How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Positive-degree cohomology of a compact manifold is nilpotent
Statement
Assume AC. Let be a compact finite-dimensional Hausdorff second-countable smooth manifold without boundary, equipped with a Riemannian metric, and let be a field. There is a finite CW complex homotopy equivalent to , and an integer such that for every . Consequently the ideal in the graded cohomology ring satisfies . If , take , , and .
Statement references
[Finite-dimensional support in the localization proof] Atiyah–Bott, Section 3, printed pp. 6–9
[Finite cover and Mayer–Vietoris route] Dwivedi et al., Section 9.10, PDF pp. 86–87
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, a compact smooth Riemannian manifold , and a field .
Full AC includes the countable-choice hypothesis of the convex-neighborhood theorem. The Axiom of Choice
Every point has a strongly geodesically convex open neighborhood, every finite nonempty intersection of such neighborhoods remains strongly geodesically convex, and its unique minimizing geodesics depend smoothly on endpoints. Existence of geodesically convex neighborhoods
Homotopic maps induce the same singular cohomology map with coefficients in . Homotopy invariance of singular cohomology with field coefficients
An open two-set cover has the singular cohomology Mayer–Vietoris long exact sequence, and cohomology is computed as cocycles modulo coboundaries of the singular cochain complex. Mayer vietoris sequence in singular cohomology Singular cochain complex with coefficients Singular cohomology with coefficients The singular boundary operator
A compact smooth Riemannian manifold has a finite strongly geodesically convex cover whose finite nerve realization is homotopy equivalent to it. A compact smooth manifold has a finite good-cover nerve model
Proof
Given: The data in the statement.
For , choose the finite cover together with its nerve homotopy equivalence supplied by [F4], with . Every nonempty finite intersection is strongly geodesically convex. Choosing a point in that intersection, the unique minimizing geodesics to it give a continuous contraction to the point; by [F2] and the singular cochain definition in [F3], its cohomology is in degree zero and zero in positive degrees. For a point, this follows from the unique singular -simplex: its boundary coefficient is for even and for odd , so the positive-degree cochain complex is alternately identity and zero and has zero cohomology. The nerve of this same cover has at most vertices; its usual realization, with one open cell for each nonempty simplex, is a finite CW complex homotopy equivalent to by the chosen [F4] data.
We prove by induction on the number of members of a finite good cover that its union has cohomology zero in every degree . For , step 1.1 makes the member contractible, giving the claim. Empty cover members have zero cohomology by [F3] and may be discarded; if none remain the union is empty and the assertion holds. For , write and . The intersection is covered by the sets , whose nonempty finite intersections are contractible by step 1.1. The induction hypothesis gives and for ; also since . The exact segment from [F3] therefore forces .
Apply step 2.1 to the selected finite cover of to get for . Every homogeneous factor of a product of elements of has positive degree, so the product has degree at least and vanishes; expanding finite sums proves . For empty , every cohomology group is zero by the empty-space cochain complex, so works.
Depends on
The Axiom of Choice
Homotopy invariance of singular cohomology with field coefficients
A compact smooth manifold has a finite good-cover nerve model
Existence of geodesically convex neighborhoods
Mayer vietoris sequence in singular cohomology
The singular boundary operator
Singular cochain complex with coefficients
Singular cohomology with coefficients