Alphabeta Math
DefinitionDefinition: AI-adaptedProof: AI-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Exact bifurcate-sphere package for the IK criterion

Definition

For the end, section and exterior in Exact asymptotic and orbit package for the IK criterion, set S0=∂I−(Mend)∩∂I+(Mend). The IK SBS package requires S0⊂Σ0 to be an embedded two-sphere equal to ∣x∣=1 under the chosen identification of Σ0 with {∣x∣>1/2}. In a neighborhood O of S0, require H+=O∩∂I−(Mend) and H−=O∩∂I+(Mend) to be smooth embedded null hypersurfaces, each diffeomorphic to S0×(−1,1), intersecting transversely in S0. Require both to be non-expanding, meaning their null second fundamental forms have zero trace. Here the null second fundamental form is χL(X,Y)=g(∇XL,Y) on the two-dimensional spacelike quotient of a null hypersurface by its null normal line, for a smooth nonzero null normal L; its trace uses the quotient's induced positive metric. Finally T is tangent to both branches and is not identically zero on S0. Nullness and transversality follow the conventions in Bifurcate Killing horizons, rotation and normalization; this package does not require T itself to be a null generator.

Facts & Assumptions

[F1]

The AF package fixes the ambient smooth time-oriented Lorentzian four-manifold, end, section, exterior and stationary field, with the inherited ZFC conventions. Exact asymptotic and orbit package for the IK criterion

[F2]

A smooth null hypersurface has a tangent metric with nonzero radical; its null normal line is that radical. The embeddedness and transversality conventions are those of Bifurcate Killing horizons, rotation and normalization. No Killing generator is assumed for either branch here.

[F3]

The ambient metric has signature (−,+,+,+), and its Levi–Civita connection is torsion-free and metric-compatible: Xg(U,V)=g(∇XU,V)+g(U,∇XV) and ∇XY−∇YX=[X,Y]. Stationary Lorentzian data and tensor conventions

[F4]

For a smooth null hypersurface whose tangent metric is positive semidefinite of rank two, the normal-screen supplier gives the smooth positive quotient L⊥/RL and its identification with a transverse spacelike section. Derivatives of fields along the hypersurface use the pullback connection. Its Countable Choice assumption is supplied by the inherited ZFC convention. Only these clauses of Local null normal pairs and the positive screen quotient are used; its affine-generator descent clause is replaced by the local argument below.

[F5]

A smooth vector bundle map over the identity of a smooth base with constant fibre rank has a smooth kernel subbundle. In particular, a rank-two map from a rank-three bundle has a smooth rank-one kernel, with smooth nonzero local sections. Constant-rank kernels and images of bundle maps over one base are subbundles

Justification

Given: Either smooth null branch H in the Definition, with its ambient Lorentzian metric and Levi–Civita connection. Work locally on H; the smooth nonzero null normal L used below will be obtained in step 1.1.

1.1 At a point p, nondegeneracy of the ambient metric and codimension one give dim⁡(TpH)⊥=1. Choose a nonzero vector Lp in the radical. Then (TpH)⊥=RLp and TpH=Lp⊥. In a basis with metric −(dx0)2+∣dx∣2, write Lp=a(1,u) with a≠0 and ∣u∣=1. Every vector of Lp⊥ is uniquely (b,bu+v) with u⋅v=0, and its squared norm is ∣v∣2. Thus the tangent metric is positive semidefinite of rank two with radical exactly RLp. View the induced metric as the smooth bundle map bH:TH→T∗H, bH(v)=g(v,⋅)∣TH. Its fibre rank is two by the preceding calculation, and its kernel is the radical. By F5 this kernel is a smooth line subbundle; choose a smooth nowhere-zero local section L. The quotient and its positive metric are therefore those in F4, reversing the sign of a local normal if needed for that supplier's future convention. In particular γˉ([X],[Y])=g(X,Y) is independent of representatives and positive definite. [given, F1, F2, F3, F4, F5, algebra]

2.1 For smooth tangent fields X on H, the bracket [L,X] is tangent to H. Metric compatibility and torsion freedom give g(∇LL,X)=−g(L,∇LX)=−g(L,∇XL+[L,X])=−12Xg(L,L)=0. Hence ∇LL lies in (TH)⊥=RL: there is a smooth local scalar κ with ∇LL=κL. Smoothness follows by dividing a nonvanishing component of L into the corresponding smooth component of ∇LL. This derives the required pregeodesic property for every such normal; it imposes no affine parametrization or Killing assumption. [given, F2, F3, step 1.1]

3.1 The pullback derivative ∇XL depends only on L along H: two smooth ambient extensions differ by a field vanishing on H, whose derivative in each tangent direction also vanishes there. The expression χL(X,Y)=g(∇XL,Y) is bilinear in the tangent vectors. Metric compatibility gives χL(X,L)=12Xg(L,L)=0, while step 2.1 gives χL(L,Y)=κg(L,Y)=0. Changing either representative by a multiple of L therefore leaves χL unchanged. It is symmetric because χL(X,Y)−χL(Y,X)=−g(L,∇XY−∇YX)=−g(L,[X,Y])=0. Thus it defines a smooth symmetric form on TH/RL, and its trace uses the inverse of the positive quotient metric established in step 1.1. [given, F2, F3, F4, step 1.1, step 2.1]

4.1 Any other nonzero local normal is fL for a smooth nowhere-zero function f. The connection product rule gives χfL(X,Y)=fχL(X,Y)+X(f)g(L,Y)=fχL(X,Y). The quotient metric is unchanged, so the trace is multiplied by f and its vanishing is independent of the chosen local normal. This makes the non-expansion predicate well-defined on both branches. The remaining clauses prescribe embedded sets and tangencies without asserting existence of a horizon generator Killing field. [given, F1, F2, F3, step 1.1, step 3.1] ∎

External input

The independent Ionescu–Klainerman source supplies the SBS predicates in section 1.2, SBS and footnotes 5–6, printed/PDF p. 7. Only this geometric definition package is imported. The quotient well-definedness and normal-rescaling argument above are local; no existence, vacuum field equation or analytic theorem is inferred from recording these predicates.

Depends on

Used by · 4

Dependency tree · 2 levels

Each result is drawn at its shortest distance from this item. Arrows run from prerequisites to the items that use them; this item has a heavier outline. External source nodes link directly to the cited text. The view shows up to two dependency steps; open a prerequisite to continue.

External dependencies

Ionescu–Klainerman, On the uniqueness of smooth, stationary black holes in vacuum · §1.2, SBS and footnotes 5–6, printed p. 7

SBS assumes transverse smooth non-expanding horizon branches and nontrivial tangential T on S0.

Hypotheses: The AF end and section are fixed.

Reading limits: Consulted the arXiv v2 PDF text of section 1.2, SBS and footnotes 5–6 on printed/PDF p. 7. No page-image inspection or later analytic proof reconstruction is claimed. This citation supplies the SBS predicates only; quotient geometry and descent are justified below with the declared mathematical suppliers and a local argument.

Sources