How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
Uniform-field dielectric sphere: candidate solution and its class
The explicit uniform-field dielectric-sphere candidate of the quasistatic linear branch: the two harmonic potentials, their matching at r=a with sigma_f=0, the O(r^-2) decay of the difference from the applied uniform potential, uniqueness in the declared decay class, the uniform interior field C E0 e_z, the exterior dipole moment p=4 pi eps_out d e_z and the bound surface charge. Conditional on the declared constants and interface hypotheses; no dynamic polarisability, no material data and no empirical claim.
Example
Let the laboratory frame and units be those of Laboratory geometry: a restricted inertial chart, its spatial slices and fixed-time fields and Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values, with spatial coordinates , , and the applied field along . The potentials below are functions on the full ball and full exterior in ; their physical fields are restricted to the laboratory region, while (c)-(d) concern the full exterior. Fix a radius in metres with , so that the interface below lies in the laboratory region, a field magnitude in and constants (the interior and exterior permittivities of the elementary branch of Declared material-closure branches: linear nondispersive Ohmic response and the causal memory branch, the material being at rest in the laboratory frame), and put
Consider the time-independent potentials
with fields and inside, outside ( being of the class of The electric and magnetic fields as fixed-time spatial vector fields restricted to this time-independent configuration). The coefficient is dimensionless and has units , so both potentials carry volts. Write , for the outward unit normal, and . For a trace , its normal and tangential parts are and . Then:
(a) [Harmonicity] on and on in the classical sense of The Laplacian of a function and of a vector field, and the potentials and their first derivatives extend continuously to the closed sides of .
(b) [Interface conditions] With one-sided traces at , and on . Potential-trace equality implies tangential-electric continuity, and the weighted radial-derivative equality is equivalent to normal- continuity. Tangential-electric continuity alone determines the potential-trace difference only up to an additive constant; the displayed potentials have that constant fixed to zero. These electric matching identities hold independently of any magnetic completion. In addition, declare the static completion , , with any constant symmetric positive-definite permeability and the zero-conductivity branch , of Declared material-closure branches: linear nondispersive Ohmic response and the causal memory branch. The four fields then satisfy all four thin-interface macroscopic equations distributionally with , and the joint one-sided regularity at the compact sphere verifies the hypotheses of Stationary macroscopic interface jump conditions for D, B, E and H. Assume its inherited convention (The Axiom of Countable Choice ()) for this distribution/surface reading.
(c) [Asymptotics] and as : the difference from the applied uniform potential decays like and its gradient like .
(d) [Uniqueness in the declared class] Assume Countable Choice (The Axiom of Countable Choice ()), as required by the Green and harmonic derivative-estimate interfaces used in this branch. Let be on the closed ball respectively on every closed exterior region , harmonic on and , satisfying the same interface conditions (b), and satisfying for some and all sufficiently large . Then and . Hence the displayed pair is the unique solution of the dielectric-sphere transmission problem in that class, existence being exhibited explicitly; the uniqueness proof uses only the Green identity, the matching conditions and the decay, with no maximum principle.
(e) [Fields, polarisation and induced dipole] On the field is uniform, with ; outside, the field is the applied uniform field plus , where the dipole potential in a uniform background of permittivity is here defined as for . Its effective moment is in ; this field identification on asserts no point source inside the actual sphere; the interior polarisation is and the bound surface charge density on is , the singular coefficient of at (with the exterior polarisation ).
(f) [Regime and scope] The computation is a quasistatic result of the declared linear branch at ; using as a dynamic wave polarisability of the sphere requires a separate quasistatic/dipole approximation and is not asserted here. The example asserts no material data and no empirical claim.
Compactness of follows from its closedness and boundedness (Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line). Its smooth surface charts are obtained by solving near any point where ; such a coordinate exists because .
Verification
Given: The potentials, constants , interface and spatial data of the Example, with and the static completion of (b); assume for the distributional interface reading and for the uniqueness argument of (d).
[A1] The elementary branch: inside and outside with positive constants, with the declared static completion , , permeability constant symmetric positive definite, and (Declared material-closure branches: linear nondispersive Ohmic response and the causal memory branch, clause (b)); the macroscopic equation forms are those of The macroscopic Maxwell equations in terms of D, H and the free sources.
[L1] The calculus of the displayed potentials: for smooth functions and total derivatives, sums, scalar multiples and compositions obey the sum, product and chain rules (Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: , , , and when , The chain rule for total derivatives: ), the Euclidean radius powers are smooth away from the origin with the stated derivatives (Continuity and derivatives of positive-base real powers); mixed second partials commute for the smooth potentials (Clairaut--Schwarz theorem for continuous second partial derivatives), and the Laplacian is (The Laplacian of a function and of a vector field).
[L2] The first Green identity on a bounded domain: for functions up to the boundary, (First Green identity); harmonic functions obey the interior Cauchy estimates in supremum norm, so on compact subballs (Harmonic Cauchy estimates in supremum norm); and the classical Dirichlet problem on a ball has at most one solution (Uniqueness of classical Dirichlet and compatible Neumann solutions).
