Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedprecheck pass
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The sine and cosine systems are complete orthogonal systems of L^2 on an interval and on a rectangle

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Countable Choice ACω (The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω)). Let L>0 and R=(0,L1)×(0,L2) with L1,L2>0. (a) [One interval] The families {cos⁡(mπx/L)}m≥0 and {sin⁡(mπx/L)}m≥1 are orthogonal complete systems in the real Hilbert space L2(0,L) (The space Lp(μ) as the quotient by null functions, L2 with the integral pairing is a Hilbert space, Orthonormal families, complete orthonormal systems and Hilbert bases): each is orthogonal, and its closed linear span is all of L2(0,L). (b) [Rectangle] With m,n ranging over N0 in cosine slots and over N≥1 in sine slots, each of the four product families {cos⁡mπx1L1cos⁡nπx2L2}, {cos⁡mπx1L1sin⁡nπx2L2}, {sin⁡mπx1L1cos⁡nπx2L2} and {sin⁡mπx1L1sin⁡nπx2L2} is an orthogonal complete system in L2(R); in particular the Neumann family {hmn}m,n≥0 and the Dirichlet family {emn}m,n≥1 of The separated sine and cosine rectangle profiles: eigen-identities, boundary traces, orthogonality and Dirichlet integrals are orthogonal complete systems in L2(R).

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The Axiom of Countable Choice; a length L>0, rectangle dimensions L1,L2>0; the real Hilbert space L2(0,L) (similarly L2(R)) of The space Lp(μ) as the quotient by null functions with inner product ⟨f,g⟩=∫fg and norm ∥⋅∥2 (L2 with the integral pairing is a Hilbert space); and the one-interval families cm(x):=cos⁡(mπx/L) (m≥0), sp(x):=sin⁡(pπx/L) (p≥1).

[F1]

On real L2(μ) the formula ⟨f,g⟩=∫fg dμ is an inner product with ⟨f,f⟩=∥f∥22, L2(μ) is complete for the induced norm, and ∣∫fg∣≤∥f∥2∥g∥2 for f,g∈L2 (L2 with the integral pairing is a Hilbert space, Cauchy-Schwarz inequality for L2, The space Lp(μ) as the quotient by null functions). A family is orthogonal when its distinct members pair to 0 and complete when its closed linear span is the whole space (Orthonormal families, complete orthonormal systems and Hilbert bases).

[F2]

Assume ACω (The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω)); the torus T=R/Z carries the normalized Haar integral mT and the characters ek([t])=exp⁡(2πikt), and the characters form an orthonormal basis of the complex Hilbert space L2(T;C) (The one-dimensional torus and its normalized Haar integral, The trigonometric system is complete in L2 of the torus); for real φ, exp⁡(iφ)=cos⁡φ+isin⁡φ (exp⁡(x+iy)=ex(cos⁡y+isin⁡y), ∣exp⁡(x+iy)∣=ex, and eiπ+1=0).

[F3]

Change of variables: invertible linear maps T scale Lebesgue measure by ∣det⁡T∣ (A linear map T of Rn sends Lebesgue measurable sets to Lebesgue measurable sets, with λn(T[E])=∣det⁡T∣ λn(E) when T is invertible and T[E] Lebesgue null when it is not), and a C1 diffeomorphism T:U→V substitutes in L1 integrands by ∫Vf=∫Uf∘T ∣det⁡DT∣ (A C^1 diffeomorphism satisfies the change-of-variables formula for L^1 functions); both hold under ACω. In particular the affine substitutions t↦2Lt and x↦−x below preserve integrability and transform the displayed integrals.

[F4]

Fubini for L1: for sigma-finite spaces and h∈L1(μ×ν), the sections are a.e. integrable, the section-integral functions are integrable, and the iterated and double integrals agree (Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product).

[F6]

sin⁡(A+B)=sin⁡Acos⁡B+cos⁡Asin⁡B and cos⁡(A+B)=cos⁡Acos⁡B−sin⁡Asin⁡B for real A,B (The addition formulas for sine and cosine); sine is odd, cosine is even, and sin⁡2+cos⁡2=1 (Parity and the Pythagorean identity for sine and cosine).

[F7]

Every f∈L2(R) satisfies ∫R∣f∣2<+∞; bounded measurable factors on the finite-measure rectangle preserve L1 and L2 membership, and ∫R∣fg∣≤∥f∥2∥g∥2 is the Cauchy–Schwarz estimate (Cauchy-Schwarz inequality for L2, The space Lp(μ) as the quotient by null functions, L2 with the integral pairing is a Hilbert space, Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product).

[F8]

Assume ACω; if (ei)i∈I is a complete orthonormal family in a real or complex Hilbert space and x is in the space, then the finite-subset net of partial sums ∑i∈F⟨x,ei⟩ei converges to x (Fourier expansion in a Hilbert space).

