How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Controlled weak-field first variation of the relativistic force law and the leading Thomson-model cross section
Conditional weak-field (small-amplitude) first variation of the adopted relativistic external-force law for a test charge in an ideal plane wave: the linearized periodic displacement, the induced harmonic dipole amplitude , and the resulting leading Thomson-model cross section independent of frequency. Excluded: exact Newtonian force laws, existence, persistence, stability or self-consistency of the weak-field family, self-force and radiation reaction, material media, quantum and atomic-resonance content, and every measured, statistical or empirical claim. The nonlinear family remains on any common open containing ; only its harmonic first-order ODE response is globally extended and periodically prepared. is a zeroth-order rest/reference position, with arbitrary first-order response mean ; no exact nonlinear-family mean or periodicity is claimed. All zero-charge and complex-polarization cases remain.
Statement
Assume Countable Choice () as carried by Differential and total cross sections of the ideal harmonic dipole in a plane wave, with actual-source fidelity bounds; the linearization below and Periodic responses of and the affine classification of all solutions use no choice. Assume the setting and postulates of The four-force equation reproduces the coordinate Lorentz force and power for a test particle with charge parameter (Charge parameter, frame charge and current densities, volume charge and flux, and the four-current(a)) and externally supplied rest mass , in the incident plane-wave field of Real plane-wave fields encoded by complex amplitudes with wavevector , complex amplitude , , and as in Differential and total cross sections of the ideal harmonic dipole in a plane wave, with actual-source fidelity bounds; write and (Real and imaginary parts, complex conjugation, and modulus, Laboratory geometry: a restricted inertial chart, its spatial slices and fixed-time fields, Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values). Assume that for some and a common open interval , for every there is a future timelike massive solution of the adopted four-force law in the external field (no self-field, recoil or material force), and that the family admits a uniform first-order expansion: there are and, for every compact , a constant with
about a fixed position . The family time interval is not required to contain a full period, and no solution outside is assumed. For the periodic-response conclusions (b), (c), impose the following explicit preparation (P): the unique global harmonic-ODE extension of supplied after (a) by Periodic responses of and the affine classification of all solutions(d), with its actual value and derivative at , is -periodic, . Equivalently its affine drift is zero, or with . The linearized equation and affine local/global classification in (a) hold for every stated family even without (P); overlap-only periodicity on a short is not substituted for (P). Then: (a) [Linearized equation] on . (b) [Induced dipole under preparation (P)] is the zeroth-order rest/reference position. Let be the mean of the global periodic first-order response, so on one has with . The arbitrary constant is retained: no exact mean or periodicity of the full nonlinear family is asserted. The oscillating part of the first-order dipole coefficient is with complex amplitude
equivalently with (units ) and the unimodular factor , . (c) [Leading Thomson-model cross section] substituting this into Differential and total cross sections of the ideal harmonic dipole in a plane wave, with actual-source fidelity bounds(b) gives
independent of and of the phase factor. (d) [Scope] this is a controlled conditional first variation of the adopted relativistic external-force law under the stated solution-family hypotheses. It is not the exact Newtonian force postulate, it does not assert existence, persistence, stability or self-consistency of the family, it excludes self-force, radiation reaction and material media, and it makes no empirical, measurement, atomic-physics or frequency-response claim. In (a), every local has the unique global harmonic extension , with , . Thus the general affine-drift response is also retained; preparation (P) sets for (b), (c) and leaves arbitrary. For a nonzero , the associated leading ideal harmonic model has incident amplitude and induced dipole amplitude . Their squared flux factors cancel in its cross-section ratio; is this leading-model coefficient, not an assertion of the exact nonlinear particle's emitted field or cross section. At the induced amplitude and are zero without any division by . All estimates apply only to the open parameter domain on which the family was declared.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The setting, family and preparation (P) of the Statement: charge and mass (Charge parameter, frame charge and current densities, volume charge and flux, and the four-current, Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values); the plane-wave data with , , ; the family on the common open interval with the uniform first-order expansion about ; the first-order function ; the harmonic data and .
