How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A nondegenerate projective quadric
Example
Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let be an algebraically closed field with , let , put and let carry the reduced classical variety structure. Then:
- is nonempty and has pure dimension : every irreducible component of has dimension , and at every closed point of ;
- is smooth;
- at every closed point one has , and is not a singular point of .
In the chart the quadric is the affine hypersurface in the ratio coordinates; the hypothesis makes these equations nonconstant and squarefree. In characteristic two the form is a square, , the chart partials vanish identically, and the scheme is the nonreduced hyperplane rather than a smooth quadric.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC; an algebraically closed field with ; an integer ; the polynomial ; the projective algebraic set with its reduced classical variety structure; and the standard charts with their ratio coordinates.
The Axiom of Choice: "Every family of nonempty sets has a choice function."
projective space points: for , , where exactly when for some , and a class is written .
projective algebraic set: for homogeneous , .
homogeneous polynomial and homogeneous ideal: a polynomial is homogeneous of degree if each occurring monomial has total degree ; is homogeneous in every degree.
standard projective opens are affine spaces: "For every , normalization of the th coordinate identifies with ."
projective hypersurface affine pieces: "If , then is the affine hypersurface obtained by setting in , with the usual ratio-coordinate transition formulas."
Field: a field is a commutative structure in which every has a multiplicative inverse and ; the field operations are the ring operations.
The characteristic of a ring: the least with when one exists, and otherwise: the characteristic of a ring is the least positive with , and when no such exists; hence means .
An algebraically closed field: every nonconstant polynomial has a root in the field: " is algebraically closed when every nonconstant polynomial has a root in ."
Polynomial rings in finitely many commuting indeterminates by iteration: the iterated ring satisfies and .
Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in : "The degree in is the largest with ", computed from the unique finite expansion .
A polynomial ring in finitely many indeterminates over an integral domain is an integral domain: "If is an integral domain, then is an integral domain for every , including ."
Over an integral domain, degrees add under multiplication of nonzero polynomials: "If is an integral domain and are nonzero, then and ."
The units of over an integral domain are exactly the constant polynomials whose values are units of : "Let be an integral domain. A polynomial is a unit if and only if it is a constant polynomial whose constant value is a unit of ."
Every finite-variable polynomial ring over a field is a UFD, with prime irreducibles and principal height-one primes: "Then is a unique factorisation domain ... Every irreducible element of it is prime."
Irreducible and prime elements of an integral domain: a nonzero nonunit is "irreducible if every factorisation has or a unit".
The gradient test for a reduced hypersurface: "For every , the point is singular exactly when every formal first partial derivative of vanishes at " for reduced over algebraically closed with nonconstant and squarefree.
The gradient test for a reduced hypersurface: "The affine scheme uses the actual ideal , which is already radical for squarefree ."
is an integral domain if and only if is a prime ideal: " is an integral domain if and only if is a prime ideal."
Classical affine algebraic sets correspond to radical ideals, and irreducible sets to prime ideals: "Nonempty irreducible algebraic sets correspond precisely to proper prime ideals, and points to maximal ideals."
Affine and projective n-space have dimension n: "For every integer , ."
A nontrivial principal section has pure codimension one: "Let be irreducible affine and be a nonunit. Then is nonempty and every irreducible component has dimension , hence codimension one."
Global and local dimension of classical varieties: "Say that has pure dimension if every irreducible component has dimension "; is the chain dimension and is the maximum of over the irreducible components containing the closed point .
Nonempty opens preserve irreducible dimension: "If is a nonempty open of an irreducible classical variety , then ."
Irreducibility via nonempty open subsets, connectedness and open subspaces: if is irreducible and is a nonempty open subspace, then is irreducible; and is irreducible exactly when it is nonempty and every nonempty open subset of is dense in .
Classical varieties have finite irreducible decompositions: "Every classical variety is Noetherian and has finitely many irreducible components. Every open or closed subvariety has a finite affine cover."
Existence and basic properties of irreducible components: "every irreducible subset of is contained in an irreducible component of ; in particular every point of lies in an irreducible component, so is the union of its irreducible components"; also irreducible implies its closure is irreducible.
Local dimension for a reducible classical algebraic set: "If are the irreducible components of , then ."
The coordinate ring of an affine algebraic set: "Its coordinate ring is ."
The coordinate ring of a classical affine algebraic set: the coordinate ring of an affine algebraic set is reduced, and "The finite coordinate classes generate it as a -algebra".
Classical algebraic prevarieties, regular maps, and varieties: a classical algebraic prevariety over is a quasi-compact locally ringed space "covered by open subspaces isomorphic over k to these affine models", and its affine models are polynomial zero sets with coordinate-ring local data.
The local ring at a point of an affine variety is the localization at its maximal ideal: for a classical affine variety and , "there is a canonical isomorphism of local rings ".
The stalk of the affine structure sheaf at a prime is A_p: "For , there is a canonical isomorphism ."
Equation rows and coordinate columns in an affine Jacobian: "The Jacobian matrix at , with the equation-row convention, is the matrix "; formal derivatives are computed on monomials by the displayed rule and extended -linearly.
Jacobian rank detects regularity at closed points: for with a specified generating list and a maximal ideal , " if and only if is a regular local ring", where ; at a -rational point no perfectness hypothesis is needed.
regular noetherian ring: "A commutative Noetherian ring is regular if for every prime ideal , the local ring is regular local."
localisation and polynomial extension of regular rings: "Localizations and finite polynomial extensions of a commutative regular Noetherian ring are regular. Regularity can equivalently be tested at maximal ideals."
Regular points of locally Noetherian schemes: "Then the intrinsic tangent space is finite-dimensional over , and "
Regular equals smooth over a perfect field: for a perfect field and a finite-type -scheme , ""
Fields of characteristic zero, finite fields, and algebraically closed fields are perfect: "Every field of characteristic zero is perfect. Every finite field is perfect, and every algebraically closed field is perfect."
Locally finite type and finite type morphisms: "It is of finite type if it is locally of finite type and quasi-compact."
Regular and singular loci: for a reduced classical finite-type space over an algebraically closed field and a closed point , is regular exactly when , and the singular locus is the complement of the regular locus.
A field has only the zero ideal and itself, hence is Noetherian: "consequently every ideal of is finitely generated, and is a Noetherian ring".
Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring: "Let be a Noetherian commutative ring and let be a commutative -algebra of finite type. Then is a Noetherian ring."
Gluing affine schemes along compatible open isomorphisms: affine schemes with compatible open-overlap isomorphisms satisfying the cocycle condition glue to a scheme.
Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings: ring isomorphisms induce isomorphisms of affine schemes.
Verification
Set up the objects and charts. All monomials have total degree two, so is homogeneous of degree two [F4] and . By [F3] the set is the projective algebraic set of zeros of , and by [F5] the normalization of the th coordinate identifies with , so by [F6] the intersection is the affine hypersurface cut out by in the ratio coordinates; write and for its coordinate ring [F6, F29]. The charts for cover and hence [F2]. Since is a field [F7] with [F8], the element is nonzero, and by [F9] the nonconstant polynomial has a root ; then , so the class is a point of [F2, F3] and . Each has degree in every variable with [F10, F11], and holds in .
Squarefreeness of the chart equations. Each is of the shape with , , and all coefficients . Suppose some were not squarefree; since is a unique factorisation domain [F15], some irreducible element occurs in at least twice [F16], that is with . Fix a variable and view the ring as a one-variable polynomial ring in over the remaining variables [F10]; that coefficient ring is an integral domain [F12] and degrees in add on products [F13], so gives . For the left side is and for it is , so for every . If also for every , then is a nonzero constant, hence a unit [F14], contradicting irreducibility [F16]. Otherwise fix with : then and , so with and not involving , and comparing -coefficients in gives . Since in [F7, F8], , and the coefficient ring is a domain [F12], this forces , so ; as is irreducible and is a nonunit [F14], the cofactor is a unit [F16] and for a unit . Then is divisible by , hence vanishes after substituting ; but that substitution leaves , whose term for some (here is used) is a nonzero monomial, so the substituted polynomial is nonzero — a contradiction. Hence every is nonconstant and squarefree.
Radical chart ideals. Since is squarefree, [F18] says the ideal of is already radical, so the reduced classical chart has vanishing ideal and coordinate ring [F29], a reduced finitely generated -algebra [F30]. Moreover is a nonzero nonunit of : it is nonzero and nonconstant by step 2.1, and a unit would have to be a nonzero constant [F14]. [F14, F18, F29, F30, step 2.1, given, algebra] The associated scheme. To interpret the structure morphism in the Example, glue the reduced affine schemes as follows. Write on chart . On the overlap with chart , invert and identify and for . Substitution sends to , so it induces an isomorphism with inverse obtained by interchanging . The ratio formulas compose identically on triple overlaps. Thus [F45, F46] glue these affine schemes to a reduced finite-type -scheme : reducedness holds on each chart by the radical-ideal calculation above, and the cover has charts of finite-type algebras. Its closed-point charts and local rings are the classical and their local rings by [F20, F32, F33], and their identifications are precisely [F6]. This is the associated scheme of the stated reduced classical variety. In the scheme assertions below, denotes this ; every scheme point, including a nonclosed one, lies in some .
The chart hypersurfaces have dimension . The polynomial ring is an integral domain [F12], so its zero ideal is prime [F19] and the corresponding nonempty irreducible algebraic set is itself by the Nullstellensatz correspondence [F20]; by [F21], . The polynomial is a nonzero nonunit of by step 3.1, so [F22] applies with : the zero set is nonempty and every irreducible component of has dimension .
Pure dimension of the quadric. By [F26] every classical variety is Noetherian with finitely many irreducible components. Let be an irreducible component of . Since the charts cover [F2, F5], the intersection is nonempty for some , so is a nonempty open subset of the irreducible space ; by [F25], is irreducible and dense in , and by [F24] . The irreducible subset of is contained in an irreducible component of [F27], and step 4.1 gives , so . Conversely is irreducible and contains , so its closure in is irreducible [F27] and contains the dense subset of ; hence , and since is an irreducible component of while is irreducible and closed, . Therefore and , so for every irreducible component of . Thus has pure dimension [F23], and is nonempty because is nonempty by step 4.1 and contained in .
Jacobian rank and regularity of the chart local rings. Fix and a maximal ideal of ; by the classical correspondence [F20] the ideal is the evaluation ideal of a closed point of the chart with residue field , and by [F32] and [F33] the local ring of at agrees with the local ring of the chart, (using from step 3.1). By [F28] applied to the reduced chart and by step 5.1, , the maximum running over the components of through . The Jacobian matrix of the one-element generating list of the ideal of is the row with entries [F34]. If for every , then , and since in by step 1.1 this gives , impossible; hence some , and because in [F7, F8] the image of in is nonzero, so . Since is a -rational point, the Jacobian criterion [F35] applies without a perfectness hypothesis and shows that is a regular local ring. As was an arbitrary maximal ideal of , every maximal localization of is regular.
The quadric is regular and smooth over . Each is a finitely generated -algebra [F30], and is a field, hence a Noetherian ring [F43], so is a Noetherian ring [F44]. By step 6.1 every maximal localization of is regular, so by [F37] regularity of the Noetherian ring can be tested at maximal ideals: is regular, that is, every prime localization is a regular local ring [F36]. Every point of lies in a chart [F2, F5], and for the prime of corresponding to [F32, F33], so every local ring of is regular; the scheme charts constructed in step 3.1 form a finite cover by spectra of finitely generated -algebras, so is a finite-type morphism [F41]. The field is algebraically closed, hence perfect [F40], so the equivalence of [F39] applies to the finite-type -scheme : is regular if and only if is smooth. Therefore is smooth.
Tangent dimensions and absence of singular points. Let be a closed point of . By step 7.1 the local ring is regular; by [F38] this means , and by step 5.1 together with [F28] the right side is , the maximum of over the components of containing . Hence , so is a regular point of the reduced classical finite-type space and [F42]. Independently, step 6.1 exhibits a nonzero partial at the point, so the affine gradient test [F17] also makes the corresponding chart point nonsingular. Since every closed point is regular and every local ring of the scheme is regular by step 7.1, the quadric has no singular point in either sense.
Boundary and scope dispositions. Nonemptiness: by step 1.1 and each chart equation has a nonempty zero set by step 4.1, so the empty case has no instance. Zero cases: the origin of each chart is not on the quadric because ; this origin is exactly the point where all partials vanish, so the gradient of each chart equation vanishes only off the quadric, and the zero vector lies in every tangent space. One: each chart is cut by one equation, the Jacobian of the one-element generating list has one row, and the relative dimension of the quadric is . Degenerate case: the excluded characteristic two is genuinely degenerate, since there is a square, the partials of the chart equations vanish identically, and is the nonreduced hyperplane , whose reduced variety is a hyperplane rather than a quadric of dimension ; the hypothesis enters through [F7, F8] in steps 1.1, 2.1 and 6.1. Endpoints: the discrete parameter is , the ambient dimension is , the quadric and its tangent spaces have the extreme value , and the proof's squarefreeness step uses exactly at its final divisibility contradiction, so the stated range is the endpoint of the argument. Nonempty choice: AC is declared in [F1] and used only through the AC-assuming suppliers [F18], [F20], [F21], [F22], [F23], [F24], [F26], [F28], [F32], [F37], [F39] and [F42], each cited at the step that uses it; the degree-counting argument of step 2.1, the chart identifications of steps 1.1 and 3.1 and the Jacobian rank computation of step 6.1 make no choice. Biconditional directions: step 6.1 uses the direction rank implies regular of the Jacobian criterion [F35], step 7.1 uses the direction regular implies smooth of [F39], and step 8.1 uses the direction regular implies of [F38]; no reverse direction of these three equivalences is used anywhere, so the reverse cases are not applicable.
