gj−1K, gK↦gGj−1K, is well defined and a surjective homomorphism with kernel Gˉj−1=Gj−1K/K, so by [F5] the quotient Gˉj/Gˉj−1 is isomorphic to GjK/Gj−1K; that group is in turn a quotient of the prime-order group Gj/Gj−1, since Gj→GjK/Gj−1K is surjective with Gj−1 in its kernel. Hence every factor Gˉj/Gˉj−1 has order 1 or prime.

1.2F4givenalgebra

Now assume that G is nonabelian, so G=Gr⊈Z(G) by [F4], while G0=1⊆Z(G). Let i∈{1,…,r} be the least index with Gi⊈Z(G); such an index exists because Gr⊈Z(G), and i≥1 because G0=1 is central. By minimality Gi−1⊆Z(G).

2.1A1F1step 1.2algebra

By step 1.2 the subgroup Gi−1 is contained in Z(G), hence in Z(Gi); by [F1] the factor Gi/Gi−1 has prime order, so Gi=Gi−1⟨x⟩ for any x∈Gi∖Gi−1 by [A1], and every element of Gi is of the form gxk with g∈Gi−1. Two such elements gxk and g′xk′ commute, because g,g′∈Gi−1⊆Z(Gi) and powers of x commute with each other. Hence Gi is abelian.

3.1step 1.2step 2.1given

Thus A:=Gi is abelian by step 2.1, it is normal in G by hypothesis, and A=Gi⊈Z(G) by the choice of i in step 1.2. This is the asserted abelian normal subgroup of G and proves the first assertion.

4.1F4step 1.1step 2.1∎

Finally assume that Gˉ=G/K is nonabelian, so Gˉ=Gˉr⊈Z(Gˉ) by [F4] while Gˉ0=1⊆Z(Gˉ). Let j be the least index with Gˉj⊈Z(Gˉ); then j≥1, Gˉj−1⊆Z(Gˉ), and Gˉj≠Gˉj−1, so by step 1.1 the factor Gˉj/Gˉj−1 has prime order. The computation of step 2.1, applied with the pair (Gi,Gi−1) replaced by the pair (Gˉj,Gˉj−1) inside Gˉ, shows in the same way that Gˉj is abelian, while Gˉj⊈Z(Gˉ) by the choice of j. Hence the nonabelian quotient Gˉ also contains an abelian normal subgroup that is not contained in its center, which is the second assertion.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

17 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources