How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The second Conway coefficient is a degree-two finite-type invariant
Statement
Let be a Conway skein invariant of oriented links, and for a knot put . Then has type at most two: its third finite difference vanishes on every three-singular knot. If is the degree-two chord diagram of a two-singular knot, then when the two chords intersect and when they do not. Thus its degree-two symbol is a nonzero weight system on the unframed 4T+1T quotient. Moreover, for the unknot, and for the positive trefoil represented by the closure of a two-strand braid with three successive positive Artin half twists; closure joins each upper endpoint to the corresponding lower endpoint outside the braid cylinder.
The two possible degree-two chord patterns are shown below. The first has alternating endpoints and the second has an isolated chord. The diagrams illustrate the symbol values; the proof is algebraic.
Statement references
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A Conway skein invariant on oriented links, the finite-difference convention for singular knots, and the degree-two chord-diagram convention.
The Conway polynomial: and for an oriented skein triple.
Singular knots and Vassiliev derivatives: the -fold finite difference is the alternating sum over independent positive/negative resolutions, and type at most two means that every third finite difference is zero.
Framed chord diagrams and four-term relations: a two-chord diagram is either intersecting or has an isolated chord; 1T kills the latter, and 4T has the alternating four-term sign convention.
The Kontsevich integral on parenthesized braids: the positive Artin half twist is the positive two-strand braid generator, and stacking an inverse half twist beside it cancels to the identity braid.
Oriented crossing signs, diagram writhe, and blackboard framing: a positive crossing has sign under the determinant convention, and the positive Artin half twist has that sign.
The Conway polynomial: its Definition records the skein interface and explicitly separates the existence-and-uniqueness obligation. That obligation is discharged in the supplier's Proof, step 3.1, using its labelled external input and finite uniqueness argument; it is not a conclusion of the Definition alone. The theorem here is conditional on the Conway skein invariant specified in the Given, and its coefficient arguments use only [F1].
Proof
Given: As above. All arguments use the unframed branch and no choice axiom.
For any skein triple, the constant coefficients of and agree because their difference is divisible by . Hence is unchanged by crossing switches. Choose a basepoint on each component of a link diagram and a finite order of the components; switch each crossing so its first encounter in that traversal is the overpass. The resulting diagram is descending: starting at each basepoint, every arc can be pulled successively over the portions it meets, in the chosen component order, until each component is a round circle in a separate ball. Thus every link can be changed by crossing switches to an unlink. For the -component unlink , the normalization gives . Add a local curl to one component of ; its positive and negative versions are both , while its oriented smoothing is the split unlink . The skein relation gives . Multiplication by the indeterminate is injective in : if and , then each coefficient is zero. Hence . Therefore for knots and for links with at least two components.
Comparing the coefficient of in the skein relation gives . In a two-component link, smoothing a mixed crossing yields a knot and therefore difference ; smoothing a self-crossing yields a three-component link and therefore difference , by step 1.1. The value of this first difference depends only on whether the crossing is mixed, not on any other crossing resolution.
At one singular crossing of a knot, the skein relation gives for its oriented two-component smoothing . On a three-singular knot, resolve one marked point first and apply the two remaining differences to this . By step 2.1, taking the difference at either remaining crossing gives of its oriented smoothing; that smoothing has either one or three components, so its is constant across the resolution of the last marked crossing by step 1.1. The final alternating difference is therefore zero. Since the marked point chosen first was arbitrary, every third finite difference of vanishes.
For a two-singular knot, smooth the first marked point. Its two preimages split the circle into two arcs, which become the two components of . The other marked crossing is mixed exactly when its two preimages lie on different arcs, equivalently when the two chord endpoints alternate with those of the first chord. By step 2.1 the resulting second difference is in that case and otherwise.
Define on the intersecting two-chord diagram and on the nonintersecting one. The latter is zero by 1T [F3]. If the cyclic order of the three fixed points is , the four diagrams in the 4T generator have intersection indicators ; if the order is , they have indicators . These exhaust the cyclic orders up to rotation. In either case . Thus factors through the unframed quotient. Since , that class is nonzero and the degree-two symbol in step 3.2 is nonzero.
The unknot normalization gives , hence . Let be the closure of a two-strand braid with two successive positive Artin half twists. Switching one crossing creates adjacent positive and negative half twists, which cancel by [F4] to the two-component unlink ; smoothing that crossing leaves a one-half-twist closure, an unknot with a removable type-I curl. Step 1.1 gives , so the skein relation yields . For the positive trefoil , the closure of three successive positive half twists, switching one crossing leaves an adjacent positive-negative pair that cancels and hence an unknot; smoothing that crossing leaves . Therefore , so .
Depends on
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
12 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Introduction to Vassiliev Knot Invariants, §§2.3 and 3.1.1 (standard reference, not scraped)
- Polyak–Viro Formulas for Coefficients of the Conway Polynomial, §§3.4–4.2 (standard reference, not scraped)