How statement and proof provenance work
The first chip identifies the source of the statement or construction; the second identifies the source of its local proof or verification.
- Literature-sourced: the exact statement appears in a cited source; only wording and notation differ.
- AI-adapted: a semantically identical restatement of literature-sourced material, modulo indexing, notation, and boundary cases adopted by the library.
- AI-generated: a genuinely novel statement formulated by AI, with no source for the claim itself.
These labels describe origin, not correctness: citations and verification chips remain separate evidence.
A compact test variation and gauge-source sign check
Worked computation in the smooth finite-region field action on a box: the explicit first variation of a constant-field potential vanishes with no boundary term, and the exact gauge difference of the action pins the relative sign between the source coupling, the gauge shift and source conservation, including a non-conserved source exhibiting both signs. Excluded: existence statements, numerical values of constants, and any global or empirical claim.
Example
SI numerical values. Throughout this example, a symbol for a physical quantity denotes its real numerical value in the following fixed SI unit: in m, in s, in m s, in N A, in F m, in T m, in T, in V m, in C m, in A m, the auxiliary gauge factors and gauge functions in T m, and in J s; are dimensionless. Precisely, if represents a quantity with unit , its physical field is , with the same rule componentwise and for constants. The box thus represents the physical coordinate box . All derivatives and integrals below are with respect to these numerical coordinates, so and . The coherent SI units make the numerical action formula exactly that of Smooth finite-region Maxwell action, compact variations and the fixed-endpoint particle functional, with ; the facts below use the same numerical representations of the cited quantity formulas.
Assume Countable Choice, inherited from the cited theorems. Work in the field-action setting of Smooth finite-region Maxwell action, compact variations and the fixed-endpoint particle functional with , constants , (Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values), and the component dictionary of The electromagnetic two-form, its observer decomposition and the four-current: , , .
(a) [Source-free zero field] For and the first-variation coefficient (whose integral is multiplied by ) of clause (a) of Compact variations of the quadratic field functional: first variation and the coefficient equation vanishes identically for every , because and ; hence every compact first variation of at is zero and is stationary.
(b) [A non-trivial compact test variation] Let be the smooth potential with and , and let . Then , , and all other components vanish, so the represented field is , (clause (a) of The electromagnetic two-form, its observer decomposition and the four-current) and on . In quantities this is and , in T m and V m, respectively. By the equivalence of Action stationarity implies the inhomogeneous Maxwell equations, is stationary; directly, for every the first variation of at is
where each of and vanishes by the fundamental theorem in one variable combined with Fubini, and no boundary term appears because is compactly supported in (Newton–Leibniz needs only continuity on , differentiability on , and a Riemann-integrable extension of the interior derivative, Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product, The Lebesgue integral is linear on ).
(c) [Gauge-source sign check with actual overlap] Independently choose the smooth prescribed source , , with nonzero nonnegative extended by zero. Choose with near , and nonzero nonnegative , supplied by Test function cutoffs and euclidean localization. Put and . Both are nonnegative compact bumps, but they are not globally monotone: on the entire support of their derivatives equal and , respectively. Use the contravariant gauge variations from Compact gauge variation is boundary-free for conserved source. Then, for every smooth potential on a neighbourhood of ,
which is strictly positive for and strictly negative for , since both factors are positive. Integration by parts gives exactly the same value as with . This verifies the relative sign of the coupling, the raised-vector/covariant-lowered gauge shift and the conservation condition, using explicitly overlapping supports. If instead is constant on the whole neighbourhood, the source is conserved and every compact gauge difference is zero. No compact nonzero globally increasing or decreasing function is used.
(d) [Scope] The example is an exact computation in the declared smooth finite-region model; it asserts no existence of sources or fields, no numerical value of , and no global gauge statement.
Facts & Assumptions
Given: The SI numerical-value convention above; Countable Choice; the field-action definition on the box with smooth on a neighbourhood of , constants , and the component dictionary; the linear potential of part (b); and the compactly supported data and gauge directions of part (c).
The field action is with , compactly supported smooth variations and the stationarity predicate (Smooth finite-region Maxwell action, compact variations and the fixed-endpoint particle functional).
The compact-variation lemma states that the first variation of its functional at in the direction is , and that is stationary if and only if on for every (Compact variations of the quadratic field functional: first variation and the coefficient equation).
The action-stationarity theorem states that, on the smooth class, stationarity of the field action under all compactly supported smooth variations is equivalent to on for every (Action stationarity implies the inhomogeneous Maxwell equations).
The gauge-source theorem states: the field term is gauge invariant and , with the equivalent distributional expression; for smooth sources, invariance under all compact gauge variations is equivalent to on (Compact gauge variation is boundary-free for conserved source (a)-(b)).
The component dictionary is , , , , with (The electromagnetic two-form, its observer decomposition and the four-current (a)).
The electric constant is (Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values).
The four-current convention is (Charge parameter, frame charge and current densities, volume charge and flux, and the four-current).
In ZF, for compact with open there is with and on a neighbourhood of (Test function cutoffs and euclidean localization).
If is continuous, differentiable on , and is a Riemann-integrable extension of from , then (Newton–Leibniz needs only continuity on , differentiability on , and a Riemann-integrable extension of the interior derivative).
Fubini's theorem for functions: the multiple integral equals the iterated integrals (Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product).
The Lebesgue integral is linear on (The Lebesgue integral is linear on ).