[L3] For a two-sided compact embedded interface with one-sided traces, and , under (Distributional divergence and curl across a stationary interface), the derivatives being distributional derivatives of the regular distributions of the fields.
[L4] The Euclidean inner and cross products of (The Euclidean inner product on , The cross product in ), and the jump and free/bound conventions of Polarization, magnetization, bound and free sources, and the fields D and H: , .
On the functions and are smooth and is smooth away from the origin; the sum and scalar rules of [L1] give and , with and ; hence , so on and on ; the interior potential is linear on the entire closed ball, including the origin, while the exterior expression and its gradient are smooth up to because on that closed exterior side.
Put for the fixed directional factor along a radial line. At : and , whose equality for every angle is the scalar equation ; the radial derivatives are and , whose equality after the weights is . Substituting the displayed and satisfies both equations (the determinant of the pair is ), so the two matching identities hold. By the chain rule along any smooth surface chart, equal traces have equal tangential derivatives and hence equal tangential electric fields; conversely, equality of those derivatives makes the trace difference constant along every piecewise smooth path on the sphere, whose points are joined by great-circle arcs, without fixing its value. The displayed trace computation fixes it to zero. The weighted radial identity is exactly normal- continuity because and . The asymptotics (c) follow from : and has squared norm because , hence norm at most .
For the declared static completion, [L3] gives and , with analogous formulas for and ; by step 1.1 the piecewise classical divergences and curls of and vanish (each side is a constant multiple of the gradient of a harmonic function, so and there, the latter by the mixed-partial commutation of [L1]), and by step 1.2 the normal jump and tangential jump vanish; since and with , all four distributional macroscopic equations hold on the local region and the hypotheses of Stationary macroscopic interface jump conditions for D, B, E and H ( a compact embedded hypersurface in because , locally integrable fields, off , joint one-sided extensions, stationary free sheet data) are verified.
For uniqueness, let on and on ; both are harmonic with regularity on the closed regions, their traces and weighted radial derivatives agree on by the shared interface conditions, and for all sufficiently large . Apply the first Green identity of [L2] with on the ball and with on the annulus : since the Laplacians vanish, and ; multiplying by and and adding, the two surface terms on cancel by and , while the term on is bounded by using [L2]'s Cauchy estimate on balls of radius centred at , which lie in the exterior for large and carry the bound , hence tends to . For each fixed , the nonnegative weighted energy on the ball and is at most that on the ball and for , and the latter is bounded by the absolute outer boundary term, which tends to zero. Thus every fixed bounded-region energy is zero; continuity and the positive weights imply that both gradients vanish, so is constant on the ball and is constant on ; the decay forces that constant to be , hence the common trace is , and then by the Dirichlet uniqueness of [L2] applied on the ball to and the zero function.
The fields follow by differentiation: with on ; outside, is the sum of the applied uniform potential and the potential of a dipole at the origin with moment , and direct differentiation of the defined dipole potential gives , so the exterior field has precisely that form; the interior polarisation is and the exterior polarisation is , so the bound surface charge density is the singular coefficient of at , namely in , by applying [L3] to the piecewise smooth with jump .
Steps 1.1-1.2 verify (a)-(c), step 2.1 verifies (b) and the distributional thin-interface reading, step 2.2 gives the uniqueness statement (d) with existence exhibited by the displayed pair, and step 2.3 gives the fields, polarisation, exterior dipole moment and bound surface charge of (e). The scope (f) holds: the computation is quasistatic, of the declared linear branch at , conditional on the stated constants and regularity; the identification of with a dynamic wave polarisability requires a separate quasistatic/dipole approximation, and no material data, empirical claim or general existence theorem is supplied beyond this explicit transmission solution.
Depends on
Uniqueness of classical Dirichlet and compatible Neumann solutions
First Green identity
Harmonic Cauchy estimates in supremum norm
The Axiom of Countable Choice ()
The cross product in
The electric and magnetic fields as fixed-time spatial vector fields
Laboratory geometry: a restricted inertial chart, its spatial slices and fixed-time fields
Polarization, magnetization, bound and free sources, and the fields D and H
Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values
The Euclidean inner product on
The Laplacian of a function and of a vector field
Declared material-closure branches: linear nondispersive Ohmic response and the causal memory branch
Stationary macroscopic interface jump conditions for D, B, E and H
Sums, scalar multiples, products and quotients: , , , and when
The chain rule for total derivatives:
Continuity and derivatives of positive-base real powers
Distributional divergence and curl across a stationary interface
The macroscopic Maxwell equations in terms of D, H and the free sources
Clairaut--Schwarz theorem for continuous second partial derivatives
Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line
Dependency tree · 2 levels
Sources
- R. Fitzpatrick, Electromagnetism (University of Texas at Austin course), node 71: Boundary value problems with dielectrics
- David J. Griffiths, Introduction to Electrodynamics, 3rd edition (Prentice Hall 1999, 596 pp.; full scanned text)
- David Tong, Electromagnetism, University of Cambridge Part II Mathematical Tripos lecture notes (2026 printing, 236 pp.)