How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
The variety of complete flags of a finite-dimensional vector space is smooth projective
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice, inherited from the projective product and properness suppliers (The Axiom of Choice).
Let be an algebraically closed field and let be a finite-dimensional -vector space of dimension . The set of complete flags carries the structure of a smooth projective classical -variety: it is the closed subvariety of the product of Grassmannians cut out by the incidence conditions , embedded in a product of projective spaces by Plücker coordinates. The group acts transitively on , the stabilizer of a flag is a closed subgroup scheme of , and the stabilizer of a complete flag is solvable.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC, an algebraically closed field and a -vector space with .
For the Grassmannian is the parameter set of -dimensional subspaces; the Plücker map is well defined and injective with closed image, cut out by the quadratic Plücker relations, so is a projective classical -variety, smooth, irreducible of dimension , covered by the standard affine charts isomorphic to . (The Grassmannian of r-dimensional subspaces of a finite-dimensional vector space, Plucker coordinates and the Plucker map, The Plucker map is well defined and injective, The Plucker image is a closed projective algebraic set, Standard affine charts on the Grassmannian, The Grassmannian is smooth, irreducible, and has dimension r(n-r))
Nonempty projective varieties have a product, realized as a Segre image, and that product is a projective variety. (Products of nonempty projective varieties exist as projective varieties, Products of classical algebraic sets and their universal property)
Incidence is closed: for the set is a closed subvariety of the product. In a standard affine chart of in which is spanned by the rows of a matrix whose first columns form the identity, a complement of the chart locus is given by the vanishing of the Plücker coordinate, and is expressed by the linear equations saying that a spanning matrix of has zero entries in the coordinates complementary to ; these equations are polynomial in the chart coordinates of and glue over the charts of . (Milne, Proposition 7.30, printed p. 146. No local item isolates this incidence statement.)
A closed subvariety of a projective variety is projective, and a closed immersion is proper; a projective variety over is complete, i.e. proper over . (Closed immersions are proper, Finite-dimensional projective space is proper over every base, Products of nonempty projective varieties exist as projective varieties)
The upper triangular group scheme is a closed subgroup scheme of ; is a diagonalizable commutative group scheme and has a central series with successive quotients isomorphic to . (The central series of U_n with additive quotients, The upper unitriangular group scheme U_n and its coordinate ring, Rational representations and comodules of an affine group scheme, The general linear group scheme and its coordinate ring)
A group scheme with a normal series whose successive quotients are commutative is solvable, by the definition of the derived series; explicitly for the terms of any such series. (The derived subgroup, the derived series and solvable algebraic groups)
AC is the axiom of The Axiom of Choice, explicitly assumed for the specified projective and properness suppliers.
Proof
Given: AC, an algebraically closed field and a finite-dimensional -vector space of dimension .
For , the empty product is the one-point variety, there is a unique flag, and all incidence conditions are vacuous. For , by [F1] each is a projective variety, and by [F2] the product is a projective variety. By [F3] each incidence condition defines a closed subvariety, so their intersection is a closed subvariety; by [F4] it is projective, hence complete, and its Plücker embedding in the product of projective spaces is the restriction of the Plücker embeddings of the factors.
Fix a basis and its opposite coordinate flag . The locus of flags satisfying is open: projection of onto is invertible exactly when its leading Plücker coordinate is nonzero. Each such flag is uniquely , where are the columns of a lower unitriangular matrix. To construct , use the unique vector of projecting to in the first coordinates; it has the displayed form. Nesting shows the earlier belong to , and their distinct leading coordinates make them a basis. Uniqueness follows from that same projection. The coefficients are regular on the standard Grassmannian charts of [F1], obtained by matrix inversion with the nonzero leading minors as denominators. Conversely every lower unitriangular matrix yields such a flag, with polynomial Plücker coordinates. Thus these mutually inverse regular maps identify with . Every flag admits an adapted basis and is transverse to its reverse coordinate flag, so these affine-space charts cover the flag variety. These inversions and polynomial formulas also work over arbitrary -algebras when the leading minors are units, so the charts parameterize locally direct-summand flags after base change. They give smoothness; for the chart is .
I claim that the stabilizer of a complete flag is solvable. Fix the flag given by for a basis . For every -algebra , an -point stabilizes each if and only if its matrix is upper triangular, since the image of is spanned by the images of the first basis vectors; hence the stabilizer of is exactly the upper triangular closed subgroup scheme of [F5]. The series is a normal series whose successive quotients are, in order, (commutative, being diagonalizable) and the quotients of the central series of [F5], which are commutative. By [F6] a group scheme with such a series is solvable, so the stabilizer of the complete flag is solvable.
I claim that acts transitively on , compatibly with its action on the Grassmannians, and that the stabilizer of a flag is a closed subgroup scheme. Given two flags , , choose bases and adapted to them; the linear map lies in and carries onto for every . The action of on preserves the incidence conditions, so it restricts to a morphism , an action of the group scheme by [F5]; the scheme-theoretic stabilizer of a point is then a closed subgroup scheme of . Since acts transitively, the stabilizer of any complete flag is a -conjugate of the stabilizer of the standard flag, so by [step 1.3] the stabilizer of every complete flag is solvable. Moreover is the determinant-open integral subscheme of matrix affine space. The closure of its flag orbit is irreducible and contains every closed point by transitivity, hence is all of ; thus the flag variety is irreducible.
Collecting: [step 1.1] gives the projective closed-subvariety model of via incidence, [step 1.2] its smoothness, [step 2.1] the transitive action and closed stabilizer subgroups, and [step 1.3] the solvability of the stabilizer of a complete flag. This proves the statement.
Depends on
- The Axiom of Choice
- The central series of U_n with additive quotients
- The Grassmannian is smooth, irreducible, and has dimension r(n-r)
- Products of nonempty projective varieties exist as projective varieties
- Algebraic group actions, orbit maps, orbit subschemes and scheme-theoretic stabilizers
- The derived subgroup, the derived series and solvable algebraic groups
- The Grassmannian of r-dimensional subspaces of a finite-dimensional vector space
- Plucker coordinates and the Plucker map
- Products of classical algebraic sets and their universal property
- Projective bundle in the quotient convention
- Rational representations and comodules of an affine group scheme
- Closed immersions are proper
- The general linear group scheme and its coordinate ring
- Standard affine charts on the Grassmannian
- The Plucker map is well defined and injective
- Fixed-multidegree forms define maps from products to projective space
- The Plucker image is a closed projective algebraic set
- Finite-dimensional projective space is proper over every base
- The upper unitriangular group scheme U_n and its coordinate ring
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
92 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Groups (corrected 2022 printing, Cambridge University Press) (standard reference, not scraped)