Alphabeta Math
LemmaStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedprecheck passjudge pass (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

The tangent conic of a rational Gorenstein surface singularity

Statement

Assume AC and DC. Let A be a nonregular rational normal local surface domain in the permitted canonical-module setting, with ωA≅A. Then its point blowup is normal with trivial canonical module. Its exceptional conormal L has degree two and dim⁡κmn/mn+1=2n+1. For a minimal generating triple of m, the associated graded ring is κ[T1,T2,T3]/(q) for one nonzero quadratic q, so the exceptional fibre is its plane conic.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A nonregular rational normal local surface domain (A,m,κ) in the permitted canonical-module setting with ωA≅A, its ordinary point blowup f ⁣:X→Spec⁡A, exceptional divisor E and tautological ideal I=OX(1).

[F1]

def-axiom-of-choice. The Axiom of Choice (AC) is the following statement. > Every family of nonempty sets has a choice function > (def-choice-function). Written out: for every set F all of whose members are nonempty, there exists a function g with domain F satisfying g(S)∈S for all S∈F. (The Axiom of Choice)

[F2]

def-dependent-choice. Let X be a set and let R⊆X×X be a binary relation on X. Call R entire on X when for every x∈X there is y∈X with xRy. The Axiom of Dependent Choice, written DC, is the following statement. (The axiom of dependent choice: a relation in which every element is related to something admits an N-indexed chain)

[F3]

def-hilbert-function-and-hilbert-series. Let S=⨁n≥0Sn be a graded ring and M=⨁n∈ZMn a graded S-module. Assume each homogeneous piece Mn has finite length as an S0-module and that Mn=0 for all sufficiently negative n. The Hilbert function of M is (The Hilbert function and formal Hilbert series of a graded module with finite-length pieces)

[F4]

lem-rational-normal-surface-point-blowup-normal-and-fibre-cohomology. Assume AC and DC. For a rational permitted normal local surface domain (A,m,κ), its ordinary point blowup X is normal. Its exceptional fibre E is a projective pure CM curve, its tautological conormal line L=OE(1) is very ample, and H1(E,Ln)=0, H0(E,Ln)=mn/mn+1 for n≥0. (Normality and fibre cohomology of a rational surface point blowup)

[F5]

lem-rational-singular-point-blowup-canonical-pullback-surjective. Assume AC and DC. For a nonregular rational normal local surface domain in the permitted regular-base dualizing setting, let f:X→Spec⁡A be its ordinary point blowup, E its exceptional divisor and I=OX(1). Then H1(X,ωX⊗In)=0 for n≥0 and the canonical evaluation f∗ωA→ωX is surjective. (Canonical pullback is surjective after blowing up a rational singular point)

[F6]

lem-regular-base-surface-cartier-curve-canonical-adjunction. Assume AC and DC. For a normal projective surface modification X over a finite normal local domain A of a regular two-dimensional local ring R, let E be a Cartier closed fibre with residue field κ and conormal L=OX(−E)∣E. (Canonical adjunction for a Cartier fibre curve)

[F7]

cor-degree-additive-proper-curve. Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice). Let k be a field and let C be a proper k-scheme (def-proper-morphism) whose underlying topological space has dimension at most one (def-dimension-noetherian-topological-space). For all invertible OC-modules L and M (def-invertible-sheaf): 1. (Degree is additive on invertible sheaves over a proper curve)

[F8]

thm-serre-duality-for-coherent-sheaves-on-projective-cm-scheme. Assume AC. Let k be a field and let X be a projective, pure d-dimensional Cohen–Macaulay k-scheme. Let DX=ωX[d] be its normalized dualizing complex, and let tX:Hd(X,ωX)→k be its trace. (Serre duality for coherent sheaves on a projective Cohen–Macaulay scheme)

[F9]

thm-cohomology-projective-space-twisting-sheaves. Assume the Axiom of Choice (The Axiom of Choice). Let A be a commutative ring with 1 (def-commutative-ring), let n≥0, let d∈Z and let X=PAn≅Proj⁡A[x0,…,xn] be relative projective space (def-relative-projective-space-standard-charts, def-polynomial-ring-on-a-family-of-indeterminates), with twisting sheaf (Cohomology of O(d) on projective space)

Proof

1.1F5given

The canonical evaluation f∗ωA→ωX is surjective, and ωA≅A makes its source OX; since ωX is torsion-free of generic rank one, the surjection OX→ωX is an isomorphism, so the point blowup has trivial canonical module.

2.1F4F6step 1.1

The point-blowup helper gives that X is normal, that E is a projective pure Cohen--Macaulay curve with H0(E,OE)=κ and H1(E,OE)=0, and that L=I∣E is very ample with H1(E,Ln)=0 and H0(E,Ln)=mn/mn+1 for n≥0; Cartier adjunction, together with the trivial canonical module, gives ωE=ωX∣E⊗L−1=L−1.

3.1F4F8step 2.1

Since L is globally generated and nontrivial, let 0≠s∈H0(E,L−1) and choose a finite family of global sections generating L. If every product of one of these sections with s were zero, then on the open set where each generator is a frame it would force s=0; these opens cover E, a contradiction. Thus some t∈H0(E,L) has ts≠0. As H0(E,OE)=κ, this product is a unit, so the homomorphism L→sOE is surjective and hence an isomorphism, contradicting that the very ample line bundle L is nontrivial. Therefore H0(E,L−1)=0, while Serre duality gives H1(E,L−1)=H1(E,ωE)=H0(E,OE)∨ of dimension one.

4.1F7step 3.1

Therefore χ(E,L−1)=−1 and χ(E,OE)=1, so the degree satisfies deg⁡EL−1=χ(L−1)−χ(OE)=−2, and additivity of degree gives deg⁡EL=−deg⁡EL−1=2; tensor-power additivity then gives χ(E,Ln)=1+2n, hence dim⁡κmn/mn+1=2n+1 for every n≥0.

5.1F3step 4.1

In particular dim⁡κm/m2=3 and dim⁡κm2/m3=5; the natural surjection κ[T1,T2,T3]→gr⁡mA therefore has a nonzero quadratic q in its kernel, and because the degree-two part of the polynomial ring has dimension six and that of gr⁡mA has dimension five, the quadratic part of the kernel is spanned by q.

6.1F3step 5.1

Multiplication by a nonzero quadratic in the polynomial ring is injective, so the quotient κ[T1,T2,T3]/(q) has degree-n dimension (n+22)−(n2)=2n+1; the induced surjection onto gr⁡mA is thus a map of vector spaces of equal finite dimension in every degree, hence an isomorphism, so gr⁡mA≅κ[T1,T2,T3]/(q).

7.1F1F2F9step 6.1∎

Taking Proj identifies the exceptional fibre E with the plane conic {q=0}⊆Pκ2; the resolution 0→O(−2)→O→O{q=0}→0 together with the projective-space cohomology calculation reproduces the same Hilbert function 2n+1, confirming the identification, and the Axiom of Choice and the Axiom of Dependent Choice are inherited from the cited suppliers.

Remarks

  • Nonregularity gives deg⁡EL=2, which is what makes the tangent conic a genuine conic rather than a line.
  • The argument avoids applying smooth-curve Riemann--Roch to a possibly nonreduced exceptional curve.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

86 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources