Alphabeta Math
CounterexampleConstruction: Literature-sourcedVerification: AI-adaptedPipeline-generated
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

A normal singular surface: the quadric cone

Statement refuted

False claim: every normal classical variety over an algebraically closed field is regular, hence nonsingular.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: AC, an algebraically closed field k with char⁡k≠2, the polynomial f=xy−z2∈k[x,y,z], the closed set X=V(f)⊆Ak3, and its coordinate ring R=k[x,y,z]/(f)=k[X].

[F1]

k[x,y,z] is a unique factorisation domain in which every irreducible element is prime; f is primitive of positive degree in z over k[x,y], and xy is not a square in k(x,y) because the x-adic valuation of xy is odd, so f is irreducible in k(x,y)[z] and hence in k[x,y,z] by Gauss's lemma (Every finite-variable polynomial ring over a field is a UFD, with prime irreducibles and principal height-one primes, Gauss lemma over a UFD, For every field F, F[x] is a unique factorisation domain, Every irreducible polynomial over a field is prime).

[F2]

For an affine algebraic set the closed subsets correspond to radical ideals and the nonempty irreducible ones to prime ideals, with I(V(J))=J (Affine algebraic sets correspond to radical ideals, and irreducible ones to prime ideals, Strong Nullstellensatz: I(V(I)) equals the radical of I); points of a classical affine variety give its coordinate ring, a domain (A classical affine variety, The coordinate ring of an affine algebraic set).

[F3]

Jacobian criterion: for a reduced classical affine algebraic set over an algebraically closed field, a closed point is regular exactly when the Jacobian rank equals n−dim⁡Am, and at a closed point dim⁡Am=dim⁡xX (Jacobian rank detects regularity at closed points, Regular and singular loci). AC is used here.

[F4]

Serre's criterion: a Noetherian ring is normal if and only if it satisfies (R1) and (S2) (serre normality criterion, serre r k and s k conditions). AC is used here.

[F5]

A regular local ring is a Cohen--Macaulay domain, and a localisation of a regular local ring at a prime is regular (regular local rings are domains and cohen macaulay, localisations of regular local rings are regular); depth is the supremum of lengths of regular sequences (Depth with respect to an ideal).

[F6]

For a finite-type domain A over a field and a prime p, ht⁡(p)+dim⁡(A/p)=dim⁡A; a prime minimal over a principal ideal has height at most one; the polynomial ring in r variables over a field has dimension r and is Noetherian; and the geometric dimension of an affine variety equals the Krull dimension of its coordinate ring (Height plus quotient dimension equals ambient dimension in an affine domain, Krull's principal ideal theorem, A polynomial ring in n variables over a field has dimension n, Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring, Affine geometric dimension equals ring dimension).

[F7]

A Noetherian ring is normal when all its prime localisations are integrally closed domains, and a classical variety is normal when all its local rings are integrally closed domains (normal noetherian ring, Normal points and normal varieties).

Counterexample

1.1F1F2F3F6given

By [F1] the element f is prime, so R=k[x,y,z]/(f) is a domain and X=V(f) is an irreducible closed subset, hence a classical affine variety with coordinate ring R [F2]; R is Noetherian by [F6]. Since (f) is a nonzero principal prime, ht⁡(f)=1 [F6]; the height formula [F6] then gives dim⁡R=3−1=2 and, for every point x∈X, dim⁡xX=dim⁡X=2 [F6]. The Jacobian matrix of f is the row (y,x,−2z), so by [F3] a point x∈X is regular exactly when that row has rank 3−2=1, and singular exactly when y=x=z=0; as char⁡k≠2 this is the origin and nothing else. Hence every point x≠(0,0,0) of X is regular, and its local ring Rmx is a regular local ring.

1.2F5F6given

The sequence x,y is a regular sequence in R: x is a nonzerodivisor because R is a domain, and R/xR≅k[y,z]/(z2), in which y is again a nonzerodivisor. Hence depth⁡Rm0≥2=dim⁡Rm0, where m0=(x,y,z) is the maximal ideal of the origin [F5, F6].

2.1F2F5F6step 1.1

R satisfies condition (R1). Let p be a prime with ht⁡p≤1. If p=0 then Rp is a field, hence regular. If ht⁡p=1, the quotient R/p has dimension 2−1=1 by [F6], so the closed subvariety V(p)⊆X, whose coordinate ring is the domain R/p [F2], has dimension 1; a one-dimensional variety is not a single point, so V(p) contains a point x≠(0,0,0). The corresponding maximal ideal mx contains p, and Rmx is regular by step 1.1, so Rp=(Rmx)pRmx is regular by [F5]. Thus (R1) holds.

2.2F3step 1.1

The origin is singular. At the origin the Jacobian row (y,x,−2z) is the zero row, of rank 0, while 3−dim⁡m0Rm0=3−2=1; by the criterion [F3] the local ring Rm0 is not regular, so the origin is a singular point of X.

3.1F5step 1.1step 1.2step 2.1

R satisfies condition (S2). Let p be a prime. If p=m0, step 1.2 gives depth⁡Rp≥2=dim⁡Rp. If p≠m0 and ht⁡p≤1, then Rp is regular by step 2.1 and therefore Cohen--Macaulay, so depth⁡Rp=dim⁡Rp=min⁡{2,dim⁡Rp}. If ht⁡p=2 then p is maximal, hence p=mx for a point x≠(0,0,0), and Rp is regular by step 1.1, so again depth⁡Rp=2=min⁡{2,dim⁡Rp}. Thus every prime satisfies depth⁡Rp≥min⁡{2,dim⁡Rp}, that is, (S2) holds.

4.1F4F7step 2.2step 3.1∎

By steps 2.1 and 3.1 the ring R satisfies (R1) and (S2), so R is normal by Serre's criterion [F4]; consequently each prime localisation Rp, in particular each local ring Rmx at a point of X, is an integrally closed domain, and X is a normal variety [F7]. By step 2.2 the origin is a singular point. Therefore X=V(xy−z2) is a normal classical variety that is singular at the origin: normal does not imply nonsingular in dimension two, and the characteristic hypothesis char⁡k≠2 was used only to identify the singular locus with the origin.

Depends on

Used by

Nothing in the library uses this result yet.

Dependency tree · two levels

102 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources