Alphabeta Math
TheoremStatement: Literature-sourcedProof: AI-adaptedPipeline-generatedjudge pass (gpt-6.1-sol)
How statement and proof provenance work

The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.

  • Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
  • AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
  • AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.

These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.

Borel fixed point theorem for complete schemes

Statement

Assume the Axiom of Choice where the geometric orbit and dimension suppliers use it. Let k be a field, let G be a smooth connected solvable affine algebraic group over k (Affine schemes and their coordinate rings, Smooth morphism of schemes), and let X be a nonempty complete k-scheme of finite type (Complete varieties, Proper morphisms) with a rational action of G. Then there is a point x∈X(ka) fixed by G(ka). If k is algebraically closed, the fixed point lies in X(k).

Completeness and affineness are essential for this theorem: Ga acting by translation on A1 has no fixed point, while an elliptic curve acting on itself by translation is a smooth connected solvable nonaffine group acting on a complete scheme without a fixed point. Smoothness is used by the scheme-theoretic orbit proof below; no assertion that it is necessary for the stated geometric-point conclusion is made.

Facts & Assumptions

Given: The Axiom of Choice, a field k, a smooth connected solvable affine algebraic group G over k, and a nonempty complete finite-type k-scheme X with an action of G.

[F1]

Base change along k→ka preserves completeness, nonemptiness and finite type, and the action base changes; a fixed point over ka is exactly a point of X(ka) fixed by G(ka). Smoothness survives field extension; connectedness does so for group schemes by geometric connectedness, and solvability does so because the derived-subgroup construction commutes with field extension. Completeness here means properness, including for nonreduced X. (Milne A.75 and A.76, printed p. 587; Connected finite-type groups are geometrically connected, Properties of the derived subgroup of an algebraic group, Proper morphisms)

[F2]

If dim⁡G=0, then G=1: a smooth connected finite-type group scheme of dimension zero is a single reduced point. A nonempty finite-type scheme over an algebraically closed field has a k-point: take a nonempty affine chart Spec⁡B, choose a maximal ideal in its nonzero finitely generated algebra by AC, and apply the weak Nullstellensatz to its preimage under a polynomial-ring surjection onto B. (Smooth morphism of schemes, Connected finite-type groups are geometrically connected, In a nonzero commutative ring, every proper ideal is contained in a maximal ideal, Over an algebraically closed field, every maximal ideal is an evaluation ideal)

[F3]

Assume AC. If G is smooth, connected and solvable with G≠1, then DG is a smooth connected closed characteristic normal subgroup scheme with DG≠G, so dim⁡DG<dim⁡G. (Properties of the derived subgroup of an algebraic group)

[F4]

Assume AC. Let G be smooth over an algebraically closed field acting on a separated finite-type scheme X, let H⊆G be a smooth closed normal subgroup scheme and y∈X(k) fixed by H(k). Then the closure Z of the G-orbit of y is G-stable and fixed pointwise by H(k); and for every x∈Z(k) fixed by H(k), the stabilizer Gx contains H. (Fixed loci are closed and a normal subgroup fixing a point fixes the orbit closure)

[F5]

Assume AC. For a smooth group G acting on a separated finite-type scheme X, the orbit map G→G⋅x is faithfully flat, the orbit of a k-point of minimal dimension among the orbits in a G-stable closed subset is closed, and for an orbit of minimal dimension the orbit map exhibits the orbit as the coset space G/Gx, a separated finite-type scheme. (Smooth orbits are locally closed and their orbit maps are faithfully flat over every field, Fibre dimension and orbit dimension add to the dimension of the group, A faithfully flat orbit map represents the coset quotient sheaf, Homogeneous spaces of smooth affine groups are separated schemes)

[F6]

Assume AC. If N is a closed normal subgroup scheme of the affine group G, the quotient G/N is affine; if Gx is a closed subgroup containing DG, then Gx is normal in G. A reduced connected complete affine finite-type k-scheme over algebraically closed k is a single reduced point: properness makes its coordinate algebra finite-dimensional, reducedness makes it a product of finite field extensions of k, and connectedness leaves one factor, equal to k. The reducedness condition excludes infinitesimal counterexamples such as αp. (Quotients of affine group schemes by normal subgroup schemes are affine, Properties of the derived subgroup of an algebraic group, Morphisms from complete connected schemes to affine schemes are constant)

Proof

Given: The Axiom of Choice, a field k, a smooth connected solvable affine k-group G, and a nonempty complete finite-type k-scheme X with a G-action.

1.1F1

Base changing along k→ka preserves all hypotheses and produces a nonempty complete finite-type ka-scheme with an action of the smooth connected solvable group Gka, and a fixed point there is a point of X(ka) fixed by G(ka); for the second assertion we may therefore assume k algebraically closed, and it suffices to prove the first. We keep the given scheme structure on X; no reduction of the ambient action is required.

1.2F2

We argue by induction on d=dim⁡G. If d=0, then G=1 by [F2] and any k-point of the nonempty finite-type k-scheme X (which exists by [F2]) is fixed by G(k).

2.1F3F4step 1.1

Suppose d>0; then G≠1, and [F3] makes N=DG a smooth connected closed normal subgroup scheme with dim⁡N<d, solvable as a subgroup of the solvable group G. By the induction hypothesis applied to the action of N on X, there is a point y∈X(k) fixed by N(k). By [F4] the orbit closure Z, equipped with its reduced induced closed subscheme structure, is a nonempty G-stable closed subset of X, fixed pointwise by N(k); it is complete as a closed subscheme of the complete scheme X, and reduced by its chosen induced scheme structure.

3.1F4F5F6step 2.1

Among the G-orbits of k-points of the nonempty Z, choose one of minimal dimension and let x be a point of it; its orbit Ox is closed in Z and hence complete. The orbit lemma in [F5] applies on the reduced orbit closure Z: the smooth connected G is geometrically integral, hence its orbit closure is irreducible and reduced, a classical variety over algebraically closed k (Milne Appendix A.22(a)-(d), printed p. 574, the scheme/classical closed-point dictionary). By [F5] the orbit map G→Ox is faithfully flat and exhibits Ox≅G/Gx as the coset space, a separated finite-type scheme. Since x∈Z(k) is fixed by N(k), [F4] gives N=DG⊆Gx; by [F6] the subgroup Gx is then normal in G, so G/Gx is an affine group scheme by [F6], connected (as a quotient of the connected group G), and complete because it is isomorphic to Ox.

4.1F6step 3.1∎

The orbit Ox has its reduced orbit structure from [F5], so its isomorphic quotient G/Gx is reduced. Applying the reduced connected complete affine assertion of [F6] makes this quotient the reduced point Spec⁡k. Its scheme kernel is therefore all of G, so Gx=G; hence x is fixed by G(k). This completes the induction, and with [step 1.1] it proves both assertions of the statement.

Depends on

Used by

Dependency tree · two levels

117 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.

Sources