[F9]

The profiles of The separated sine and cosine rectangle profiles: eigen-identities, boundary traces, orthogonality and Dirichlet integrals satisfy hmn=cm(1)⊗cn(2) and emn=sm(1)⊗sn(2), where the superscripts select the x1- and x2-families, and the lemma states their rectangle orthogonality and norms. The four families of clause (b) are the products c(i)⊗d(j) of one cosine or sine family on each factor.

Proof

technique · direct: compute the one-dimensional inner products with the product-to-sum identities and the fundamental theorem, transfer completeness of the trigonometric system of the torus to the interval through even and odd periodic extensions, and obtain the rectangle families by Fubini and one completeness argument applied on each factor
1.1F5F6algebra

[One-interval inner products] Let m,m′≥0 and p,p′≥1 be integers. By [F6], cos⁡mπxLcos⁡m′πxL=12[cos⁡(m−m′)πxL+cos⁡(m+m′)πxL] and sin⁡pπxLsin⁡p′πxL=12[cos⁡(p−p′)πxL−cos⁡(p+p′)πxL]; for every nonzero integer k the function x↦Lkπsin⁡kπxL has derivative cos⁡kπxL on [0,L] by [F5], so ∫0Lcos⁡kπxLdx=Lkπ[sin⁡(kπ)−sin⁡0]=0 by [F5], [F6] (the case k=0, i.e. m=m′ or p=p′, leaves the constant 1 or the difference 0). The integrands are continuous, hence Riemann integrable [F5], and their Riemann and Lebesgue integrals agree [F5]. Therefore ⟨cm,cm′⟩=0 for m≠m′, ⟨sp,sp′⟩=0 for p≠p′, while ⟨cm,cm⟩=L2(1+δm0) and ⟨sp,sp⟩=L2 are nonzero; each displayed member is nonzero because it equals 1 at some point of [0,L]. Hence both families of clause (a) are orthogonal in the sense of [F1].

1.2F1F2F3F6algebra

[Even extensions have vanishing torus coefficients] Let f∈L2(0,L) satisfy ⟨f,cm⟩=0 for every m≥0. Define F(x):=f(∣x∣) on (−L,L) and let G be the 2L-periodic extension of F to R; define g([t]):=G(2Lt) on T. Then g is a real-valued element of L2(T;C): by [F1], [F3] the change of variables x↦2Lt and the periodicity give ∫T∣g∣2dmT=∫01∣G(2Lt)∣2dt=12L∫02L∣G∣2=12L∫−LL∣F∣2=1L∥f∥22<∞. Splitting the integral at 0, substituting x↦−x on (−L,0) by [F3] and using F(−x)=F(x), its character coefficients are g^(k)=∫01G(2Lt)e−2πiktdt=12L∫−LLF(x)e−iπkx/Ldx=12L∫0Lf(x)(e−iπkx/L+eiπkx/L)dx=1L∫0Lf(x)cos⁡kπxLdx=1L⟨f,c∣k∣⟩=0 for every k∈Z, using the affine substitutions, the periodicity of G, the cartesian form of [F2] and the parity of [F6] for the identification with cos⁡kπxL=cos⁡∣k∣πxL.

1.3F1F2algebra

[Trivial orthogonal complement in L2] We record the Hilbert-space step used below. Let H be a real or complex Hilbert space, let V⊆H be the closed linear span of a family (vi)i∈I, and suppose the only w∈H with ⟨w,vi⟩=0 for every i is w=0. Then V=H: for u∈H put d:=inf⁡v∈V∥u−v∥; under [F2] (countable choice) choose vn∈V with ∥u−vn∥→d, and the parallelogram identity ∥vn−vm∥2=2∥u−vn∥2+2∥u−vm∥2−4∥u−vn+vm2∥2≤2∥u−vn∥2+2∥u−vm∥2−4d2 of [F1] makes (vn) Cauchy, so vn→v∗∈V by closedness and completeness; if d>0 then z:=u−v∗≠0 and for every w∈V and real ε one has d2≤∥z−εw∥2=d2−2εRe⁡⟨z,w⟩+ε2∥w∥2, so taking ε=Re⁡⟨z,w⟩/∥w∥2 for w≠0 forces Re⁡⟨z,w⟩=0; when H is complex, applying that conclusion to iw in place of w gives Im⁡⟨z,w⟩=0 as well, so ⟨z,w⟩=0 in either case; in particular ⟨z,vi⟩=0 for all i, contradicting the hypothesis, so d=0 and u∈V.

1.4F1F2

[Torus elements with all coefficients zero vanish] If h∈L2(T;C) has h^(k)=0 for every k, then h=0: by [F2] the characters are complete orthonormal, so Cauchy–Schwarz [F1] makes ⟨h,φ⟩=0 for every φ in their closed span, which is all of L2(T;C), and ⟨h,h⟩=0 gives h=0.