Source qualification
J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry v6.10, §4a (printed pp. 81–84) and
Exercise 6-1 (printed p. 159) state the classical nonsingularity test that a
point of a hypersurface is nonsingular exactly when not all formal partial
derivatives of its equation vanish, and that a plane projective curve is
nonsingular exactly when its three partial derivatives do not all vanish; the
item uses the affine form of that test through
cor-hypersurface-singular-locus-gradient and the Jacobian rank computation of
thm-jacobian-criterion-affine-variety. Donu Arapura, Notes on Basic
Algebraic Geometry, §5.2 (printed p. 35), defines a point of a variety as
nonsingular when and singular otherwise, and records that
and are nonsingular; the item's nonsingularity claim
is the corresponding statement for the quadric, obtained here from regularity
of the local rings rather than from a homogeneity argument. The scaffold's
source string "§4a gradient method; Arapura §5.2" is the origin of this
item; the proof given here sharpens it to the scheme-level statement that
is smooth, so it also cites
thm-regular-equals-smooth-over-perfect-field and the regularity machinery for
Noetherian rings. The hypothesis is retained from the scaffold: the
squarefreeness argument of step 2.1 uses two square terms, and for the
quadric would need the separate one-variable check on
; for the set is empty. The characteristic hypothesis
is genuinely used, in the two forms recorded in the
boundary step: it makes invertible and the quadratic form nondegenerate.
Depends on
- Affine and projective n-space have dimension n
- Fields of characteristic zero, finite fields, and algebraically closed fields are perfect
- Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring
- The gradient test for a reduced hypersurface
- A polynomial ring in finitely many indeterminates over an integral domain is an integral domain
- The units of $R[x]$ over an integral domain are exactly the constant polynomials whose values are units of $R$
- An algebraically closed field: every nonconstant polynomial has a root in the field
- The Axiom of Choice
- The coordinate ring of a classical affine algebraic set
- Classical algebraic prevarieties, regular maps, and varieties
- The coordinate ring of an affine algebraic set
- Global and local dimension of classical varieties
- Field
- homogeneous polynomial and homogeneous ideal
- Irreducible and prime elements of an integral domain
- Equation rows and coordinate columns in an affine Jacobian
- Locally finite type and finite type morphisms
- Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in $F[x_1,\dots,x_n]$
- Polynomial rings in finitely many commuting indeterminates by iteration
- projective algebraic set
- projective space points
- Regular points of locally Noetherian schemes
- regular noetherian ring
- The characteristic of a ring: the least $n \ge 1$ with $n \cdot 1_R = 0$ when one exists, and $0$ otherwise
- Regular and singular loci
- Classical varieties have finite irreducible decompositions
- Nonempty opens preserve irreducible dimension
- A field has only the zero ideal and itself, hence is Noetherian
- Every finite-variable polynomial ring over a field is a UFD, with prime irreducibles and principal height-one primes
- Irreducibility via nonempty open subsets, connectedness and open subspaces
- Existence and basic properties of irreducible components
- Local dimension for a reducible classical algebraic set
- projective hypersurface affine pieces
- standard projective opens are affine spaces
- Classical affine algebraic sets correspond to radical ideals, and irreducible sets to prime ideals
- Jacobian rank detects regularity at closed points
- The local ring at a point of an affine variety is the localization at its maximal ideal
- localisation and polynomial extension of regular rings
- Over an integral domain, degrees add under multiplication of nonzero polynomials
- A nontrivial principal section has pure codimension one
- $R/P$ is an integral domain if and only if $P$ is a prime ideal
- Regular equals smooth over a perfect field
- The stalk of the affine structure sheaf at a prime is A_p
- Gluing affine schemes along compatible open isomorphisms
- Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
177 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry, v6.10, §4a (nonsingularity via the partial derivatives), Exercise 6-1 (printed p. 159) (standard reference, not scraped)
- Donu Arapura, Notes on Basic Algebraic Geometry, §5.2 (nonsingularity, printed p. 35) (standard reference, not scraped)