How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A transverse hyperplane slice is smooth at the chosen point
Statement
Assume the Axiom of Choice. Let be an algebraically closed field, let , and let be a classical variety over , embedded as a closed subvariety and carrying its reduced finite-type -scheme structure. Suppose that is smooth at the classical closed point (Smooth morphisms via local standard smooth presentations) and put , assumed to satisfy . Let be an affine-linear polynomial whose linear part is nonzero and which satisfies , and let be the closed subscheme of cut out by the principal ideal --- the fibre of over the origin , that is, the affine hyperplane through . Assume that is nonzero on : under the identification obtained from Tangent vectors at rational points are dual-number points and Universal property of a polynomial ring on an arbitrary family of indeterminates, the composite is not the zero map, where is the inclusion. Then the restricted morphism is smooth at ; the scheme-theoretic intersection is canonically the scheme-theoretic fibre of over , its structure morphism is smooth at , and is a regular local ring of dimension ; and the kernel of the composite displayed above (so that, under that identification, is the subspace of ).
Facts & Assumptions
Given: AC; an algebraically closed field ; ; a classical variety with closed point at which is smooth; ; the affine-linear polynomial with nonzero linear part and ; the closed subscheme ; and the transversality assumption that the composite induced by is not the zero map.
The Axiom of Choice: every family of nonempty sets has a choice function.
Classical algebraic prevarieties, regular maps, and varieties: a classical algebraic variety over an algebraically closed field is a separated classical prevariety; varieties may be reducible or empty, their affine models are polynomial zero sets whose points have residue field canonically , and these definitions use no Axiom of Choice.
The coordinate ring of a classical affine algebraic set: for an affine algebraic set the coordinate ring is ; it is reduced, and the finite coordinate classes generate it as a -algebra.
Global and local dimension of classical varieties: for a classical variety with irreducible components and a closed point one has , where is the chain dimension.
Local dimension for a reducible classical algebraic set: under AC, for a reduced classical finite-type space over an algebraically closed field and a closed point one has .
Smooth morphisms via local standard smooth presentations: a morphism of finite-type -schemes is smooth when every source point has affine neighbourhoods on which the induced ring map is standard smooth at the prime for that point; the condition is local on source and target, and the definition assumes AC.
Standard smooth presentations and locally standard smooth maps: a standard smooth presentation of an -algebra is an isomorphism with an invertible Jacobian minor; the case is exactly a localisation of a polynomial ring, and standard smoothness at a prime holds after a principal shrinking.
Fibres of standard smooth algebras are regular of relative dimension: under AC, if is standard smooth over the commutative ring , then for every prime of and every field extension of its residue field, every local ring of the corresponding base-changed fibre is a regular local ring.
The stalk of the affine structure sheaf at a prime is A_p: for , the affine structure-sheaf stalk is canonically .
Regular points of locally Noetherian schemes: for a point of a locally Noetherian scheme, is regular exactly when is a regular local ring, and then the intrinsic tangent space is finite-dimensional over with .
The affine scheme of dual numbers and Tangent vectors at rational points are dual-number points: is the dual-numbers scheme, and for a -scheme with the intrinsic tangent space is naturally isomorphic, as a -vector space, to the fibre over of ; equivalently .
Universal property of a polynomial ring on an arbitrary family of indeterminates: a -algebra map from to a commutative -algebra is uniquely determined by arbitrary images of its variables.
Differentials, open restriction, and the chain rule: the differential is the dual of the induced cotangent map, it agrees with post-composition by on based dual-number points, it satisfies the chain rule, and it is an isomorphism for isomorphisms of -schemes; no choice is used.
Scheme-theoretic fibre: for a morphism and a point , the scheme-theoretic fibre is .
Intersections of subschemes: the scheme-theoretic intersection of finitely many closed subschemes of a scheme is their iterated fibre product over it, cut out by the sum of their ideal sheaves.
Fibre product of schemes and Existence of all scheme fibre products: a fibre product of is a scheme with projections , such that and, for every test scheme and morphisms , with , there is exactly one with and ; every such diagram of schemes has a fibre product.
Affine fibre products are spectra of tensor products: the fibre product of affine schemes over an affine base is , with projections corresponding to and .
naturally: for a commutative ring , an ideal and an -module there is a natural isomorphism , ; it is -linear, for it is the tensor-unit isomorphism, and for both sides are zero.
Base change and composition of standard smooth presentations: base change of a standard smooth presentation along an arbitrary ring map is standard smooth with the same parameters, so locally standard smooth maps are stable under base change of the base ring.
Submersion criterion for locally standard smooth morphisms: under AC, let be -schemes locally standard smooth over at -rational points and , and let be of finite type; then is locally standard smooth at if and only if the induced map is injective; if so, and , , then the local ring of the scheme-theoretic fibre at is a regular local ring of dimension .
embedding dimension and regular local ring: for a nonzero commutative Noetherian local ring one has , and is regular local exactly when .
Locally finite type and finite type morphisms and Subalgebra generated by a subset, algebras of finite type, and module-finite algebras: a morphism is of finite type when it is locally of finite type and quasi-compact, and an -algebra is of finite type over when it is generated as an -algebra by finitely many elements, equivalently a quotient of a polynomial ring in finitely many variables.
