Alphabeta Math
TheoremStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedprecheck passaudited 2026-09-14
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Separable dual spaces have the Radon--Nikodym property

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice. If Y is a real or complex normed space and its continuous dual X=Y is norm separable, then the Banach space X has the Radon--Nikodym property.

Facts & Assumptions

[A1]

The Axiom of Choice holds (The Axiom of Choice).

[L1]

AC implies Countable Choice and the relative Hahn--Banach principle: the former follows from the preceding local choice lemma, while the latter is realized by the AC form of dominated Hahn--Banach (AC supplies the countable and dependent choices used in Banach integration, Hahn-Banach dominated extension theorem for real vector spaces).

[L2]

Under Countable Choice and relative Hahn--Banach, norm separability of Y implies norm separability of Y (Separable dual implies separable primal).

[L3]

RNP is the Bochner-density assertion for every absolutely continuous bounded-variation vector measure over a finite measure (Radon--Nikodym property), and the variation of such a vector measure is a finite positive measure (Bounded variation of a vector measure is a finite measure).

[L4]

On the finite measure spaces fixed in [L3], hence on sigma-finite reference spaces, AC gives integrable scalar densities for finite absolutely continuous signed and complex measures (A sigma-finite signed measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has a unique almost-everywhere density, A finite complex measure absolutely continuous with respect to a sigma-finite positive measure has an integrable complex density).

[L6]

Countable scalar suprema and pointwise limits preserve measurability (Sequential suprema, infima, limsup, liminf, and pointwise limits of measurable functions are measurable).

[L7]

A strongly measurable Banach-valued function is Bochner integrable when its norm is integrable (Bochner integrability criterion), and bounded linear maps commute with its integral (Bounded linear maps commute with Bochner integration).

Proof

technique · direct

Given: AC, a normed space Y, and a norm-separable dual X=Y.

1.1

Obtain the needed separability and choice interfaces. By [L1], AC supplies Countable Choice and proves every instance of the relative Hahn--Banach principle. Thus [L2] applies and makes Y norm separable. Adjoin zero to chosen countable dense subsets of Y and X so that [L8] enumerates both even in the zero-space case.

givenA1L1L2
1.2

Fix a vector measure and dominate it by one scalar density. Let (Ω,A,μ) be a finite measure space and let ν:AY have bounded variation with νμ. If μ(E)=0, every cell in a finite partition of E has zero ν-value, so ν(E)=0. Hence νμ. By [L3] it is a finite positive measure, and [L4] gives an integrable real density g with ν(E)=Egdμ. Positivity, tested on {g1/m}, permits replacing g on a null set so that g0 everywhere.

givenA1L3L4
2.1

Choose a countable linear test space and all its scalar densities. Let K0=Q in the real case and K0=Q+iQ in the complex case. The K0-linear span D of a countable dense subset of Y is countable and norm dense by [L8]. For dD define the finite signed or complex measure νd(E)=ν(E)(d). Its partition sums satisfy νd(E)dν(E), and νdμ. Apply [L4], using AC to choose simultaneously for all dD, measurable hdL1(μ) such that νd(E)=Ehddμ.

A1L4L8step 1.1step 1.2choose
3.1

Make the scalar representatives pointwise linear and bounded. Uniqueness of scalar densities says, for every a,bK0 and d,eD, that had+be=ahd+bhe almost everywhere. There are only countably many such relations. Moreover [L5] and the variation estimate in step 2.1 give

L3L5step 1.2step 2.1

Ehddμ=νd(E)dEgdμ.

Testing this inequality on {hd>dg+1/m} shows hddg almost everywhere, for every dD. The union of the exceptional sets for all relations, bounds, and d is null by countable additivity. Replace every hd by zero there. Off this one null set, the map dhd(ω) is K0-linear and bounded by g(ω)d.

4.1

Extend the pointwise functionals to Y. For every remaining ω, continuity and density of D extend dhd(ω) uniquely to a scalar-linear functional f(ω)Y with f(ω)g(ω). In the complex case, Q+iQ-linearity and continuity give full complex linearity. Set f=0 on the common null set. Then f(ω)(d)=hd(ω) for all dD off that set.

step 3.1construct
5.1

Prove strong measurability rather than merely coordinate measurability. Fix yY. Using an enumeration of D, for every integer m1 take the least indexed dmD with dmy<1/m. Step 3.1 gives hdm(ω)f(ω)(y) off the common null set, so [L6] makes every coordinate ωf(ω)(y) measurable. Let (uj)j1 enumerate a countable dense subset of the unit ball of Y obtained from D by rational rescaling. For each xX,

L6L8step 1.1step 3.1step 4.1construct

f(ω)x=supj1f(ω)(uj)x(uj),

so [L6] makes this distance measurable. Finally enumerate a norm-dense positively indexed sequence (xk)k1 in the separable space X. For each integer m1, assign to ω the least indexed nearest point among x1,,xm. The measurable distance functions make its finitely many tie-broken cells measurable, and density makes these simple functions converge in norm to f(ω). Thus f is strongly measurable.

6.1

Integrate the extension and identify the vector measure. The bound fg and [L7] make f Bochner integrable. For dD, boundedness of evaluation at d, commutation in [L7], and step 2.1 give

L7step 2.1step 4.1step 5.1

(Efdμ)(d)=Ef(ω)(d)dμ=Ehddμ=ν(E)(d).

Both Ef and ν(E) are continuous functionals on Y and agree on the norm-dense subspace D, so they agree on all of Y. Hence ν(E)=Efdμ for every measurable E.

7.1

Conclude RNP and close the degenerate cases. [A1, L3, step 1.1, step 6.1] The measure space and ν were arbitrary, so step 6.1 proves the RNP condition in [L3]. If Y={0}, every scalar measure and every density above is zero; if μ(Ω)=0 or ν=0, take g=f=0. A one-point dense set and a one-element rational span are covered by the same construction. AC is used for Hahn--Banach and Countable Choice in step 1.1, scalar RN and simultaneous representatives in steps 1.2--2.1, and the common countable family of a.e. relations; no stronger unstated choice is used.

A1L3step 1.1step 6.1

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

76 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources