How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The cusp retains a doubled tangent line
Example
Let be a field of characteristic not or , and let be the plane cubic defined by , with origin . Then:
- the tangent space at the origin is ;
- the multiplicity of the equation at the origin is ;
- the scheme-theoretic tangent cone is , the -axis doubled;
- its reduction is the line , whose -linear span inside is the one-dimensional subspace , so the reduced cone does not span the tangent space.
The degree-one part of the cone ideal is zero, while its radical is : a linear form lies in the radical of the cone ideal but not in the cone ideal itself. The nilpotent class of in is nonzero and is retained throughout; no reduction is performed in computing the tangent cone, and the reduction is computed separately.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A field of characteristic not or , the polynomial ring (Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in ), the polynomial , the principal ideal , the quotient ring , the plane cubic , and its origin .
The polynomial ring over a commutative ring as finitely supported coefficient sequences with convolution: is the ring of finitely supported coefficient functions with unique coefficients, written , and is the coefficient sequence with at index .
Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in : every polynomial in the iterated ring has a unique finite expansion , with each monomial having a total degree.
homogeneous polynomial and homogeneous ideal: a polynomial is homogeneous of degree when every occurring monomial has total degree , and is homogeneous in every degree.
Multiplicity of a hypersurface equation at a rational point: for with , writing as its homogeneous decomposition, the multiplicity is the least with , and it equals the -adic order of in the local ring at .
All initial forms define the tangent cone: for in , the canonical graded map is an isomorphism, so , and for a principal ideal one has .
The scheme-theoretic tangent cone at a point: for a locally Noetherian scheme and a point , the scheme-theoretic tangent cone is ; the full associated graded ring is used without quotienting by nilpotents, and the reduction of the cone is a closed subscheme that can differ from the cone.
Equation rows and coordinate columns in an affine Jacobian: for an ideal with a finite generating list and a point satisfying for all , the Jacobian matrix at has rows , with formal monomial derivatives whose integer coefficients are read in and using the actual scheme ideal.
The Jacobian kernel computes the tangent space: for any field, ideal , , rational point and any finite generating list of , the coordinate-velocity map gives a canonical -linear isomorphism .
Evaluation at a point has kernel (x_1-a_1, ..., x_n-a_n): for the evaluation map has kernel , which is a maximal ideal.
A ring homomorphism whose kernel contains a two-sided ideal factors uniquely through the quotient ring: a ring homomorphism whose kernel contains an ideal factors uniquely through the quotient ring.
Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings: ring maps correspond contravariantly to morphisms , so -algebra homomorphisms are the -rational points of .
The nilradical and reduced rings: the nilradical of a commutative ring is , consisting of the nilpotent elements, and is reduced exactly when its only nilpotent element is .
The reduction of a scheme: the reduction is the closed subscheme with the same underlying topological space and structure sheaf ; on it is .
A polynomial ring in finitely many indeterminates over an integral domain is an integral domain: if is an integral domain then is an integral domain for every , including .
Every field is a commutative ring with ; it is an integral domain, and it is a commutative division ring: every field is a commutative ring with and is an integral domain.
The ideal generated by a subset and principal ideals: is the intersection of all two-sided ideals containing , and denotes the principal ideal generated by .
Division by a monic polynomial over a commutative ring: for a monic and any there are unique with and or .
The binomial theorem over an arbitrary commutative ring: in a commutative ring, for every , the natural-number coefficients acting by repeated addition.
The radical of an ideal: the radical of an ideal is , and is radical when .
Verification
The polynomial has the unique monomial expansion by [F2], with homogeneous parts of degree and of degree by [F3], and it generates the principal ideal by [F16]; the quotient ring defines the closed subscheme of , and is a commutative polynomial ring by [F1].
The quotient ring is a free -module with basis : division by the monic polynomial by [F17] writes every uniquely as with and , so the classes of and form a -basis of and in holds exactly when .
The multiplicity of the equation at the origin is : the translated expansion is with and no part of degree or , so the least with is by [F4]; equivalently the -adic order of in the local ring of at the origin is .
The origin is a -rational point of : the evaluation map at has kernel , which is maximal by [F9]; since has no constant term, by [F16], so [F10] factors through a surjective -algebra homomorphism , and [F11] exhibits it as a -rational point of .
The scheme-theoretic tangent cone: lies in because it has no constant term, and , so [F5] applies with and gives with in the principal case; by [F6] this spectrum is the scheme-theoretic tangent cone, so , the closed subscheme of defined by .
The nilradical of is the principal ideal : for and , the binomial theorem [F18] gives in , because for ; if this is zero, then and by the uniqueness of the basis representation in step 1.2, and since is an integral domain by [F14] and [F15], forces ; hence every nilpotent element of lies in , while because , so by [F12].
The tangent space is two-dimensional: since is generated by the single equation , the Jacobian matrix of the list at is the matrix evaluated at , namely , by [F7]; its kernel is all of , so [F8] gives a canonical isomorphism , of dimension . The two entries and vanish at the origin in every characteristic, so the computation does not use the nonvanishing of or .
The degree-one part of the cone ideal is zero: every nonzero element of has the form with , and each of its monomials has -exponent at least , hence total degree at least ; so no nonzero linear form lies in , and for the degree-one space of [F2, F3].
The reduced cone is the -axis: by [F13] the reduction of is by [F12] and step 2.4; the preimage of under the quotient map is , because maps into exactly when with by the basis of step 1.2, that is exactly when ; hence and the reduced cone is the line , the -axis of ; under the coordinate-velocity identification of step 3.1 this line is the set , whose -linear span is the one-dimensional subspace , properly contained in ; the same preimage computation gives in by [F19], so lies in the radical of the cone ideal but not in the cone ideal, as step 3.2 records.
Conclusion: the tangent cone is the doubled line , nonreduced with and , its reduction is the -axis, and that line spans only a one-dimensional subspace of the two-dimensional tangent space ; the multiplicity of the equation at the origin is by step 2.1, so the origin is a multiple point of the plane cubic. The tangent cone therefore records the doubling that the tangent space does not see, while its reduction has directions along only one line. The full graded cone does determine the tangent space: its degree-one piece is by [F6], and here has the independent classes of by step 3.2, whose dual is . The computation retains nilpotents and performs no reduction of the cone or of the curve.
Boundary and scope dispositions: the curve and the cone are nonempty, since is a -rational point of by step 2.2 and the cone is a spectrum over ; the zero case appears in the Jacobian matrix of step 3.1, whose kernel is all of , in the zero degree-one part of step 3.2, and in the vanishing of step 2.4; there is one equation, one Jacobian row and one cone equation of degree two (step 1.1 and step 2.3); the degenerate nonreduced case is exactly the cone with nilpotent nonzero , retained and not removed by any reduction in step 2.3, its reduction being computed separately in step 4.1, and the multiplicity is by step 2.1; the endpoint in the exponent is the least interesting case itself, and the characteristic hypothesis comes from the source's standing assumption, no step using the invertibility of or , as noted in step 3.1; no Axiom of Choice or dependent choice is used, since the equation, the Jacobian, the initial form, the basis and the nilpotent computation are all exhibited explicitly; and no biconditional is asserted or used, the only two-sided claim being the computation of the nilradical in step 2.4, proved by two inclusions.
Source qualification
Milne, Algebraic Geometry v6.10, Example 4.3 (printed p. 82) records that the curve has the origin as its only singular point; the next example, Milne Example 4.12 on printed p. 84, states that at the origin of "the tangent cone is defined by , which is the -axis (doubled)". The Chapter 10 supplement, Definition 10.67 and Example 10.68 (printed p. 18), gives the scheme-theoretic tangent cone for a curve without square factors and lists with tangent cone , noting that the curve is integral while its cone is nonreduced. The item's equation is , and the sign leaves the defining ideal unchanged and multiplies both the Jacobian row and the leading form by , preserving the Jacobian kernel and the initial ideal. The source's examples assume characteristic or exclude and ; the computations here use only the vanishing of the gradient at the origin, the order-two leading form , and the nilpotent structure of , all of which hold in every characteristic, and the item states the characteristic exclusion only to preserve the scaffolded hypothesis. The tangent-cone identification is proved from the library's own supplier All initial forms define the tangent cone, and the reduction of the cone from the nilradical computation of step 2.4.
Depends on
- A polynomial ring in finitely many indeterminates over an integral domain is an integral domain
- The ideal generated by a subset and principal ideals
- homogeneous polynomial and homogeneous ideal
- Equation rows and coordinate columns in an affine Jacobian
- Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in $F[x_1,\dots,x_n]$
- Multiplicity of a hypersurface equation at a rational point
- The nilradical and reduced rings
- The polynomial ring over a commutative ring as finitely supported coefficient sequences with convolution
- The radical of an ideal
- The reduction of a scheme
- The scheme-theoretic tangent cone at a point
- Evaluation at a point has kernel (x_1-a_1, ..., x_n-a_n)
- Every field is a commutative ring with $1 \ne 0$; it is an integral domain, and it is a commutative division ring
- All initial forms define the tangent cone
- Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings
- The binomial theorem over an arbitrary commutative ring
- Division by a monic polynomial over a commutative ring
- A ring homomorphism whose kernel contains a two-sided ideal factors uniquely through the quotient ring
- The Jacobian kernel computes the tangent space
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
80 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry, v6.10, Example 4.3 (printed p. 82) and Example 4.12 (printed p. 84) (standard reference, not scraped)
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry Chapter 10 supplement, Definitions 10.67 and Example 10.68 (printed p. 18) (standard reference, not scraped)