How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
An irreducible curve can have arbitrarily large tangent dimension
Example
Let be a field, let , and assume the Axiom of Choice. Put the monomial curve spanned by the consecutive monomials of degrees . Then:
- is irreducible and , so is a curve;
- the ideal is maximal, the residue field at it is , so is a -rational point of , and the classes of form a -basis of ;
- consequently : for every there is an irreducible curve whose tangent space at a point has dimension ;
- there is no closed immersion of -schemes, and hence no such curve embeds in .
The tangent dimension is visible in the degree gap: contains no element of degree below and contains no element of degree below , so the degrees survive as independent tangent directions.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: A field , an integer , the polynomial ring and the polynomial ring on the finite variable family , the point , the subring , the scheme over , and the Axiom of Choice.
The polynomial ring over a commutative ring as finitely supported coefficient sequences with convolution: is the set of finitely supported coefficient functions with and , so and every polynomial has coefficients; iterating with the finitely many variables of the family gives .
Universal property of a polynomial ring on an arbitrary family of indeterminates: for commutative rings , a ring homomorphism and a family in , there is a unique ring homomorphism restricting to on and sending ; for a common field this is the unique -algebra map with prescribed values on the variables.
First isomorphism theorem for rings: : a ring homomorphism with kernel induces an isomorphism from the quotient ring to its image.
Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in : every polynomial in over a field has a unique finite monomial expansion, so two elements of are equal exactly when all coefficients agree; each monomial has a total degree.
A polynomial ring in finitely many indeterminates over an integral domain is an integral domain: a polynomial ring in finitely many variables over an integral domain is an integral domain; in particular is a domain and so is every subring of it.
Every field is a commutative ring with ; it is an integral domain, and it is a commutative division ring: every field is a commutative ring with and is an integral domain.
Integral elements over a commutative ring and algebraic integers: for a ring homomorphism , an element is integral over when it is a root of a monic polynomial in .
Integral elements over a nonzero base ring form a subring: for commutative rings with , the elements of integral over form a subring of .
Injective integral extensions preserve Krull dimension: assuming the Axiom of Choice, an injective integral extension of nonzero commutative rings satisfies .
A polynomial ring in n variables over a field has dimension n: for a field and , ; in particular .
A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point: assuming the Axiom of Choice, a nonempty Zariski-closed subset is irreducible if and only if its radical defining ideal is prime.
The intrinsic cotangent space: the intrinsic cotangent space is , a vector space over the residue field ; at a -rational point .
The intrinsic Zariski tangent space: the intrinsic tangent space is , and at a -rational point it is .
The space of linear maps with pointwise addition and scalar multiplication: the set of linear maps between -vector spaces is an -vector space under pointwise operations.
The dual family associated to a Hamel basis , defined by : for a basis of a vector space , the coordinate functional is defined by on basis elements and extended linearly using the unique finite basis expansion.
Basis of a vector space: a linearly independent spanning subset; and ordered basis: an injective finite list whose image is a basis: a basis is a linearly independent spanning subset; every element is a unique finite linear combination of basis elements.
Finite-dimensional vector space, and its dimension ; infinite-dimensional means having no finite basis: a vector space with a finite basis is -dimensional, and is that unique ; isomorphic vector spaces have equal dimension because the image of a basis under an isomorphism is a basis.
Schemes and morphisms over a base: a -scheme is a scheme with a morphism to , and a -morphism commutes with the structure maps; a -rational point is a section over .
Morphisms of schemes: scheme morphisms are the morphisms of locally ringed spaces, and they compose.
Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings: ring maps correspond contravariantly to morphisms , so -algebra homomorphisms are the -rational points of .
Evaluation at a point has kernel (x_1-a_1, ..., x_n-a_n): the evaluation map at has kernel , which is a maximal ideal.
Closed immersions of schemes: a morphism is a closed immersion when its underlying map is a homeomorphism onto a closed subset and the structure sheaf map is surjective.
