Alphabeta Math
TheoremStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-generatedprecheck passaudited 2026-09-05
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Hasse-Minkowski theorem over Q

Statement

Let q be a nondegenerate quadratic form over Q. Then q is isotropic over Q if and only if it is isotropic over R and over Qp for every prime p.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: A nondegenerate quadratic form q over Q that is isotropic over every completion of Q.

[L2]

The local-global statement already holds in dimension 3 (Hasse-Minkowski for ternary forms over Q).

[L3]

Finitely many local square classes can be patched by one global rational number (Global approximation of finitely many square classes).

[L4]

In dimension at least 3, only finitely many finite places can fail local isotropy (Almost all local completions are isotropic in dimension at least three).

[L5]

A ternary diagonal form is locally isotropic exactly when the associated Hilbert symbol is 1 (Ternary isotropy via the Hilbert symbol).

[L6]

Over an odd prime place, the Hilbert symbol of two units is 1 (The odd-prime Hilbert symbol formula).

[L7]

Ternary isotropy at all but one place forces isotropy at the last place (One local place is determined by the others for ternary forms).

[L8]

Weak approximation lets one choose rational coordinates close to finitely many prescribed local ones (Weak approximation for rational places).

Proof

technique · direct
1.1

By [L1] and clearing denominators, write q=a1X12++anXn2 with every aiZ×. Dimension 1 is vacuous. In dimension 2, local isotropy says that a1a2 has even valuation at every finite prime and is positive at the real place, hence it is a rational square and q is rationally isotropic. Dimension 3 is [L2]. We proceed by induction on n4.

L1L2giveninduction
1.2

Suppose n=4. Write q=a1,a2a3,a4 and let S consist of and the primes dividing 2a1a2a3a4. At every vS, local isotropy gives a common value tv represented by the first binary form whose negative is represented by the second. If that value is 0, at least one of the two nondegenerate binary forms has a nontrivial zero and therefore represents every local element by the elementary parametrization used in Ternary isotropy via the Hilbert symbol; choose a nonzero value represented by the other binary form and use universality of the isotropic one to obtain a nonzero common value. Apply [L3] to obtain tQ× in the square class of tv at every vS, with even valuation outside S except possibly at one extra odd prime p0. If no exceptional prime occurs, choose any odd p0S as a harmless placeholder. Only finitely many of those even valuations are nonzero. Multiplying t by the global square (pS{p0}pvp(t)/2)2 preserves every local square class and makes vp(t)=0 for all pS{p0}.

L3constructalgebra
2.1

Put f1=a1,a2,t,f2=a3,a4,t. Both forms are isotropic at every place of S by the choice of the local square classes. If pS{p0}, then p is odd and all three coefficients of each form are units. Fact [L6], followed by [L5], makes both forms isotropic over Qp. Thus each is isotropic everywhere except possibly at p0, and [L7] supplies isotropy there too. Applying the ternary theorem [L2] makes both forms rationally isotropic. An isotropic vector of f1 with nonzero third coordinate scales to a representation of t by a1,a2; if that coordinate is zero, the binary form is itself isotropic and the same elementary parametrization represents t. Applying the identical argument to f2 gives rational identities t=a1x12+a2x22,t=a3x32+a4x42. Their sum is a nontrivial rational zero of q.

L2L5L6L7step 1.2algebra
2.2

Now suppose n5 and the result is known in smaller dimensions. Set q=a3,,an. By [L4], the set S of places where q is not isotropic is finite. If it is empty, induction applied to q already gives a rational zero of q. Otherwise, fix vS and choose a local zero of q. If its value tv:=a1xv2+a2yv2 is nonzero, retain it. If tv=0, anisotropy of q forces all the q-coordinates of this zero to vanish, so (xv,yv) is a nontrivial zero of the first binary form. Both coordinates are nonzero; put r:=xv/yv, so a2=a1r2. For any uQv, the choices X:=u+a12a1,Y:=ua12a1r satisfy a1X2+a2Y2=u, which is the elementary parametrization underlying [L5]. Choose any nonzero vector zv for q; anisotropy gives q(zv)0, and use the displayed formula with u=q(zv) to obtain new xv,yv. This gives a local zero of q for which tv=a1xv2+a2yv20, and q represents tv. Make this choice at every vS.

L4L5step 1.1inductionchoose
3.1

By [L8], choose rational x,y close enough to every (xv,yv) that t:=a1x2+a2y2 lies in tvQv×2 for all vS. Then tq is isotropic at every place in S because q represents t there, and it is isotropic outside S because q already is. This form has dimension n1, so induction gives a rational zero of it. Substituting t=a1x2+a2y2 turns that zero into a rational zero of q.

L8step 2.2inductiondischarge-induction
4.1

Conversely, a rational isotropic vector remains isotropic after embedding Q into any completion.

givenalgebra

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

27 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources