How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Proj carries a scheme structure
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice, inherited from the affine-scheme construction and from prime existence in nonzero rings. Let be a commutative nonnegatively graded ring. Then there is a scheme , written as a scheme, together with open subscheme identifications for every homogeneous of positive degree, such that:
- The open subschemes , homogeneous, form an affine open cover of , and for each of them, in the sense that identifies the two structure sheaves.
- The identifications agree on overlaps: for homogeneous of degrees , writing and , the set is carried by onto and by onto , and the transition is the canonical isomorphism induced by the localisation isomorphisms .
- The underlying topological space of is with the topology of Points of Proj of a graded ring, compatibly over each , and the inclusion of systems is the standard-open basis of Standard opens of Proj.
- The scheme is unique up to a unique isomorphism compatible with all the identifications : any other scheme with these properties carries a unique isomorphism identifying the charts.
The empty cases are included: if then , and if is nilpotent then and .
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The Axiom of Choice; a commutative nonnegatively graded ring ; homogeneous elements of positive degrees ; the localisations , and the degree-zero rings .
The Axiom of Choice states that every family of nonempty sets has a choice function. (The Axiom of Choice)
is the set of homogeneous primes with , with closed sets ; for it is empty. (Points of Proj of a graded ring)
is open, , and the family of all , homogeneous, is a basis of the topology. (Standard opens of Proj)
The maps of Prime correspondence on a Proj chart give bijections and , and for homogeneous of degree the subset corresponds to the distinguished open ; if is nilpotent, and . (Prime correspondence on a Proj chart)
Affine schemes with open overlap subschemes and isomorphisms satisfying the identity and cocycle conditions glue to a scheme, uniquely up to unique isomorphism, and the given affine schemes become an open affine cover. (Gluing affine schemes along compatible open isomorphisms)
is a contravariant equivalence from commutative rings to affine schemes with quasi-inverse global sections; in particular and an isomorphism of rings induces an isomorphism of affine schemes. (Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings, The underlying space of an affine spectrum)
Assume AC. If is a nonzero commutative ring, then has a prime ideal: apply the criterion with and , where for all . (Separating an element from an ideal by a prime)
If is multiplicative and every maps to a unit under , there is a unique ring homomorphism compatible with the localisation map. (Universal property of localisation: maps that invert factor uniquely through , Principal localisation )
In a localisation, if and only if for some in the multiplicative subset. (Equality, vanishing, and the kernel of the localisation map)
Proof
The localisation map exists and is unique, because becomes a unit in (its inverse is ); it is graded, hence restricts to a ring homomorphism mapping to , and the element maps to , which is a unit there with inverse ; symmetrically is a unit with inverse .
The induced map of step 1.1 is surjective: an element of has the form with homogeneous of degree , and putting and , which is homogeneous of degree , the element lies in and .
The map of step 1.1 is injective: if , then multiplying by gives , so for one has in and hence in for some ; choosing with gives , so in , whence in the localisation.
The symmetric map , , is likewise an isomorphism, by the same two arguments with the roles of and exchanged, so the two isomorphisms are the canonical transition isomorphisms between the charts and required in clause (2) of the Statement.
The transition isomorphisms of step 3.1 satisfy the identity and cocycle conditions: for a triple every one of the pairwise transitions, transported to , is the canonical map of the localisation induced by , which is unique by [F7]; hence the composite around each triangle of charts is the identity on the triple overlap, and the transition of a pair with itself is the identity. By [F3] the overlap identifications fit the intersections and .
By step 4.1 the affine schemes , indexed by homogeneous , with the overlap isomorphisms of step 3.1 are gluing data satisfying the identity and cocycle conditions; the gluing theorem produces a scheme with an open affine cover by the images of the , identified with the charts, uniquely up to a unique chart-compatible isomorphism. For nilpotent the chart is by [F3], so the corresponding open subscheme is empty.
The underlying topological space of is : by [F3] each chart is in bijection with , and step 4.1 says the bijections agree on overlaps, so the chartwise bijections glue to a well-defined bijection . The bijection is a homeomorphism: distinguished opens form a basis inside each affine chart of , and each is a member of the family in [F3]. Indeed, for with , , which is the chart open corresponding to ; for , and corresponds to . Thus the chart opens form a basis for . On the same family is a basis by [F2], and the chart prime correspondences of [F3] match both bases. In the empty cases both sides are empty: if then by [F1] and every chart is ; if then each and by [F3] together with [F6], since a nonzero has a prime, contradicting the bijection with the empty set .
Sections: on the chart the identification exhibits the structure sheaf of as that of , so by [F5]; in particular the identifications are isomorphisms of locally ringed spaces respecting the structure sheaves, and clause (1) of the Statement holds.
Clauses (1)-(4) of the Statement are exactly steps 5.1 (existence, cover, uniqueness), 6.1 (sections), 4.1 (overlap agreement) and 5.2 (underlying space). The Axiom of Choice [A1] is inherited through the affine-scheme and prime-existence interfaces [F5, F6] and is used only in step 5.2, to know that a nonzero has a prime and hence a nonempty chart; the gluing and the transition isomorphisms are choice-free.
Depends on
- Prime correspondence on a Proj chart
- Gluing affine schemes along compatible open isomorphisms
- The Axiom of Choice
- Points of Proj of a graded ring
- Standard opens of Proj
- The underlying space of an affine spectrum
- Principal localisation $R_f=\{1,f,f^2,\ldots\}^{-1}R$
- Equality, vanishing, and the kernel of the localisation map
- Universal property of localisation: maps that invert $S$ factor uniquely through $S^{-1}R$
- Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings
- Separating an element from an ideal by a prime
Used by
- Global generation does not imply very ampleness Counterexample
- Associated sheaf of a graded module on Proj Definition
- Relative Proj of a graded quasi-coherent algebra Definition
- Affine-local graded algebras glue their Proj charts Lemma
- Proj is invariant under Veronese regrading Lemma
- Standard opens are affine Lemma
- Invertible twists for degree-one generated rings Theorem
- Projective space is Proj of a polynomial ring Theorem
Dependency tree · two levels
32 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- The Stacks Project, Constructions of Schemes, Section 27.8 (Tag 01M3) (standard reference, not scraped)
- Ravi Vakil, The Rising Sea, August 2022 draft, Section 4.5 (standard reference, not scraped)