Classical varieties have finite irreducible decompositions: every classical variety is Noetherian with finitely many irreducible components, and every open or closed subvariety has a finite affine cover.
The affine line has coordinate ring by The coordinate ring of a classical affine algebraic set, and its local ring at a closed point is with residue field by The classical affine local ring is localization at the point's maximal ideal.
Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings: for commutative unital rings the assignment gives a natural bijection , a contravariant equivalence on affine schemes.
Finite type is affine-local on source and target: being locally of finite type is affine-local on source and target, and a quasi-compact morphism locally of finite type is of finite type; equivalently, over each affine target open this may be tested on a finite affine source cover.
Affine and projective n-space have dimension n: for every integer , .
Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring: a commutative algebra of finite type over a Noetherian commutative ring is a Noetherian ring.
Locally Noetherian and Noetherian schemes: a scheme is locally Noetherian if it has an affine open cover by spectra of Noetherian rings.
Proof
Setup. The closed subvariety is an affine model with its reduced finite-type structure and function sheaf [F2], and its coordinate ring is reduced and generated as a -algebra by the finitely many classes [F3]. Its points have residue field [F2], so is a -rational point. The variety is Noetherian with finitely many irreducible components [F23], and [F5] with [F4] gives the maximum being over the components containing , a nonempty finite family. Smoothness of at means that the structure morphism is locally standard smooth at [F6]; fix an affine chart containing on which is standard smooth [F7], and write for the prime of in , so that [F9]. The subscheme is cut out by the principal ideal , and its defining equation vanishes at : .
The differential of . Write . Every is represented by a based dual-number point at [F11]. Its composite corresponds to a -algebra map [F25]. By [F12] this map is uniquely determined by the images of the . Since reduction modulo gives the point , these images have the unique form for . Conversely every gives such a based point by [F12], and the -linear dual-number correspondence [F11] identifies with in these coordinates. Call the image of under . By [F13] the differential is represented by the composite , and substituting in the affine-linear form gives because and is -linear. Hence , that is, and ; the transversality hypothesis is therefore exactly the condition . Taking in the same calculation gives , which is one-dimensional, and is finite-dimensional [F10]. Thus a nonzero is surjective, and by [F13] the induced cotangent map is its dual, hence injective.
The morphism is of finite type. The affine model has coordinate ring , generated as a -algebra by the finitely many classes [F3], and the affine line has coordinate ring [F24]; by [F25] the -morphism from the affine chart to corresponds to the -algebra map sending to the class of , the pullback of the coordinate function. This ring map is of finite type: the same finite family generates over [F3], hence over [F22]. By [F26] finiteness of type may be tested over each affine target open on a finite affine source cover; the target is affine and the single chart is such a cover, so is of finite type.
Regularity of at and of the affine line at the origin. The coordinate ring of the chart of step 1.1 is a finitely generated -algebra [F3], hence a Noetherian ring by [F28] because is a field and therefore Noetherian; so is locally Noetherian [F29]. Applying clause 1 of [F8] to the standard smooth presentation of step 1.1 with , and shows that every local ring of that chart, in particular , is a regular local ring; by [F10] therefore , so because . The affine line has coordinate ring and local ring at the origin with residue field [F24], and is standard smooth with one variable and no equation [F7]; hence is locally standard smooth at [F6] and is a regular local ring [F8]. The affine line is irreducible with [F27], so [F5] with [F4] gives . [F3, F4, F5, F6, F7, F8, F10, F24, F27, F28, F29, step 1.1, given, algebra] 2.2 The slice is the fibre. First, is the fibre of over the origin: the fibre product of and the point is with the projections of [F17], and [F18] identifies , where is a -algebra through , the ideal is generated by for and , and the isomorphism is one of -algebras; hence is this fibre, with projections and satisfying [F16]. Second, is the scheme-theoretic intersection of the closed subschemes and of affine space, with projections , satisfying [F15]. Third, the fibre of over has projections , satisfying [F14]. All three fibre products exist, and a morphism into any of them is determined by its projections [F16]. The morphisms and have equal composites to , namely , so the universal property of gives a unique with and ; since , the pair induces a unique with and . Conversely the morphisms and have equal composites to , namely , so the universal property of gives a unique with and . By the uniqueness clauses and : both composites induce the same projections, and a morphism into is determined by its composites with and . Hence is a canonical isomorphism over and over . The -point satisfies because , so it induces a -point of , carried by to a -point of mapping to ; this is the point at which all local statements are taken. Finally the tangent space. A -morphism is by the universal property a pair with and such that [F16]; the morphism is unique, and being based at means that is based at and is the structure morphism. Hence based dual-number points of at correspond bijectively to based dual-number points of at whose composite is the constant point at . Under the identifications of [F11] this correspondence is -linear and identifies with : by [F13], is represented by , and the constant point at represents the zero vector of [F12]. Since is an isomorphism, its differential at is an isomorphism [F13], so
The submersion criterion. Take and : the point has residue field [F24], and both and are -rational [step 1.1]. The schemes and are locally standard smooth over at and [step 1.1, step 2.1], the morphism is of finite type [step 1.3], and the cotangent map of [F20] is injective by [step 1.2]. Clause 1 of [F20] therefore makes locally standard smooth at , that is, smooth at in the sense of [F6]. [F6, F20, F24, step 1.1, step 2.1, step 1.2, step 1.3, given, algebra] 4.1 Dimension of the slice. By step 3.1, clause 2 of [F20] applies at with , , [step 1.1] and [step 2.1]; it makes the local ring of the fibre at a regular local ring of dimension . By step 2.2, , so is a regular local ring of dimension in the sense of [F21]. Consistently, rank-nullity for the surjective differential [step 1.2] gives [step 2.1], and by step 2.2, so the tangent dimension of the slice agrees with the local dimension. [F20, F21, step 2.1, step 1.2, step 3.1, step 2.2, given, algebra] 5.1 Smoothness of the slice and conclusion. Since is smooth at [step 3.1] and is the base change of along the point [step 2.2], clause 1 of [F19] makes locally standard smooth at , so the slice is smooth at [F6]. Together with steps 3.1, 2.2 and 4.1 this proves the assertions of the statement, including and its description as the set of with . Boundaries. The hypothesis guards against vacuity: if then [step 2.1], so carries no nonzero linear functional and the transversality hypothesis fails. For the conclusion gives [step 4.1], so the slice is isolated at in the local sense. The ambient endpoint forces , hence and the same zero-dimensional conclusion. For the inclusion is the identity, the slice is the hyperplane itself (the projection is an isomorphism by the universal property [F16] applied to ), the transversality condition is exactly , and step 2.2 gives . No characteristic hypothesis is used: the argument never divides by an integer, so all characteristics are covered. The variety may be reducible, and nothing is asserted in the nontransverse case where vanishes on . AC enters the statement through [F1] and is used only through the suppliers that assume it, namely [F5], [F6], [F8], [F20], [F23] and [F24], each cited at the step that uses it; the affine chart, its presentation, the polynomial and the point are single given objects, so no further selection is made and [F13], [F15], [F16] and [F18] are choice-free.
Source qualification
Milne, Algebraic Geometry v6.10, Exercise 4-2 (printed pp. 98-99; PDF pages 98-99) assumes irreducible and nonsingular on , and asks only that be nonsingular on each irreducible component of on which it lies, adding "you may assume" that each component has codimension one in ; the official solution (printed p. 222) argues from and the dimension inequality. The item above instead treats the scheme-theoretic intersection of an arbitrary closed subvariety with the hyperplane cut out by an affine-linear equation, allows a reducible , and proves the tangent identity by the fibre-product universal property and dual-number points. Regularity and the local dimension are taken from the locally standard smooth submersion criterion Submersion criterion for locally standard smooth morphisms, whose pointwise hypotheses suffice; the earlier scaffold planned to route them through The submersion criterion between smooth varieties, which assumes globally smooth varieties. The converse questions of the exercise -- an example with and singular on , and whether must be singular in that case -- are not asserted here; the affine-linear form, the characteristic and the ambient dimension are unrestricted.
Depends on
- Affine and projective n-space have dimension n
- Every algebra of finite type over a Noetherian ring is a Noetherian ring
- $M\otimes_RR/I\cong M/IM$ naturally
- Standard smooth presentations and locally standard smooth maps
- The Axiom of Choice
- The coordinate ring of a classical affine algebraic set
- Classical algebraic prevarieties, regular maps, and varieties
- Global and local dimension of classical varieties
- The affine scheme of dual numbers
- embedding dimension and regular local ring
- Fibre product of schemes
- Subalgebra generated by a subset, algebras of finite type, and module-finite algebras
- Locally finite type and finite type morphisms
- Locally Noetherian and Noetherian schemes
- Regular points of locally Noetherian schemes
- Scheme-theoretic fibre
- Smooth morphisms via local standard smooth presentations
- The classical affine local ring is localization at the point's maximal ideal
- Fibres of standard smooth algebras are regular of relative dimension
- Classical varieties have finite irreducible decompositions
- Finite type is affine-local on source and target
- Local dimension for a reducible classical algebraic set
- Intersections of subschemes
- Differentials, open restriction, and the chain rule
- Tangent vectors at rational points are dual-number points
- Affine fibre products are spectra of tensor products
- Affine schemes are contravariantly equivalent to commutative rings
- Base change and composition of standard smooth presentations
- Submersion criterion for locally standard smooth morphisms
- Existence of all scheme fibre products
- The stalk of the affine structure sheaf at a prime is A_p
- Universal property of a polynomial ring on an arbitrary family of indeterminates
Used by
Dependency tree · two levels
145 results within two dependency steps of this one, each drawn at its shortest distance from it. An arrow runs from a result to what uses it, so the chart reads left to right and ends at this result, which carries a heavier outline. Every node is a link to that result. Click elsewhere on the chart to enlarge it.
Sources
- J. S. Milne, Algebraic Geometry, v6.10, Exercise 4-2 (printed pp. 98-99) with its solution (printed p. 222) (standard reference, not scraped)