2.1step 1.2F1F2F3F6algebra

[Odd extensions have vanishing torus coefficients] Let f∈L2(0,L) satisfy ⟨f,sp⟩=0 for every p≥1. Define F(x):=sgn⁡(x)f(∣x∣) (so F is odd and F=f on (0,L)) and define G,g from F as in step 1.2. The same change of variables and periodicity give ∥g∥2=1L∥f∥22<∞, and now the reflection substitution yields g^(k)=12L∫−LLF(x)e−iπkx/Ldx=12L∫0Lf(x)(e−iπkx/L−eiπkx/L)dx=−iL∫0Lf(x)sin⁡kπxLdx; by the parity of sine this is −isgn⁡(k)L⟨f,s∣k∣⟩=0 for k≠0 and 0 for k=0.

2.2step 1.1step 1.2step 1.3step 1.4F3

[Interval completeness, cosine case] Let f∈L2(0,L) be orthogonal to every cm. Step 1.2 produces g∈L2(T;C) whose character coefficients all vanish, so g=0 by step 1.4, and hence G(2Lt)=0 for almost every t∈[0,1). By [F3] (the linear map t↦2Lt scales Lebesgue measure by 2L) the set of x∈(0,2L) with G(x)≠0 is null, so F, hence f, vanishes almost everywhere on (0,L). Thus the only element of L2(0,L) orthogonal to the cosine family is 0; by step 1.3 with the family (cm) the closed span of the cosine family is L2(0,L), and step 1.1 gives orthogonality.

2.3step 1.1F4F7algebra

[Rectangle orthogonality] Let c denote either of the two x1-families and d either of the two x2-families of clause (b); all members are continuous, hence bounded and measurable on the closed rectangle. For members cm⊗dn and cm′⊗dn′, the product (cmcm′)(dndn′) is bounded and measurable on the finite-measure rectangle, hence in L1, and Fubini [F4] factors the inner product as ⟨cm⊗dn, cm′⊗dn′⟩=⟨cm,cm′⟩⟨dn,dn′⟩; this vanishes whenever (m,n)≠(m′,n′) by step 1.1 (a member with a matching index has nonzero squared norm L12(1+δm0) or L12, or the analogous x2-norm). Hence each of the four product families is orthogonal in L2(R).

3.1step 1.1step 1.3step 1.4step 2.1F3

[Interval completeness, sine case] The same argument with step 2.1 in place of step 1.2 shows that the only element of L2(0,L) orthogonal to the sine family is 0, so its closed span is L2(0,L) by step 1.3, and it is orthogonal by step 1.1; this proves clause (a) together with step 2.2.

4.1step 1.3step 2.2step 2.3step 3.1F1F4F7F9choose

[Rectangle completeness] Fix one of the four product families c⊗d in L2(R) and let f∈L2(R) be orthogonal to every cm⊗dn. By Fubini applied to the integrable function ∣f∣2 [F4], the section f(⋅,x2) lies in L2(0,L1) for almost every x2, and the identities of [F4] applied to the integrable function fcm define measurable functions φm(x2):=∫0L1f(x1,x2)cm(x1)dx1 almost everywhere, with ∫0L2∣φm∣2≤∥cm∥22∥f∥22<∞ by Cauchy–Schwarz [F7], so φm∈L2(0,L2); and Fubini applied to fcmdn gives ⟨φm,dn⟩=⟨f,cm⊗dn⟩=0 for every n. Since the d-family is complete in L2(0,L2) by step 2.2 or step 3.1, Cauchy–Schwarz [F1] makes φm orthogonal to the whole closed span, so φm=0 almost everywhere. There are countably many m, so [F2] (countable choice) selects the countably many exceptional null sets whose union N is null, and for every x2∉N the section f(⋅,x2)∈L2(0,L1) is orthogonal to every cm, hence vanishes almost everywhere in x1 by step 2.2 or step 3.1. Fubini applied to ∣f∣2 [F4] now gives ∥f∥22=0, so f=0. By step 1.3 the closed span of the product family is L2(R); with step 2.3 this proves the first claim of clause (b) for all four parity choices, and the identification of [F9] gives the claim for the Neumann family {hmn} and the Dirichlet family {emn}.

5.1step 1.1step 2.2step 2.3step 3.1step 4.1F1F8algebra∎

[Expansions] For each system (ui) of clauses (a) and (b), put vi:=ui/∥ui∥2; the norms are nonzero and (vi) is a complete orthonormal system of [F1]. By [F8], every f in the space is the norm limit of the finite-subset net ∑i∈F⟨f,vi⟩vi. Since ⟨f,vi⟩vi=(⟨f,ui⟩/∥ui∥22)ui, the corresponding coefficients in the original orthogonal system are ⟨f,ui⟩/∥ui∥22, obtained by dividing the normalized coefficients by ∥ui∥2.

Depends on

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Sources