Adopted force law (external supplier, whose carrier is the referenced in-run item): under its postulates, with the coordinate reading , velocity and of a future timelike massive worldline in a prescribed exterior field , the coordinate momentum satisfies and ; the norm is constant and a solution with future timelike data remains future timelike; and for every , wherever , and , with constants depending only on ; the statement is conditional on the adopted postulates and excludes self-force, radiation reaction and material media (The four-force equation reproduces the coordinate Lorentz force and power, Charge parameter, frame charge and current densities, volume charge and flux, and the four-current, Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values, Laboratory geometry: a restricted inertial chart, its spatial slices and fixed-time fields).
Plane-wave fields: , are jointly on (Real plane-wave fields encoded by complex amplitudes, Real and imaginary parts, complex conjugation, and modulus, , , and ); in particular, on every compact subset of they and their first derivatives are bounded, and on a compact interval the maps , are continuous (A continuous real-valued function on a nonempty compact metric space is bounded and attains a greatest and a least value, A continuous function on is Riemann integrable, by Heine-Cantor and Riemann's criterion). On a compact spatial ball times , integrating each bounded spatial derivative along the segment from to with The second fundamental theorem: if is differentiable on with and is integrable, then and The chain rule for total derivatives: gives , uniformly for ; the componentwise integral bounds are those of If on then for every partition ; in particular every constant function is integrable, with .
Harmonic response lemma: for , , , the particular solution is with and is -periodic; every solution of that equation on is with unique ; it is -periodic if and only if ; on any nonempty open interval the local solutions have a unique global extension ; with , and for the mean over every complete period is (Periodic responses of and the affine classification of all solutions).
Cross-section theorem: for the ideal harmonic model with incident amplitude and dipole amplitude , the total model cross section is , and the scalar branch with is ; the result assumes Countable Choice as carried by its suppliers (Differential and total cross sections of the ideal harmonic dipole in a plane wave, with actual-source fidelity bounds, The Axiom of Countable Choice ()).
Elementary calculus and algebra: vector-valued differentiation and integration are componentwise (The derivative and the Riemann integral of a vector-valued function: an intrinsic derivative and a componentwise integral); the second fundamental theorem evaluates for integrable (The second fundamental theorem: if is differentiable on with and is integrable, then ), a continuous real function on a closed interval is Riemann integrable (A continuous function on is Riemann integrable, by Heine-Cantor and Riemann's criterion), the first fundamental theorem differentiates the integral function (The first fundamental theorem: if is integrable on and continuous at , then ; in particular a continuous has as a primitive), and on gives with the corresponding error bound (If on then for every partition ; in particular every constant function is integrable, with ); sums, products and compositions of differentiable maps obey the algebra and chain rules (Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: , , , and when , The chain rule for total derivatives: ); the cross product is bilinear and alternating with (The cross product is bilinear, alternating, and orthogonal to both factors); and for real (, , and ).
Proof
[Uniform smallness of the velocity and of ] Let be a nonempty compact interval containing in its interior (any compact subinterval of containing will do); the expansion hypothesis gives for and , where is finite by continuity on the compact . Choose with ; then for every has , so the low-speed clause of [F1] with gives for a constant depending only on and the data, uniformly in .
[Uniform convergence of the scaled momentum and of its derivative] With and , write ; by the expansion hypothesis uniformly on with error , and by step 1.1 while is uniformly bounded, so uniformly on as with . Moreover, dividing the exact coordinate force law of [F1] by gives, for and , , and this right-hand side converges uniformly on to : the spatial Lipschitz bound of [F2] on a compact tube around gives uniformly by the expansion, while by [F2] and the bilinearity and norm bound of [F5].
[First-order equation] Fix with and fix a component index . The scalar map is on with continuous derivative , so is Riemann integrable on every closed subinterval of by [F5]; splitting at and applying the second fundamental theorem [F5] to the intervals for and for (with the orientation convention of the displayed one-sided differences) gives, for every , . By the uniform convergence of step 2.1 applied componentwise, the integrands converge uniformly on to , so the integral bound of [F5] lets : the left side tends to and the right side to . The fundamental theorem [F5] differentiates the right side in to , and the left side is differentiable with derivative ; hence componentwise on . Every point lies in such a compact containing , so the identity holds on all of and is clause (a).
