How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Barsotti-Chevalley existence over an arbitrary field, allowing nonsmooth affine kernel
Statement
Assume AC and DC. For every connected separated finite-type group scheme over any field , there is a connected affine closed normal subgroup scheme whose represented quotient is an abelian variety. The quotient projection is faithfully flat of finite presentation with scheme kernel , so is exact as fppf group sheaves. The abelian quotient is commutative and projective. Neither smoothness of nor perfectness of is assumed. The subgroup is not asserted smooth, even when is smooth, and no uniqueness is asserted under these hypotheses.
Facts & Assumptions
The perfect-field theorem applies to smooth connected groups; every finite-type characteristic-zero group is smooth. (Barsotti-Chevalley over a perfect field: unique smooth affine normal subgroup, Every finite-type characteristic-zero group scheme is smooth)
For a finite purely inseparable extension, Frobenius power ideals descend a closed normal subgroup as a nilpotent thickening, preserving affineness and connectedness. Affineness and smoothness can be checked after faithful field extension, and properness can be checked after any field extension. (Purely inseparable subgroup descent by Frobenius power ideals, Affineness and finiteness of morphisms descend under fppf base change, Affine smooth and connected properties in exact sequences of algebraic groups, Properness over a field can be checked after field extension)
Normal quotients exist as separated finite-type group schemes with fppf projection. Group images are exact quotients by scheme kernels. Quotients of smooth connected groups are smooth connected, extensions of affine groups are affine, and connected groups are geometrically connected. (Normal subgroup quotients of finite-type group schemes exist as fppf scheme quotients, Group images are exact kernel quotients and preserve affine smooth connected properties, Affine smooth and connected properties in exact sequences of algebraic groups, Connected finite-type groups are geometrically connected)
In characteristic , high relative Frobenius has a smooth scheme-theoretic image, is finite and a universal homeomorphism onto that image, and has finite kernel. Properness means finite type, separatedness and universal closedness. Algebraic closures exist under AC. (High relative Frobenius has smooth scheme-theoretic image, Proper morphisms, Assuming Choice, every field has an algebraic closure)
A proper smooth geometrically connected group is an abelian variety and is commutative and projective. (Abelian varieties over a field, A proper geometrically connected group variety is commutative, Every abelian variety over a field is projective)
Proof
Given: AC, DC, a field , and a connected separated finite-type -group .
First suppose smooth. In characteristic zero the field is perfect and [F1] already proves the assertion. In characteristic , choose an algebraic closure by [F4] and let be the union of its finite purely inseparable extensions of . This is a perfect field. By [F1], has a smooth connected affine closed normal subgroup with abelian quotient. Descend this subgroup to a finite purely inseparable inside , as follows. On a finite affine cover of , its ideal is finitely generated. Include in the finitely many coefficients of its generators, generators of the relations identifying the ideals on a finite affine cover of each overlap, and the finite equations making multiplication, inverse, identity and conjugation factor through it. Equality of ideals and vanishing of these equations hold after faithful scalar extension, hence already at the finite stage after enlarging . Also include an affine finite-presentation model of and the finitely many chart maps and inverse equations identifying it with this descended closed subscheme. Thus the subgroup is affine and normal. Smoothness descends by [F2]; connectedness descends since a disconnection remains one after scalar extension. The quotient becomes the given abelian quotient after scalar extension, because both represent the same fppf coset sheaf, by [F3]. Its properness therefore descends by [F2]. This supplies a finite purely inseparable stage with all the required properties.
Apply the power-ideal descent in [F2] to to obtain a connected affine closed normal for which contains as a nilpotent closed subscheme. Let , represented by [F3]. The map factors through ; the induced map is surjective because the projection from is surjective. This map has proper source and separated finite-type target and is proper: its graph is closed in , whose projection to is proper, by the definition of properness and base change. Hence is proper over . Explicitly, for every -scheme and closed , its preimage in is closed and its image in is closed by properness of ; surjectivity, retained by base change, makes that image exactly the image of . Finite type and separatedness of come from [F3], giving properness by [F4]. Descend properness to by [F2]. Since is smooth connected, [F3] makes smooth connected and geometrically connected. It is therefore an abelian variety by [F5]. This proves the smooth-source case without descending a smooth subgroup to .
For arbitrary in characteristic zero, [F1] reduces to the smooth-source case. In positive characteristic let be a sufficiently high relative Frobenius with smooth image, as in [F4]. It is finite and a universal homeomorphism onto , which is connected. Its scheme kernel is finite, hence affine, and connected: a universal homeomorphism has a single geometric point in the fibre over the identity. By [F3], is the represented exact quotient and is faithfully flat of finite presentation. Apply the smooth-source case to to obtain a connected affine normal with abelian quotient . Define , a closed normal subgroup. The restricted projection is an exact sequence , so [F3] makes affine. The projection is a base change of the finite universal homeomorphism and is onto; hence is connected.
The composite has scheme kernel and is fppf surjective: both factors are faithfully flat of finite presentation. It therefore identifies its coset sheaf with . Indeed every point of lifts fppf locally first to and then to , and two lifts differ precisely by a point of ; these assertions after arbitrary test-scheme base change identify the sheaves. The represented quotient in [F3] is thus , an abelian variety. Its projectivity and commutativity follow from [F5]. The Frobenius step used the smooth image , not the whole twist of , which can remain nonsmooth for every exponent; and the inseparable descent in step 2.1 retained nilpotent subgroup structure. Thus no smoothness or uniqueness of the arbitrary-field kernel was introduced. AC and DC are inherited from [F1]–[F5].
Depends on
- The Axiom of Choice
- The axiom of dependent choice: a relation in which every element is related to something admits an $\mathbb{N}$-indexed chain
- Abelian varieties over a field
- A proper geometrically connected group variety is commutative
- Every abelian variety over a field is projective
- Barsotti-Chevalley over a perfect field: unique smooth affine normal subgroup
- Every finite-type characteristic-zero group scheme is smooth
- High relative Frobenius has smooth scheme-theoretic image
- Purely inseparable subgroup descent by Frobenius power ideals
- Affineness and finiteness of morphisms descend under fppf base change
- Properness over a field can be checked after field extension
- Group images are exact kernel quotients and preserve affine smooth connected properties
- Affine smooth and connected properties in exact sequences of algebraic groups
- Connected finite-type groups are geometrically connected
- Normal subgroup quotients of finite-type group schemes exist as fppf scheme quotients
- Assuming Choice, every field has an algebraic closure
- Proper morphisms
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
64 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Milne, Algebraic Groups (2022), Theorem 8.28, with its Frobenius-image correction, pp.154-155 (standard reference, not scraped)
- Brion, Some structure theorems for algebraic groups, Theorem 4.3.2 and Theorem 4.3.4 with Lemma 4.3.5 (standard reference, not scraped)
- Conrad, A modern proof of Chevalley's theorem on algebraic groups, Theorem 1.1 and inseparable descent discussion (standard reference, not scraped)