How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
First rational Hurewicz after killing lower torsion homotopy
Statement
Assume AC. Let Y be a simply connected space and n≥2. If π_j(Y) is torsion for 2≤j<n, then H_j(Y;Q)=0 for 0<j<n and actual Hurewicz induces an isomorphism π_n(Y)⊗Q→H_n(Y;Q). CW type is not required.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC; a simply connected space and with torsion for ; the weak-join models ; and actual mapping-path fibrations over them.
A based weak CW approximation induces isomorphisms on homotopy, integral homology and rational homology (CW approximation of an arbitrary space, Weak homotopy equivalences induce integral homology isomorphisms without choice, Rationalization is exact and commutes with singular homology); CW approximations can be chosen with a prescribed basepoint (CW approximation of an arbitrary space).
The absolute Hurewicz theorem computes the first nonzero integral homology, and the cohomological universal coefficient theorem identifies with (Absolute Hurewicz theorem at the first nonzero degree); Eilenberg–Mac Lane representability supplies the classifying map and the identity evaluation naturality (Eilenberg--Mac Lane spaces represent singular cohomology).
The mapping-path factorization gives the actual homotopy fiber with its exact sequence, and the homological Serre sequence of a fibration over a simply connected rationally acyclic base has only its column (Mapping path factorization, Long exact sequence of homotopy groups of a fibration, Homological Serre spectral sequence); rational acyclicity of torsion Eilenberg–Mac Lane spaces in all degrees (Torsion Eilenberg–Mac Lane spaces are rationally acyclic).
AC chooses the CW approximations, models and representing maps (The Axiom of Choice).
Proof
A based weak CW approximation L→Y induces isomorphisms on homotopy, integral homology and rational homology. Hurewicz naturality therefore reduces the claim to L. Choose its prescribed vertex as basepoint. It is simply connected. We describe a finite sequence of CW spaces Y_2=L, Y_3,...,Y_n with Y_j (j−1)-connected, and maps Y_{j+1}→Y_j inducing isomorphisms on π_i for i>j and on rational homology in every degree.
Suppose Y_j has been constructed for 2≤j<n. Its group T_j=π_j(Y_j) is the original π_j(L), because all earlier maps preserve higher homotopy; it is torsion. Integral Hurewicz gives H_j(Y_j;Z)≅T_j and H_{j−1}(Y_j;Z)=0. The cohomological UCT therefore identifies H^j(Y_j;T_j) with Hom(H_j(Y_j;Z),T_j). Take the class corresponding to the Hurewicz inverse. Represent it by a based map f_j:Y_j→K(T_j,j). The universal class evaluates as identity on T_j. Naturality of evaluation and integral Hurewicz shows (f_j)*:π_j(Y_j)→π_j(K(T_j,j)) is the identity under the chosen markings. Let F_j be its strict homotopy fiber in the actual mapping-path fibration. Its exact sequence shows F_j is j-connected and that F_j→Y_j is an isomorphism on π_i for i>j. Indeed K(T_j,j) has no higher groups, its degree-j map is an isomorphism, and both spaces have zero groups below j. The component segment shows F_j is path-connected. The base is simply connected and rationally acyclic by the torsion-acyclicity lemma. For any rational vector space V, the rationalization lemma makes H_a(K(T_j,j);V) zero for a>0 and equal to V for a=0. Therefore the Serre sequence of F_j→E{f_j}→K(T_j,j) has only column a=0. Its fiber edge is an isomorphism in every degree. Compose it with the deformation retraction E_{f_j}→Y_j: the projection F_j→Y_j is a rational homology isomorphism. Take a based weak CW approximation Y_{j+1}→F_j preserving a chosen fiber point. It transfers both homotopy and homology, and its composite into Y_j has exactly the properties promised. This finishes the construction. The case T_j=0 uses a CW K(0,j) and works with the same argument.
After the finite sequence j=2,...,n−1, Y_n is (n−1)-connected. The composite Y_n→L induces an isomorphism on π_n and on all rational homology. Integral Hurewicz on Y_n, the rationalization lemma, and naturality give the claimed isomorphism on L and then on Y; lower vanishing transfers as well. If n=2 the construction is empty and integral first Hurewicz on L suffices. Every comparison is induced by an actual continuous map. No use of a generalized Whitehead theorem modulo torsion has been concealed.
Depends on
- Rationalization is exact and commutes with singular homology
- Torsion Eilenberg–Mac Lane spaces are rationally acyclic
- CW approximation of an arbitrary space
- Weak homotopy equivalences induce integral homology isomorphisms without choice
- Absolute Hurewicz theorem at the first nonzero degree
- Absolute and relative Hurewicz homomorphisms
- Topological universal coefficient short exact sequence for cohomology
- Eilenberg--Mac Lane spaces represent singular cohomology
- Existence and homotopy uniqueness of Eilenberg--Mac Lane spaces
- Mapping path factorization
- Long exact sequence of homotopy groups of a fibration
- Homological Serre spectral sequence
- Serre edge maps come from projection and fiber inclusion
- The Axiom of Choice
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
102 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Allen Hatcher, Algebraic Topology (standard reference, not scraped)
- Allen Hatcher, Spectral Sequences, Chapter 1 (standard reference, not scraped)