How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A plane intersection with no common component is nonempty and zero-dimensional
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let be any field, let and let be nonzero homogeneous forms of positive degrees with no common nonconstant factor. Put , a standard graded -algebra with the images of the variables of degree one, and with its standard charts (Projective scheme of a homogeneous quotient and its standard affine charts). Then:
- ;
- each standard chart with is either empty or has Krull dimension (Krull dimension of a nonzero ring), and has no strict chain of nonempty irreducible closed subsets; in particular the chain dimension of the underlying space of is (Chain dimension and the empty-space convention);
- : the homogeneous coordinate ring of has ring dimension one and never ring dimension zero, and it is not Artinian.
The argument is valid over an arbitrary field and uses the Axiom of Choice only through the cited prime-existence, height-theorem, irreducible-closed-subset and Noetherian-spectrum suppliers.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A field , the polynomial ring with its standard grading, its maximal ideal , nonzero homogeneous of positive degrees with no common nonconstant factor, the quotient , and with standard charts , .
for a field and (A polynomial ring in n variables over a field has dimension n); the height of a prime is the dimension of the localization at it and the dimension of a nonzero ring is the supremum of the lengths of strict chains of primes (The height of a prime ideal, Krull dimension of a nonzero ring), so a strict chain of primes satisfies .
is an integral domain and each quotient of by a prime ideal is a domain: polynomial rings over a domain are domains and a proper ideal is prime exactly when its quotient is a domain (A polynomial ring over an integral domain is an integral domain, is an integral domain if and only if is a prime ideal).
Contraction along is an inclusion-preserving bijection from onto the primes of containing , and it restricts to a bijection on homogeneous primes; a proper homogeneous prime of contains no nonzero element of degree zero and hence lies in (Prime ideals of a quotient ring are exactly the prime ideals containing the ideal, homogeneous polynomial and homogeneous ideal).
If nonzero homogeneous plane forms of positive degrees have no common nonconstant factor, then no height-one prime of contains both of them (Coprime positive-degree plane forms form a regular sequence).
Assume AC. A prime minimal over an ideal generated by elements of a Noetherian ring has height at most (Krull's height theorem); over a Noetherian ring every proper ideal has a minimal prime over it (Minimal primes over a proper ideal exist).
has as points the homogeneous primes of with , its standard charts are the affine schemes and they cover (Projective scheme of a homogeneous quotient and its standard affine charts); for each the map is an inclusion-preserving bijection from the homogeneous primes of with onto the points of (Prime and local-ring correspondence on standard projective charts).
Assume AC. A nonempty Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime (A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point), irreducibility being the property that the space is nonempty and not the union of two proper closed subsets (Irreducible topological spaces and irreducible subsets in the subspace topology); the chain dimension of a Noetherian space is the supremum of the lengths of strict chains of nonempty irreducible closed subsets (Chain dimension and the empty-space convention).
The Axiom of Choice is assumed (The Axiom of Choice).
A field is Noetherian, since its only ideals are and the whole ring; if a commutative ring is Noetherian, then its polynomial ring in finitely many variables is Noetherian (If is Noetherian then is Noetherian for every ). Hence is Noetherian.
Assume AC. Each standard chart ring is a finite-type -algebra: it is generated by the two ratios for , since every degree-zero fraction has spanned by degree- monomials. Therefore each is Noetherian by Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring, and each chart is a Noetherian topological space by The spectrum of a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian topological space. The three standard charts are a finite open cover of (Projective scheme of a homogeneous quotient and its standard affine charts); a descending chain of closed subsets of stabilizes on each chart and then stabilizes on because the cover is finite. Thus is Noetherian, as required to apply the chain-dimension definition in [L7].
Proof
The ring has dimension by [L1], and is a strict chain of primes of : each displayed ideal is prime, since the successive quotients are , , and polynomial rings over a domain are domains by [L2]. Hence , while because chains of primes below are chains of primes of ; so , and every prime satisfies , that is, . Finally, every proper homogeneous prime of lies in by [L3].
Let be a prime with . Then because and , so by the chain of primes of the domain ; if , then is a height-one prime containing both and , contradicting [L4]. Hence every prime of containing has height at least two.
By [L3] the primes of correspond inclusion-preservingly to the primes of containing , and homogeneous primes to homogeneous primes; moreover the irrelevant ideal is . Hence for a prime with preimage one has if and only if ; since a proper homogeneous prime of satisfies by 1.1, this is equivalent to .
By [L9], is Noetherian. The ideal is proper because positive-degree homogeneous forms lie in . Let be a prime minimal over , which exists by [L5]. Then is homogeneous. Indeed, let be the ideal generated by all homogeneous elements of ; it is a homogeneous ideal with , since are homogeneous elements of . It is prime: for homogeneous with we have , so or , hence or ; an ideal generated by homogeneous elements with this property is prime, because for arbitrary with one inducts on , where is the largest degree of a homogeneous component: the components of top degree of and of multiply to the top-degree component , so or , and in the first case with gives or by induction, whence or , the other case being symmetric. Thus is a prime containing and contained in , so minimality forces and is homogeneous. By 1.2, , and by the Noetherian Krull height theorem in [L5] applied to the two generators we have , so ; since by 1.1, the inclusion of 1.1 is strict: .
Every standard chart ring is either zero or of Krull dimension . By [L6] the primes of correspond inclusion-preservingly to the homogeneous primes of avoiding , so it suffices to rule out a strict chain of homogeneous primes of with . By 2.1 such a chain lifts to homogeneous primes of containing and, since lies in neither , with . Then by 1.2; on the other hand is a proper homogeneous prime with , so by 1.1 and ; and by [L1]. Hence , a contradiction. Therefore admits no strict chain of two primes.
By 2.2 the prime is homogeneous with and , so by 2.1 its image is a homogeneous prime of with ; hence is a point of by [L6] and .
. For the lower bound, from 2.2 gives via 2.1 a strict chain of primes of , so and . For the upper bound, suppose is a strict chain of primes of ; by 2.1 it lifts to primes of all containing . By 2.2 we have , so there is a strict chain of length two of primes below ; adjoining gives a strict chain of length in , contradicting from 1.1. Hence , and in particular is not zero-dimensional: it is also not Artinian, because in an Artinian ring every prime is maximal (Every prime ideal of an Artinian ring is maximal), which would force .
By [L10], is Noetherian, so its chain dimension in [L7] is defined. has no strict chain of nonempty irreducible closed subsets. Suppose such a chain is given. Some standard chart meets , since the charts cover by [L6]; then the subsets of the affine chart are nonempty, closed in , and satisfy . A nonempty open subset of an irreducible space is irreducible and dense: if with closed in , then is a union of closed subsets, so irreducibility of forces one of the three to equal , and since while , this gives or ; and if the closure of in were a proper closed subset, then would be a union of two proper closed subsets. Applying this to the open subset of the irreducible space shows that is irreducible and dense in , hence that its closure in is ; thus , since would give . The are nonempty irreducible closed subsets of , so by [L7] their radical defining ideals are distinct primes and form a strict chain of two primes of , contradicting 3.1. Hence no such chain exists, and the chain dimension of is .
Claim 1 is 3.2, claim 2 is 3.1 together with 4.1, and claim 3 is 3.3. The hypotheses actually used are: nonzero homogeneous of positive degrees with no common nonconstant factor, over an arbitrary field ; the Axiom of Choice enters only through the minimal-prime and height-theorem suppliers of [L5] the irreducible-closed-subset characterisation of [L7], and the Noetherian-spectrum supplier of [L10], and it is the standing assumption [L8]. Noetherianity of the chart rings is used in [L10] to justify the topological dimension convention in 4.1. Finiteness of is not assumed, and the minimal prime chosen in 2.2 is proved homogeneous rather than chosen inside the homogeneous locus.
Depends on
- Projective scheme of a homogeneous quotient and its standard affine charts
- homogeneous polynomial and homogeneous ideal
- Prime and local-ring correspondence on standard projective charts
- Coprime positive-degree plane forms form a regular sequence
- A polynomial ring in n variables over a field has dimension n
- If $R$ is Noetherian then $R[x_1,\ldots,x_n]$ is Noetherian for every $n\in\mathbb N$
- Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring
- The spectrum of a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian topological space
- A polynomial ring over an integral domain is an integral domain
- $R/P$ is an integral domain if and only if $P$ is a prime ideal
- The height of a prime ideal
- Krull dimension of a nonzero ring
- Chain dimension and the empty-space convention
- Irreducible topological spaces and irreducible subsets in the subspace topology
- A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point
- Prime ideals of a quotient ring are exactly the prime ideals containing the ideal
- Krull's height theorem
- Minimal primes over a proper ideal exist
- Every prime ideal of an Artinian ring is maximal
- The Axiom of Choice
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
74 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry v6.10, Chapter 6 (projective schemes; dimension of projective intersections) (standard reference, not scraped)
- Andreas Gathmann, Algebraic Geometry class notes (2002), Section 6.1 (Bezout and complete intersections), pp. 92-95 (standard reference, not scraped)