Closed immersions of schemes: for a closed immersion , the structure-sheaf map is surjective. At , its stalk map is therefore a surjective local homomorphism. It maps the maximal ideal onto the maximal ideal, and hence induces a surjection on cotangent spaces at rational points; dualizing gives an injection on tangent spaces.
The Jacobian kernel computes the tangent space: for any field, , , a rational point and any finite generating list of , one has .
If and is a linear subspace of , then is finite-dimensional, , and if and only if : a linear subspace of a finite-dimensional vector space is finite-dimensional with .
The standard list with and for is an ordered basis of ; hence , and is the zero space with basis and dimension : the standard unit vectors form a basis of with elements, so .
The Axiom of Choice: every family of nonempty sets admits a choice function; the statement and the cited steps below are the only uses recorded.
Verification
The image of the unique -algebra map with given by [F2] is a subring of and a finite-type -algebra, and [F3] identifies with ; by [F5, F6] the ring is a domain, hence so is its subring , and is a -scheme by [F18].
The subring description: every element of is a -linear combination of products of the generators by [F2, F3], and every nonempty such product is with by [F1], so ; conversely and for every , by strong induction on ( is a generator for , and with for ); hence with the sum direct and coefficients unique by [F4].
Suppose for contradiction that is a closed immersion of -schemes, where by [F1, F18]. By [F22] and [F23], the induced map on local rings is surjective at every source point.
The origin and irreducibility: the constant-coefficient map is a surjective -algebra homomorphism whose kernel is by step 2.1, so [F3] gives , making maximal with residue field and exhibiting as the -rational point of under [F20]; since is a domain by step 1.1, the zero ideal is prime and [F11] applied to the nonempty closed subset shows that is irreducible.
The dimension is one: is integral over because it is a root of the monic polynomial by [F7], and the integral elements of over form a subring by [F8] containing and , hence containing ; thus is an injective integral extension of nonzero commutative rings and by [F9] and [F10], with the Axiom of Choice entering exactly through [F9].
The tangent directions: , because a product of two elements of is a -linear combination of monomials with and hence lies in that span, while conversely for every by step 2.1; therefore , and the classes for form a -basis of the cotangent space by [F12, F16, F4].
The points: by step 3.1 composes with to a -rational point of by [F18, F19]. Under the anti-equivalence [F20] the point corresponds to a -algebra map , that is, to a tuple with maximal ideal by [F2, F21].
The tangent dimension: is a -vector space by [F13, F14, F12], and for each the coordinate functional of [F15] is an element of it; every satisfies because both sides are -linear and agree on the basis of [F16], and forces by evaluation at ; hence is a -basis of with elements and by [F17].
The contradiction: by step 2.2 and [F23], the stalk map is a surjective local -homomorphism. It maps the maximal ideal onto , hence maps onto and induces a surjection . Dualizing over the common residue field yields an injection by [F12, F13]. Applying [F24] to the affine space with actual ideal gives ; thus [F25] and [F26] imply . But step 5.1 gives , a contradiction. Therefore no closed immersion exists.
Conclusion: for every the monomial curve is irreducible of dimension one (steps 3.1 and 3.2), its tangent space at the -rational origin has dimension exactly (step 5.1), and it admits no closed immersion into (step 6.1); the tangent dimension of an irreducible curve is therefore unbounded, completing the source's exercise with an irreducible witness.
