Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: AI-adaptedProof: AI-generatedPipeline-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

A proper closed subgroup of a torus has a nonzero annihilating character

Statement

Assume countable choice. Let T=(R/Z)r with r≥1, and let H⊊T be a closed subgroup. A character means a smooth group homomorphism from T to the multiplicative unit circle S1={z∈C:∣z∣=1}. Then there is a nontrivial character χ:T→S1 whose restriction to all of H is the trivial character.

Statement references

[Proper isotropy character in the localization argument] Atiyah–Bott, Section 3, printed pp. 6–8

[Closed-subgroup quotient and exponential construction] Dwivedi et al., Section 9.10, PDF pp. 86–87

Facts & Assumptions

Given: Countable choice, the product torus T, and a proper closed subgroup H.

[A1]

Countable choice supplies the embedded Lie subgroup and smooth quotient structures used here. The Axiom of Countable Choice (ACω)

[F1]

For a closed subgroup H of a finite-dimensional Lie group T, the quotient Q=T/H is a smooth manifold, the quotient map is a surjective submersion, and its dimension is dim⁡T−dim⁡H. Quotient manifold by a closed Lie subgroup

[F2]

The exponential map of a finite-dimensional Lie group is smooth, has identity differential at zero, and is obtained from its one-parameter subgroups. The Lie-group exponential map is smooth with identity differential at zero One-parameter subgroups are integral curves of left-invariant fields Exponential scales one-parameter subgroups One-parameter subgroup of a Lie group

[F3]

A smooth map with invertible differential is a diffeomorphism on some open neighborhoods. The smooth inverse function theorem on manifolds

[F5]

A smooth submersion has local coordinate form (u,v)↦u and hence smooth local sections, obtained by fixing v. The constant-rank theorem for manifolds

Proof

Given: The data in the statement.

1.1A1F1F4F5givenalgebra

Since T is compact and connected, Q=T/H is compact and connected, and [F1] makes π:T→Q a smooth surjective submersion. As T is abelian, H is normal: the operations (aH)(bH)=(ab)H and (aH)−1=a−1H are independent of representatives and give an abelian group with identity H. By [F5], each point of Q has an open neighborhood U and a smooth section sU:U→T with πsU=id⁡U. On U×V, multiplication is (x,y)↦π(sU(x)sV(y)); on U, inversion is x↦π(sU(x)−1). These formulas prove both operations smooth, so Q is a Lie group. It is not a point because H⊊T; a zero-dimensional manifold is discrete, and connectedness would then make it a point. Hence d=dim⁡Q≥1.

2.1F2F3step 1.1

Let q=TeQ. The exponential map exp⁡Q:q→Q has differential the identity at zero by [F2], so [F3] makes it a diffeomorphism from a neighborhood of zero onto a neighborhood of the identity. Since Q is abelian, exp⁡Q(X+Y)=exp⁡Q(X)exp⁡Q(Y): the product of the one-parameter subgroups with velocities X,Y is a one-parameter subgroup with velocity X+Y, and uniqueness of integral curves gives the identity. Thus exp⁡Q(q) is a subgroup containing an open identity neighborhood, hence is open. Its other cosets are open, so its complement is open; connectedness of Q gives exp⁡Q(q)=Q. The kernel Λ=ker⁡(exp⁡Q) is discrete because the exponential is injective near zero. Translating its local inverse shows that exp⁡Q is open, so it induces a homeomorphism q/Λ≅Q.

3.1F4step 2.1algebra

The linear span of Λ is all of q. Otherwise the quotient linear map q→q/span⁡RΛ factors through the compact space Q=q/Λ and is onto a nonzero real vector space; that is impossible by [F4]. A discrete additive subgroup of a finite-dimensional real vector space that spans it is a lattice. To see this, a discrete subgroup has a neighborhood of zero containing no other subgroup point, so distinct subgroup points are uniformly separated and every bounded subset of it is finite. Choose a shortest nonzero vector λ1; the intersection with Rλ1 is Zλ1, since any smaller positive step would contradict shortestness. If projections of subgroup points to λ1⊥ approach zero, subtract nearest integer multiples of λ1; the resulting points lie in a bounded set, hence in a finite set, so zero is isolated in the projected subgroup. The projection remains discrete and spans λ1⊥. Induction on d gives a lattice basis for the projection; lifting that finite basis and adjoining λ1 gives a Z-basis λ1,…,λd of Λ that is also a real basis of q.

4.1F2step 2.1step 3.1algebra

Define the nonzero real linear functional ℓ:q→R by ℓ(λ1)=1 and ℓ(λj)=0 for 2≤j≤d. Then ℓ(Λ)⊆Z. Define χQ(exp⁡QX):=exp⁡(2πi ℓ(X)). This is well defined because two logarithms differ by an element of Λ. It is a homomorphism by additivity of both the exponential map on the abelian Lie algebra and ℓ; it is smooth because the exponential map is a local diffeomorphism near zero and its translates are local diffeomorphisms everywhere. It is nontrivial: exp⁡Q(λ1/2)≠e, while χQ(exp⁡Q(λ1/2))=−1.

5.1F1step 4.1construct∎

Let π:T→Q be the quotient homomorphism and set χ=χQ∘π. Surjectivity of π makes χ nontrivial, while π(H)=e makes χ∣H=1. This proves the assertion.

Depends on

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Sources