How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Infinitely many modes admit inequivalent irreducible regular Weyl representations
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Countable Choice.
Let be the real vector space of finitely supported sequences , with ; this finite sum defines a nondegenerate alternating form. For , let be the incomplete tensor product of copies of with reference vector . The finite-support operators
where all but finitely many factors are the identity, define irreducible Weyl representations with phase that are strongly continuous on every real line. They are inequivalent: a common local Gaussian average has expectation in the first reference vector and limiting expectation in every unit vector of the second representation.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: Countable Choice; the finite-support symplectic space , the two Gaussian reference vectors, and the one-mode Schrödinger formula.
The one-mode operators form a strongly continuous irreducible Weyl system with phase (The Schrödinger Weyl system is regular and irreducible).
The incomplete tensor product is the completion of the increasing finite-coordinate spaces, and for any unit the local rank-one projection is well-defined and orthogonal (Incomplete tensor product of one-mode Hilbert spaces with a reference vector).
For , the Gaussian Weyl average equals the projection onto ; it commutes through bounded intertwiners, acts as on a tensor coordinate, and the orbit of is total in (The Gaussian Weyl average is a rank-one projection).
Under Countable Choice, finite linear combinations of box indicators are dense in for each finite (Finite linear combinations of box indicators are dense in for ).
Strongly continuous Hilbert-valued vector fields with integrable norm have Bochner integrals; their norm is bounded by the integral of the norm, and bounded linear maps commute with these integrals (Bochner integrability criterion, Bochner integral norm inequality, Bounded linear maps commute with Bochner integration).
Countable Choice is assumed (The Axiom of Countable Choice ()).
Proof
Given: The data in the Statement.
The sum defining is finite for ; each term is bilinear and alternating, so is bilinear and alternating. If , choose with and let be supported only at with . Then , proving nondegeneracy. For , rescaling [F5] gives . Hence [F2] constructs the Hilbert space and its unit reference vector .
If has support in , define on the finite-coordinate operator . Each factor is unitary by [F1], so the product is unitary. Appending reference factors in the embeddings of [F2] commutes with this operator, because all acted-on coordinates are among the first ; the operators therefore define a unitary on the dense compatible union and extend to . Its inverse is the operator for .
For each finite , the span of the vectors is dense in . By [F4], finite linear combinations of indicators of finite-measure boxes are dense. A box of zero measure has zero class; for a positive finite-measure box, . By [F3], each can be approximated in by finite linear combinations of the one-mode orbit vectors . Fubini gives , and the finite telescoping estimate shows that products of these approximants converge to . Expanding the finite tensor sums gives finite linear combinations of the stated product-orbit vectors, each the restriction of for a finitely supported by step 2.1. Hence their span is dense in . For , is spanned by .
At each of the finitely many coordinates in the union of the supports of and , [F1] gives . Multiplication of these finite equations gives ; outside that finite union every factor is the identity. For fixed finitely supported , choose containing its support. On each box indicator from , embed into with ; the orbit is then a finite tensor product of strongly continuous one-mode orbits, hence is continuous by the finite telescoping estimate. Linear combinations of box indicators are dense in each by [F4], and the operators have norm , so continuity extends to every vector in the compatible union. That union is dense in by [F2]; the same norm bound extends continuity to the completion.
Fix a coordinate and a parameter . The local family , where is supported only at coordinate , is a strongly continuous one-mode Weyl family on : this holds on finite-coordinate elementary tensors by [F1] and extends by density from box-step functions [F4] and the unitary norm bound. Thus for every vector the weighted vector field is Bochner integrable by [F6]. On a finite-coordinate elementary tensor, its normalized integral acts on coordinate by the one-mode average and leaves the other coordinates fixed; [F3] identifies with the projection onto . Therefore this coordinate average equals on the dense compatible union and, by boundedness, on . If a bounded map intertwines two such local families, [F6] lets pass through the vector-valued integral, so it intertwines the corresponding . In particular, any bounded operator commuting with all global commutes with by taking . The projections for distinct coordinates commute by their finite-coordinate formulas.
The orbit of under finite-support is total in . For each , step 3.1 gives density of its finite-coordinate product-orbit vectors in ; these are restrictions of the full finite-support orbit. Since the compatible union of the is dense by [F2], the full orbit span is dense.
The joint fixed space is exactly . Let . For in a finite-coordinate space and , satisfies . Since the finite-coordinate union is dense and are contractions, strongly on . Every vector fixed by all is fixed by every , hence by and lies in the reference line; conversely each fixes .
Let act on . For a vector embedded using reference and any , the th coordinate is , so the local rank-one formula gives . For arbitrary , approximate by such a finite-coordinate . Since , for every the difference between these expectations is at most , and the difference between the squared norm terms is bounded by the same quantity. Density therefore gives . Direct substitution and [F5] give , so the limit coefficient is .
Let be a nonzero closed subspace invariant under every . For , the vector field defining the local average in step 3.3 takes values in ; its Bochner integral also lies in , since the Bochner approximants are -valued and is closed. Thus every and every maps into . Choose . Totality in step 4.1 gives a finitely supported with . Then satisfies . By step 4.2, ; closedness and linearity of give . Its total Weyl orbit forces , proving irreducibility for each .
If a unitary intertwined the two global Weyl representations, it would intertwine their local coordinate families for every . By the Bochner-integral argument in step 3.3 with , it therefore intertwines the common averages on the two spaces. Since , the unit vector would satisfy for all and hence for every . Step 4.3 gives limit , a contradiction. Thus the two irreducible line-regular Weyl representations are inequivalent.
Boundary cases
- Every vector of has finite support; the proof of line regularity uses this finite-support hypothesis essentially.
- The example fixes the nonzero central parameter ; inequivalence arises from the two infinite tensor reference vectors, not from changing that parameter.
- The construction gives two representations and does not classify all infinite-dimensional Weyl representations.
Depends on
- The Schrödinger Weyl system is regular and irreducible
- Incomplete tensor product of one-mode Hilbert spaces with a reference vector
- The Gaussian Weyl average is a rank-one projection
- The Axiom of Countable Choice ($\mathrm{AC}_\omega$)
- Hilbert space
- Complex Haar L^p spaces and compactly supported functions
- Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product
- The Gaussian integral $\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}e^{-x^2}\,dx=\sqrt{\pi}$
- Finite linear combinations of box indicators are dense in $L^p(\mathbb{R}^n)$ for $1 \le p < \infty$
- Bochner integrability criterion
- Bochner integral norm inequality
- Bounded linear maps commute with Bochner integration
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
64 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- Roland Speicher, Mathematical Aspects of Quantum Mechanics, Lecture Notes (standard reference, not scraped)