Boundary and scope dispositions: is nonempty and irreducible with the -rational point by step 3.1, and is nonempty, so no boundary object is empty; the zero cases are the zero ideal of used in step 3.1 and the zero vector of each -vector space, and for as small as possible the ideal is nonzero and principal-generated by ; the minimal instance gives , , of dimension , with the closed-embedding obstruction against still delivered by step 6.1; the degenerate case of the construction is this same endpoint, where the subring is all of , the integral extension of step 3.2 is an isomorphism and no higher-degree gap survives, while for the degree gap between the least element of and the least element of is exactly the source of the independent directions in steps 4.1 and 5.1, its endpoint being ; every construction is canonical, the only choice-theoretic inputs being the explicitly declared suppliers [F9, F11] named in steps 3.1 and 3.2, while the tuple is determined by the rational point , and no other simultaneous or dependent choice occurs; and no biconditional is asserted as a claim, the only equivalences used being the anti-equivalence of [F20], the irreducibility criterion of [F11] applied in one direction and the defining sheaf-surjectivity of [F23] applied in one direction, so the iff axes are vacuous here.
Source qualification
The source is Milne, Algebraic Geometry v6.10, Exercise 4-5 (printed p. 99): "For each , show that there is a curve and a point on such that the tangent space to at has dimension (hence cannot be embedded in )." The book's solution (printed p. 223) takes to be the union of the coordinate axes in and adds: "Of course, if you want to be irreducible, then this is more difficult." This item supplies the irreducible witness , the monomial curve used in the standard solution of that harder variant, and proves the three claims directly from the library's suppliers: the tangent space is computed intrinsically as the dual of rather than through an embedded presentation, and the closed-embedding obstruction is obtained from the Jacobian kernel bound for the (hypothetical) affine quotient presentation. The source is cited for the exercise and its coordination of the two cases; the irreducibility argument, the degree-gap computation and the embedding obstruction are carried out here, and the Axiom of Choice is declared and traced to the three named suppliers in the boundary step.
Depends on
- A polynomial ring in n variables over a field has dimension n
- Injective integral extensions preserve Krull dimension
- Integral elements over a nonzero base ring form a subring
- A polynomial ring in finitely many indeterminates over an integral domain is an integral domain
- The Axiom of Choice
- Closed immersions of schemes
- Finite-dimensional vector space, and its dimension $\dim_F V$; infinite-dimensional means having no finite basis
- The dual family $(b^*)_{b\in B}$ associated to a Hamel basis $B$, defined by $b^*(c)=\delta_{bc}$
- Integral elements over a commutative ring and algebraic integers
- Basis of a vector space: a linearly independent spanning subset; and ordered basis: an injective finite list whose image is a basis
- Monomials, coefficients, degree in each variable and total degree in $F[x_1,\dots,x_n]$
- Morphisms of schemes
- The polynomial ring over a commutative ring as finitely supported coefficient sequences with convolution
- Schemes and morphisms over a base
- The space $\mathcal L(V,W)$ of linear maps with pointwise addition and scalar multiplication
- The intrinsic cotangent space
- The intrinsic Zariski tangent space
- Evaluation at a point has kernel (x_1-a_1, ..., x_n-a_n)
- Every field is a commutative ring with $1 \ne 0$; it is an integral domain, and it is a commutative division ring
- The standard list $e : n \to F^{n}$ with $e_i(i) = 1_F$ and $e_i(j) = 0_F$ for $j \ne i$ is an ordered basis of $F^{n}$; hence $\dim_F F^{n} = n$, and $F^{0}$ is the zero space with basis $\varnothing$ and dimension $0$
- Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings
- If $\dim_F V = n$ and $U$ is a linear subspace of $V$, then $U$ is finite-dimensional, $\dim_F U \le n$, and $\dim_F U = n$ if and only if $U = V$
- First isomorphism theorem for rings: $R/\ker f\cong\operatorname{im}f$
- A Zariski-closed subset is irreducible exactly when its radical defining ideal is prime, and then it has a unique generic point
- Universal property of a polynomial ring on an arbitrary family of indeterminates
- The Jacobian kernel computes the tangent space
Used by
Nothing in the library uses this result yet.
Dependency tree · two levels
125 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry, v6.10, Exercise 4-5 (printed p. 99) with its solution (printed p. 223) (standard reference, not scraped)