[Harmonic classification and the induced dipole] Equation (a) reads on with by [F2]. By the local-clause of the harmonic lemma [F3], on one has for a unique pair , the same formula defines the unique global extension of , and exactly when is -periodic, equivalently when (differentiating at with the rules of [F5]). Preparation (P) therefore says exactly , so on we have with the mean of the periodic extension over every complete period by [F3]. Then with , because ; writing one has by [F5], so with . The arbitrary mean is retained and no mean or periodicity of the nonlinear family is asserted; this is clause (b).
[Thomson cross section] Apply the cross-section formula of [F4] with the incident amplitude and dipole amplitude of step 4.1: , and because ; substituting cancels and and gives . Multiplying out, , the same value, and it depends neither on nor on the phase factor beyond the unimodular ; this is clause (c).
[Scope and choice accounting] Clause (d) records the exact content: the result is a conditional first variation of the adopted external-force law under the stated family and preparation hypotheses, with the affine drift retained in general and set to zero only by (P) for (b) and (c); no existence, persistence, stability or self-consistency of the family, no self-force, radiation reaction or material content, and no empirical, atomic or frequency-response claim is made. The scaling statement is a remark on the leading model: for nonzero the incident amplitude and the induced amplitude scale together, so the ratio defining is unchanged; at the amplitude and vanish by direct substitution without any division by . The only choice principle used is the Countable Choice carried by the cross-section theorem [F4]; the uniform-limit, integral and harmonic-classification arguments use only the explicit suppliers [F1], [F3], [F5] and finite compact intervals.
Source notes
- Supplier reconciled. The supplier
pthm-em-relativistic-lorentz-forceis now authored (carrier on disk, level 18) and its exact clauses were checked against the uses here: clause (a) supplies the coordinate force law for , clause (b) the constancy of with the future-timelike branch, and clause (c) the controlled low-speed bounds and on any interval where , with constants depending only on . The constants agree with [F1], step 1.1 uses exactly the instance, and step 2.1 divides the exact coordinate ODE by ; the earlier open obligation is cleared with no change of formulation. - The identity and the phase factor are inherited from the plane-wave definition; the phase is not absorbed into a redefinition of the incident amplitude in clause (b).
Depends on
The four-force equation reproduces the coordinate Lorentz force and power
Differential and total cross sections of the ideal harmonic dipole in a plane wave, with actual-source fidelity bounds
Periodic responses of and the affine classification of all solutions
Real plane-wave fields encoded by complex amplitudes
Charge parameter, frame charge and current densities, volume charge and flux, and the four-current
Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values
Laboratory geometry: a restricted inertial chart, its spatial slices and fixed-time fields
Real and imaginary parts, complex conjugation, and modulus
The Axiom of Countable Choice ()
The first fundamental theorem: if is integrable on and continuous at , then ; in particular a continuous has as a primitive
The second fundamental theorem: if is differentiable on with and is integrable, then
If on then for every partition ; in particular every constant function is integrable, with
The derivative and the Riemann integral of a vector-valued function: an intrinsic derivative and a componentwise integral
, , and
Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: , , , and when
The chain rule for total derivatives:
The cross product is bilinear, alternating, and orthogonal to both factors
A continuous real-valued function on a nonempty compact metric space is bounded and attains a greatest and a least value
A continuous function on is Riemann integrable, by Heine-Cantor and Riemann's criterion
Dependency tree · 2 levels
Sources
- David Tong, Electromagnetism (University of Cambridge Part II Mathematical Tripos, author-hosted complete 236-page notes)
- R. Fitzpatrick, Classical Electromagnetism, node 96 'Thompson scattering' (University of Texas at Austin)
- N. Beisert, Elektrodynamik, ETH Zurich 2024 FS, section 12.3 'Streuung an Materie'