If are differentiable on with integrable derivatives, then (If are differentiable on with integrable, then ).
For nonnegative measurable , (Monotonicity and nonnegative homogeneity of the nonnegative integral).
Assume Countable Choice: if a continuous on an open satisfies for every ball compactly contained in , then on (Localization: vanishing integrals or fluxes force a continuous function to vanish).
Coordinate partial derivatives are the directional derivatives in the standard directions, and is the derivative in the direction (Directional derivatives and partial derivatives of a map ).
Countable Choice is the statement that every sequence of nonempty sets has a choice function (The Axiom of Countable Choice ()).
Under Countable Choice, a bounded Borel Riemann-integrable function on a nondegenerate closed box has the same Lebesgue integral (Riemann–Lebesgue comparison for distribution test integrands). In particular, each smooth compactly supported one-variable slice used below extends smoothly to and satisfies this comparison.
Closed bounded Euclidean sets are compact (Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line). A finite product of compact Euclidean sets is closed and bounded (its coordinate factors are), hence compact by that criterion.
Proof
With and one has by [F1], so the coefficient of [F2] vanishes identically on for every ; the first variation is times the integral of that coefficient by [F1], hence it is zero for every and is stationary. This is part (a).
For the potential , of part (b), [F15] gives and , so the dictionary [F5] yields ; raising indices with gives and , and all remaining components vanish because the other are constant; the inverse dictionary of [F5] then gives with and , so and on because every component of is constant and only the two nonzero components , occur, whose coordinate derivatives vanish.
For part (c), apply [F8] with and , with and , and with and ; this gives nonzero nonnegative , with near , and nonzero nonnegative , all extended by zero. Set and ; then is a nonnegative compactly supported smooth function with , which equals and respectively on a neighbourhood of and in particular on the whole support of .
With the equation of step 1.2 is exactly the coefficient equation of [F3], so [F3] gives that is stationary; directly, for every the first variation is by [F2] and step 1.2. Each of and vanishes: Fubini [F10] writes the first as the iterated integral whose inner integral is over a continuous compactly supported one-variable function, whose Lebesgue integral equals its Riemann integral by [F17] and is by the fundamental theorem [F9], and symmetrically for the second; hence the first variation is for every and the direct computation confirms stationarity with no boundary term. This is part (b).
For every smooth potential on a neighbourhood of , [F4] gives ; with the source , of step 1.3 and the convention [F7], the integrand is , whose support is a closed subset of , a compact subset of by [F18]; Fubini [F10] factors the integral as , the factors being finite Lebesgue integrals of continuous compactly supported functions; and since on by step 1.3, with , while : each positivity follows because the integrand is continuous, nonnegative and nonzero, so if the integral over the ambient open box vanished then monotonicity [F13] would give vanishing over every compactly contained ball and [F14] would force the integrand to vanish identically, a contradiction. Hence , strictly positive for and strictly negative for .
For the same data, the second form of [F4] gives ; here by [F7] and [F15], so the right-hand side is by Fubini [F10]; by [F17] the one-variable integrals equal their Riemann integrals, and integration by parts [F12] applied to and has vanishing endpoint terms because both are compactly supported, giving , which reproduces exactly the value of step 2.2. If instead is constant on the whole neighbourhood, then , and [F4] (b) gives for every compact gauge variation ; no globally monotone compact function occurs anywhere.
The computation used exact substitutions in the declared box functional, the one-variable fundamental theorem for compactly supported functions and the factoring of the four-dimensional integral by Fubini; it used no existence of sources or fields, no numerical value of , no global gauge statement and no globally monotone compact function. All integrals are the finite-region Lebesgue integrals of the definition, and Countable Choice [F16] enters only through the inherited measure statements [F14] and the cited theorems; this is part (d).
Source notes
Tong §5.5.3 (printed pp. 125-126) discards the total derivative in the variation and computes the gauge shift ; the exact compact-support witnesses here replace that informal step, and the sign of the coupling is checked with overlapping supports rather than with a global monotone function. Binney §3.6 (printed pp. 30-31) records that the remaining Maxwell equations are geometric rather than variational; the direct variation computation of part (b) is the framework's own check in its dictionary.
Depends on
Smooth finite-region Maxwell action, compact variations and the fixed-endpoint particle functional
Compact variations of the quadratic field functional: first variation and the coefficient equation
Compact gauge variation is boundary-free for conserved source
Action stationarity implies the inhomogeneous Maxwell equations
The electromagnetic two-form, its observer decomposition and the four-current
Framework-local SI units, the vacuum constants and the exact/measured status of their values
Charge parameter, frame charge and current densities, volume charge and flux, and the four-current
Test function cutoffs and euclidean localization
Newton–Leibniz needs only continuity on , differentiability on , and a Riemann-integrable extension of the interior derivative
Fubini's theorem for L^1 functions on a sigma-finite product
The Lebesgue integral is linear on
If are differentiable on with integrable, then
Monotonicity and nonnegative homogeneity of the nonnegative integral
Localization: vanishing integrals or fluxes force a continuous function to vanish
Integral over a measurable subset
Directional derivatives and partial derivatives of a map
The Axiom of Countable Choice ()
Riemann–Lebesgue comparison for distribution test integrands
Heine-Borel in : with the Euclidean metric a subset of is compact if and only if it is closed and bounded, and the proof by bisection uses no choice principle; the same holds on the real line