How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A regular point that is not smooth: a purely inseparable thickening
Statement refuted
False claim: every regular scheme of finite type over a field is smooth over that field. Let be a prime, let be the rational function field over the field of elements, and put with . Then , the ring is a field with and , and the extension is purely inseparable. The affine -scheme is of finite type over and regular, yet it is not smooth over ; base change along the purely inseparable extension satisfies a Noetherian local ring with unique prime , Krull dimension , embedding dimension and not regular, so after adjoining the th root of the regular point has become a nonregular point.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A prime , the field of rational functions in one variable over , the ring with the class of , and the Axiom of Choice.
For a field , is its rational function field; in particular and The characteristic of a ring: the least with when one exists, and otherwise: for every field the rational function field is a field whose elements are the fractions with and , and it contains an embedded copy of ; the characteristic of a ring is the least with , and is when no such exists.
For every field , is a unique factorisation domain: for every field , the polynomial ring is a unique factorisation domain.
is a field if and only if is a maximal ideal: for a commutative ring and an ideal , the quotient is a field if and only if is a maximal ideal.
Purely inseparable field algebras separate regularity from smoothness: under AC, let be a field of characteristic , let , and put with the class of . Then is a field, is injective, and ; the affine -scheme is of finite type over and regular; for every field extension and every with there is a -algebra isomorphism , where the target is a Noetherian local ring with unique prime , Krull dimension and embedding dimension , and is not regular; consequently is not smooth although is regular, the failure being witnessed already by and .
Purely inseparable algebraic extensions: an algebraic extension with is purely inseparable when for every there is with .
Algebraic and transcendental elements and algebraic extensions: an element of an extension is algebraic over when for some nonzero polynomial , and the extension is algebraic when every element is algebraic.
Frobenius is an injective endomorphism in characteristic , and an automorphism for finite fields: for a field of characteristic the Frobenius map is an injective field endomorphism, so and ; its -fold iterate is .
The Axiom of Choice: every family of nonempty sets has a choice function.
The stalk of the affine structure sheaf at a prime is A_p: for a prime there is a canonical isomorphism .
Counterexample
The field and its characteristic. By [F1] the field consists of the fractions with , , and contains an embedded copy of . In one has while for every integer with , since such an is not a multiple of ; a ring embedding preserves natural multiples of the identity, so in also and for . By the definition of characteristic in [F1] this is exactly , so is a field of characteristic .
The element is not a th power. Suppose with and ; then in the polynomial ring , which is a UFD by [F2]. Evaluation at is a surjective ring homomorphism with kernel , so is a field and is a maximal, hence prime, ideal by [F3]; therefore is a prime element, and the -adic order on nonzero polynomials, which records the largest power of dividing an element, is additive over products. Comparing orders in gives , which is impossible because does not divide . Hence no element of has th power , that is, .
The general theorem applies to this pair. The field has characteristic by step 1.1, and by step 1.2, so [F4] applies with and : the ring is a field, the structural map is injective, and ; the affine -scheme is of finite type over and regular; for every field extension and every with there is a -algebra isomorphism , where is a Noetherian local ring with unique prime , Krull dimension and embedding dimension , and is not regular; and consequently is not smooth, although is regular. The Axiom of Choice is used only here, through [F4], as declared in [F8].
Adjoining the th root: the base change at . By step 2.1 the element satisfies , so the witness clause of [F4] applies with and and gives the -algebra isomorphism ; this is the coordinate ring of the base change of along . The ring is a Noetherian local ring with unique prime and maximal ideal , Krull dimension , embedding dimension , and it is not regular; every element outside is a unit, so its localisation at is the ring itself, and by [F9] that localisation is the local ring of the unique point of . Hence that point is nonregular, although its image under is the regular point of .
The extension is purely inseparable. Every element of is a -linear combination with : each power with is reduced by . By [F7] the th power map of the field is additive and multiplicative, so , because for , and and for every . Hence every is a root of the nonzero polynomial over , so every element of is algebraic over by [F6] and is an algebraic extension; with from step 1.1 and for every , the definition [F5] shows that is purely inseparable.
Boundaries and conclusion. The argument includes , where is the dual-numbers ring over , local with Krull dimension and embedding dimension and not regular. The hypothesis is genuinely used: it holds in by step 1.2, but over the same element satisfies , and correspondingly over , so the base change acquires the class with ; this is why the regularity detected in is not stable. No reduction or Frobenius twist is applied: the isomorphism of step 3.1 is an isomorphism of the actual tensor product and retains the class . The scheme is nonempty, since is a field with , and has a single point of residue field ; the empty-scheme case is therefore absent, while has Krull dimension zero and embedding dimension zero because its local ring is the field . Its base change in step 3.1 still has dimension zero but has embedding dimension one, and the finite-type hypothesis of [F4] is met by construction. Perfectness of fails: exhibits the Frobenius of as nonsurjective by [F7]. Choice is declared in [F8] and is used only through [F4]; the example exhibits one field, one element and one base change, so no simultaneous selection occurs.
Source qualification
Stacks Project Example 33.12.7 (tag 038S), first example, takes and observes that is a regular variety over that is not geometrically reduced. The item above instantiates the pair's own general result Purely inseparable field algebras separate regularity from smoothness at and , and its only independent obligation is the hypothesis , proved in step 1.2 from reduced fractions in the UFD ; the corresponding claim for over is the one recorded by the Stacks example. All smoothness, regularity, base-change and dimension assertions are taken from the statement of Purely inseparable field algebras separate regularity from smoothness, which is proved in this library from its own suppliers; the purely inseparable clause is derived here from the definition Purely inseparable algebraic extensions. The dual-number case is the published computation of dual numbers not regular, which is not used as a supplier because its statement provenance is ai-generated.
Depends on
- For a field $F$, $F(t)=\operatorname{Frac}(F[t])$ is its rational function field; in particular $\mathbb R(t)=\operatorname{Frac}(\mathbb R[t])$
- Algebraic and transcendental elements and algebraic extensions
- The Axiom of Choice
- Purely inseparable algebraic extensions
- The characteristic of a ring: the least $n \ge 1$ with $n \cdot 1_R = 0$ when one exists, and $0$ otherwise
- Frobenius $x\mapsto x^p$ is an injective endomorphism in characteristic $p$, and an automorphism for finite fields
- For every field $F$, $F[x]$ is a unique factorisation domain
- $R/M$ is a field if and only if $M$ is a maximal ideal
- Purely inseparable field algebras separate regularity from smoothness
- The stalk of the affine structure sheaf at a prime is A_p
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
59 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- The Stacks Project, Varieties, Example 33.12.7 (tag 038S), first example (standard reference, not scraped)